muckrock icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
muckrock copied to clipboard

Option for org admins to have edit access to their orgs requests

Open mitchelljkotler opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

Request by 74 Projects:

Would there be any way to add this feature in particular in the UI where Admins can automatically edit requests of any user in the organization? Even if it would be paid, as long as it's reasonable, it would be a useful feature to have as sending links back and forth to be added as Editor gets confusing.

mitchelljkotler avatar Jul 29 '24 16:07 mitchelljkotler

Can we make sharing on MuckRock consistent with sharing on DocumentCloud?

Do we need an organization level of access?

Should all sharing go through projects rather than organizations?

What other sharing models should we look at?

How do we better share draft requests?

eyeseast avatar Jul 29 '24 17:07 eyeseast

Related permissions explanation document: https://www.notion.so/muckrock/User-organization-search-permissions-c310e46a7e7a4f7b9f35fc7b452831f5 (covers usernames and org names)

morisy avatar Oct 07 '24 17:10 morisy

@duckduckgrayduck will start new resource page that captures the service resource permissions (view, edit) across our services (eg. shared with org, public, private as view and edit options) so that we can continue to coalesce on some common understanding of resource sharing across our services.

@amandabee will review and add related links from other half started pages.

amandabee avatar Oct 07 '24 17:10 amandabee

This is the resource sharing permissions document that describes how different assets on MuckRock and DocumentCloud work with regard to sharing: https://www.notion.so/muckrock/Sharing-on-MuckRock-platforms-121f88926963803c93a1e0ce3f42c93f

duckduckgrayduck avatar Dec 16 '24 18:12 duckduckgrayduck

Michael is going to review:

https://www.notion.so/muckrock/Sharing-on-MuckRock-platforms-121f88926963803c93a1e0ce3f42c93f https://www.notion.so/muckrock/User-organization-search-permissions-c310e46a7e7a4f7b9f35fc7b452831f5

This probably needs more shaping into a clear set of feature requests.

morisy avatar Dec 16 '24 18:12 morisy

I'm also going to recommend that we close this issue as "will not fix" and re-open a new issue with the task of broadly aligning how sharing works across MuckRock's tools.

We are generally not going to give Admins blanket access to all user requests; we do want to identify a path forward that is consistent with DocumentCloud's working that gives people a way to collaborate on requests in an organized fashion.

amandabee avatar Dec 17 '24 00:12 amandabee