mostro icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
mostro copied to clipboard

Show Taker's reputation and usage time to Maker before continue with the trade

Open Catrya opened this issue 10 months ago • 8 comments

Mostro should provide the maker with the taker's reputation information and the number of days they have been using Mostro when sending or requesting an invoice. This will allow the maker to decide whether to accept the trade.

Catrya avatar Feb 24 '25 20:02 Catrya

@Catrya ,

just to recap what you would like to happen... When a user takell/takebuy an order, Mostrod will send a message to the maker sending user info as for solver message, so:

  • rating
  • days
  • reviews

In the case of taker with full privacy this infos should be removed.

Is this what you want?

arkanoider avatar Apr 01 '25 14:04 arkanoider

@Catrya ,

just to recap what you would like to happen... When a user takell/takebuy an order, Mostrod will send a message to the maker sending user info as for solver message, so:

  • rating
  • days
  • reviews

In the case of taker with full privacy this infos should be removed.

Is this what you want?

When a taker takes an order, after he fulfills his part and the order goes to waiting-buyer-invoice or waiting-payment, when Mostro sends the message to the maker of addinvoice or payinvoice, adding the taker's data of reputation, days using Mostro and trades, so that the maker decides if he wants to continue with that order.

Catrya avatar Apr 01 '25 15:04 Catrya

In the case of taker with full privacy this infos should be removed.

Regarding the taker being a user in privacy mode, I'm not sure if the ideal approach would be to not show that information, or to set everything to 0, as if they were a new user. I dont know if is good that the maker knows the taker is in privacy mode, (or in general that no one can distinguish if a user is in privacy mode, only the user himself) I think new users shouldn't be distinguished from those in privacy mode, but rather they should look the same.

I would like to know @grunch opinion

Catrya avatar Apr 01 '25 15:04 Catrya

In the case of taker with full privacy this infos should be removed.

Regarding the taker being a user in privacy mode, I'm not sure if the ideal approach would be to not show that information, or to set everything to 0, as if they were a new user. I dont know if is good that the maker knows the taker is in privacy mode, (or in general that no one can distinguish if a user is in privacy mode, only the user himself) I think new users shouldn't be distinguished from those in privacy mode, but rather they should look the same.

I would like to know @grunch opinion

good point! We can decide what to send to the maker, my two cents is maker will decide what to do when he sees a full privacy order and so decide what to do.

A more specific approach is letting maker decide previously to open to full privacy taker. I mean adding a boolean flag to neworder creating with the meaning this order accept also full privacy takers, so mostrod can refuse users trying to take that order with full privacy mode.

Let's wait for @grunch opinion?

arkanoider avatar Apr 01 '25 15:04 arkanoider

A more specific approach is letting maker decide previously to open to full privacy taker. I mean adding a boolean flag to neworder creating with the meaning this order accept also full privacy takers, so mostrod can refuse users trying to take that order with full privacy mode.

I think that for the moment anyone should be allowed to take any order, because if there are going to be few offers at the beginning, and a lot of doubts until users become familiar, limiting order taking can generate a bad UX and make users not understand why they cannot take an order and drive them away from Mostro.

imho I think it could be a good feature but for later.

Catrya avatar Apr 01 '25 16:04 Catrya

A more specific approach is letting maker decide previously to open to full privacy taker. I mean adding a boolean flag to neworder creating with the meaning this order accept also full privacy takers, so mostrod can refuse users trying to take that order with full privacy mode.

This sounds interesting but as @Catrya said, this can be implemented in the future, for now it is not a priority

grunch avatar Apr 01 '25 16:04 grunch

When a taker takes an order, after he fulfills his part and the order goes to waiting-buyer-invoice or waiting-payment, when Mostro sends the message to the maker of addinvoice or payinvoice, adding the taker's data of reputation, days using Mostro and trades, so that the maker decides if he wants to continue with that order.

Agree on this approach, for the counterpart is exactly the same a full privacy mode user or a new user, so let's show it as it is, 0, 0, 0

grunch avatar Apr 01 '25 16:04 grunch

When a taker takes an order, after he fulfills his part and the order goes to waiting-buyer-invoice or waiting-payment, when Mostro sends the message to the maker of addinvoice or payinvoice, adding the taker's data of reputation, days using Mostro and trades, so that the maker decides if he wants to continue with that order.

Agree on this approach, for the counterpart is exactly the same a full privacy mode user or a new user, so let's show it as it is, 0, 0, 0

will do like this.

arkanoider avatar Apr 01 '25 16:04 arkanoider

@Catrya this is closed with #479 right?

arkanoider avatar May 09 '25 07:05 arkanoider

@Catrya this is closed with #479 right?

yes, will close it. thanks!

Catrya avatar May 09 '25 16:05 Catrya