Heatmiser-for-home-assistant
Heatmiser-for-home-assistant copied to clipboard
MindrustUK
Questions about Floor Temperatures
At the conclusion of #72 I was seeing floor temperatures reported to one decimal place e.g. 14.8 C.
I'm still seeing them reported to one decimal place but only in whole numbers e.g. 25.0 C or 26.0 C.
Also I noticed that the temperatures being reported for Bathrooms that are in stand-by appear to be flat/constant.
Is this expected behaviour?
@PhillyGilly, regarding the decimal point issue, are you able to create some debug logs, then do a search for 'current_floor_temperature='?
Do you see any temperatures that display the decimal value (ignore any with a value of 127.5)? If not, then I believe that the issue lies with the neohub api.
Regarding the flat-line temperatures for the stats that are in stand-by mode, please can you check what is in the logs for 'current_floor_temperature' for a stat that is in both stand-by mode and active mode?
This is a neostat-E in standby "Bathroom 1": simple_attrs=('active_level', 'active_profile', 'available_modes', 'away', 'cool_on', 'cool_temp', 'current_floor_temperature', 'date', 'device_id', 'fan_control', 'fan_speed', 'floor_limit', 'hc_mode', 'heat_mode', 'heat_on', 'hold_cool', 'fan_control', 'fan_speed', 'hc_mode', 'heat_mode', 'heat_on', 'hold_cool', 'hold_off', 'hold_on', 'hold_temp', 'hold_time', 'holiday', 'lock', 'low_battery', 'manual_off', 'modelock', 'modulation_level', 'offline', 'pin_number', 'preheat_active', 'prg_temp', 'prg_timer', 'standby', 'switch_delay_left', 'temporary_set_flag', 'time', 'timer_on', 'window_open', 'write_count'), active_level=2, active_profile=5, available_modes=['heat'], away=False, cool_on=False, cool_temp=0, current_floor_temperature=127.5, date='friday', device_id=6, fan_control='Automatic', fan_speed='Off', floor_limit='Bedroom 1', hc_mode='VENT', heat_mode=True, heat_on=True, hold_cool=0, hold_off=True, hold_on=False, hold_temp=16, hold_time=datetime.timedelta(0), holiday=False, lock=False, low_battery=False, manual_off=True, modelock=False, modulation_level=0, offline=False, pin_number=0, preheat_active=0, prg_temp=0, prg_timer=False, standby=False, switch_delay_left=datetime.timedelta(0), temporary_set_flag=False, time=datetime.timedelta(seconds=52800), timer_on=False, window_open=False, write_count=0, name='Bedroom 1', target_temperature='19.0', temperature='16.8', weekday=<Weekday.FRIDAY: 'friday'>), NeoStat(_logger=<HassLogger neohub (CRITICAL)>, data=namespace(ACTIVE_LEVEL=2, ACTIVE_PROFILE=4, ACTUAL_TEMP='17.1', AVAILABLE_MODES=['heat'], AWAY=False, COOL_MODE=False, COOL_ON=False, COOL_TEMP=0, CURRENT_FLOOR_TEMPERATURE=14, DATE='friday', DEVICE_ID=7, FAN_CONTROL='Automatic', FAN_SPEED='Off', FLOOR_LIMIT=False, HC_MODE='VENT', HEAT_MODE=True, HEAT_ON=False, HOLD_COOL=0, HOLD_OFF=True, HOLD_ON=False, HOLD_TEMP=21, HOLD_TIME='0:00', HOLIDAY=False, LOCK=False, LOW_BATTERY=False, MANUAL_OFF=True, MODELOCK=False, MODULATION_LEVEL=0, OFFLINE=False, PIN_NUMBER='0000', PREHEAT_ACTIVE=False, PRG_TEMP=0, PRG_TIMER=False, RECENT_TEMPS=['16.4', '16.2', '16.2', '16.2', '16.2', '16.2', '16.3', '16.3', '16.3', '16.4', '16.4', '16.4', '16.4', '16.4', '16.4', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.6', '16.6', '16.6', '16.6', '16.6', '16.7', '16.7', '16.8', '16.7', '16.7', '16.7', '16.8', '16.7', '16.7', '16.7', '16.7', '16.6', '16.6', '16.6', '16.5', '16.5', '16.4', '16.4', '16.3', '16.3', '16.2', '16.2', '16.2', '16.1', '16.0', '16.0', '15.9', '15.9', '15.9', '15.8', '15.8', '15.7', '15.7', '15.6', '15.6', '15.5', '15.5', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.5', '15.5', '15.6', '15.7', '15.8', '15.9', '16.0', '16.1', '16.2', '16.3', '16.3', '16.3', '16.4', '16.5', '16.5', '16.5', '16.6', '16.7', '16.7', '16.8', '16.8', '16.9', '16.9', '17.0', '17.0', '17.1', '17.1'], RELATIVE_HUMIDITY=0, SET_TEMP='12.0', STANDBY=True, SWITCH_DELAY_LEFT='0:00', TEMPORARY_SET_FLAG=False, THERMOSTAT=True, TIME='14:40', TIMER_ON=False, WINDOW_OPEN=False, WRITE_COUNT=48, ZONE_NAME='Bathroom 1'), This is a neostat-E that is active "Bathroom-3" _simple_attrs=('active_level', 'active_profile', 'available_modes', 'away', 'cool_on', 'cool_temp', 'current_floor_temperature', 'date', 'device_id', 'fan_control', 'fan_speed', 'floor_limit', 'hc_mode', 'heat_mode', 'heat_on', 'hold_cool', 'fan_control', 'fan_speed', 'hc_mode', 'heat_mode', 'heat_on', 'hold_cool', 'hold_off', 'hold_on', 'hold_temp', 'hold_time', 'holiday', 'lock', 'low_battery', 'manual_off', 'modelock', 'modulation_level', 'offline', 'pin_number', 'preheat_active', 'prg_temp', 'prg_timer', 'standby', 'switch_delay_left', 'temporary_set_flag', 'time', 'timer_on', 'window_open', 'write_count'), active_level=2, active_profile=5, available_modes=['heat'], away=False, cool_on=False, cool_temp=0, current_floor_temperature=127.5, date='friday', device_id=10, fan_control='Automatic', fan_speed='Off', floor_limit='Bedroom 2', hc_mode='VENT', heat_mode=True, heat_on=True, hold_cool=0, hold_off=True, hold_on=False, hold_temp=19, hold_time=datetime.timedelta(0), holiday=False, lock=False, low_battery=False, manual_off=True, modelock=False, modulation_level=0, offline=False, pin_number=0, preheat_active=0, prg_temp=0, prg_timer=False, standby=False, switch_delay_left=datetime.timedelta(0), temporary_set_flag=False, time=datetime.timedelta(seconds=52860), timer_on=False, window_open=False, write_count=0, name='Bedroom 2', target_temperature='19.0', temperature='17.9', weekday=<Weekday.FRIDAY: 'friday'>), NeoStat(_logger=<HassLogger neohub (CRITICAL)>, data=namespace(ACTIVE_LEVEL=2, ACTIVE_PROFILE=4, ACTUAL_TEMP='17.1', AVAILABLE_MODES=['heat'], AWAY=False, COOL_MODE=False, COOL_ON=False, COOL_TEMP=0, CURRENT_FLOOR_TEMPERATURE=22, DATE='friday', DEVICE_ID=11, FAN_CONTROL='Automatic', FAN_SPEED='Off', FLOOR_LIMIT=False, HC_MODE='VENT', HEAT_MODE=True, HEAT_ON=False, HOLD_COOL=0, HOLD_OFF=True, HOLD_ON=False, HOLD_TEMP=16, HOLD_TIME='0:00', HOLIDAY=False, LOCK=False, LOW_BATTERY=False, MANUAL_OFF=True, MODELOCK=False, MODULATION_LEVEL=0, OFFLINE=False, PIN_NUMBER='0000', PREHEAT_ACTIVE=False, PRG_TEMP=0, PRG_TIMER=False, RECENT_TEMPS=['14.9', '15.0', '15.1', '15.2', '15.1', '15.1', '15.2', '15.3', '15.3', '15.4', '15.3', '15.4', '15.3', '15.3', '15.3', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.5', '15.5', '15.6', '15.8', '15.9', '15.9', '15.7', '15.7', '15.8', '15.9', '15.9', '15.9', '15.8', '15.8', '15.8', '16.0', '16.0', '15.8', '15.7', '15.6', '15.5', '15.5', '15.4', '15.4', '15.3', '15.2', '15.2', '15.1', '15.0', '14.9', '14.9', '14.8', '14.7', '14.7', '14.6', '14.6', '14.5', '14.4', '14.3', '14.3', '14.2', '14.2', '14.2', '14.1', '14.1', '14.2', '14.2', '14.2', '14.3', '14.3', '14.4', '14.7', '14.8', '14.8', '14.5', '14.4', '14.2', '14.3', '14.4', '15.1', '15.6', '16.2', '16.7', '16.8', '17.2', '17.4', '17.6', '17.9', '17.8', '17.7', '17.5', '17.4', '17.3', '17.2', '17.1'], RELATIVE_HUMIDITY=0, SET_TEMP='17.0', STANDBY=False, SWITCH_DELAY_LEFT='0:00', TEMPORARY_SET_FLAG=False, THERMOSTAT=True, TIME='14:41', TIMER_ON=False, WINDOW_OPEN=False, WRITE_COUNT=24, ZONE_NAME='Bathroom 3'), Finally here is Bathroom 3 in stand-by: _hub=<neohubapi.neohub.NeoHub object at 0x7f71eb5eb0>, _simple_attrs=('active_level', 'active_profile', 'available_modes', 'away', 'cool_on', 'cool_temp', 'current_floor_temperature', 'date', 'device_id', 'fan_control', 'fan_speed', 'floor_limit', 'hc_mode', 'heat_mode', 'heat_on', 'hold_cool', 'fan_control', 'fan_speed', 'hc_mode', 'heat_mode', 'heat_on', 'hold_cool', 'hold_off', 'hold_on', 'hold_temp', 'hold_time', 'holiday', 'lock', 'low_battery', 'manual_off', 'modelock', 'modulation_level', 'offline', 'pin_number', 'preheat_active', 'prg_temp', 'prg_timer', 'standby', 'switch_delay_left', 'temporary_set_flag', 'time', 'timer_on', 'window_open', 'write_count'), active_level=2, active_profile=5, available_modes=['heat'], away=False, cool_on=False, cool_temp=0, current_floor_temperature=127.5, date='friday', device_id=10, fan_control='Automatic', fan_speed='Off', floor_limit='Bedroom 2', hc_mode='VENT', heat_mode=True, heat_on=True, hold_cool=0, hold_off=True, hold_on=False, hold_temp=19, hold_time=datetime.timedelta(0), holiday=False, lock=False, low_battery=False, manual_off=True, modelock=False, modulation_level=0, offline=False, pin_number=0, preheat_active=0, prg_temp=0, prg_timer=False, standby=False, switch_delay_left=datetime.timedelta(0), temporary_set_flag=False, time=datetime.timedelta(seconds=53580), timer_on=False, window_open=False, write_count=0, name='Bedroom 2', target_temperature='19.0', temperature='17.9', weekday=<Weekday.FRIDAY: 'friday'>), NeoStat(_logger=<HassLogger neohub (CRITICAL)>, data=namespace(ACTIVE_LEVEL=2, ACTIVE_PROFILE=4, ACTUAL_TEMP='17.0', AVAILABLE_MODES=['heat'], AWAY=False, COOL_MODE=False, COOL_ON=False, COOL_TEMP=0, CURRENT_FLOOR_TEMPERATURE=22, DATE='friday', DEVICE_ID=11, FAN_CONTROL='Automatic', FAN_SPEED='Off', FLOOR_LIMIT=False, HC_MODE='VENT', HEAT_MODE=True, HEAT_ON=False, HOLD_COOL=0, HOLD_OFF=True, HOLD_ON=False, HOLD_TEMP=16, HOLD_TIME='0:00', HOLIDAY=False, LOCK=False, LOW_BATTERY=False, MANUAL_OFF=True, MODELOCK=False, MODULATION_LEVEL=0, OFFLINE=False, PIN_NUMBER='0000', PREHEAT_ACTIVE=False, PRG_TEMP=0, PRG_TIMER=False, RECENT_TEMPS=['15.0', '15.1', '15.2', '15.1', '15.1', '15.2', '15.3', '15.3', '15.4', '15.3', '15.4', '15.3', '15.3', '15.3', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.4', '15.5', '15.5', '15.6', '15.8', '15.9', '15.9', '15.7', '15.7', '15.8', '15.9', '15.9', '15.9', '15.8', '15.8', '15.8', '16.0', '16.0', '15.8', '15.7', '15.6', '15.5', '15.5', '15.4', '15.4', '15.3', '15.2', '15.2', '15.1', '15.0', '14.9', '14.9', '14.8', '14.7', '14.7', '14.6', '14.6', '14.5', '14.4', '14.3', '14.3', '14.2', '14.2', '14.2', '14.1', '14.1', '14.2', '14.2', '14.2', '14.3', '14.3', '14.4', '14.7', '14.8', '14.8', '14.5', '14.4', '14.2', '14.3', '14.4', '15.1', '15.6', '16.2', '16.7', '16.8', '17.2', '17.4', '17.6', '17.9', '17.8', '17.7', '17.5', '17.4', '17.3', '17.2', '17.1', '17.0'], RELATIVE_HUMIDITY=0, SET_TEMP='12.0', STANDBY=True, SWITCH_DELAY_LEFT='0:00', TEMPORARY_SET_FLAG=False, THERMOSTAT=True, TIME='14:57', TIMER_ON=False, WINDOW_OPEN=False, WRITE_COUNT=25, ZONE_NAME='Bathroom 3'),
Thanks. I can see that the floor temperature doesn't appear to be related to the stand-by status. For Bathroom 3, this shows as 22 for both stand-by and active modes. I'm not sure why Bathroom 1 would show a static value of 14 (in stand-by mode); does this report a different value in the heatmiser app?
Bathroom 1 is cold if there is no heating!
What made me suspicious is that it is constant when I would expect it to get colder at night and then warmer in the day. However this trace shows it is moving (maybe its reached rock bottom?) but I suppose the changes maybe less than 1C so won't be observable in day without better granularity.
Yeah, I'm inclined to agree with you that it's probably hovering around 14C, and given a 1C granularity you can't see any fluctuations. So, no 'flatline' issue then?
Agreed no flat-line. If we can get the granularity it should show it's not flat despite appearances.
CURRENT_FLOOR_TEMPERATURE always appears to be an integer, not sure why. I'd suggest raising it with Heatmiser as an API bug as I would think it should be reported as a float.
