MbinOrg
Replacing @user with full name in microblog posts may alter meaning
Describe the bug
In microblog posts, Mbin displays @user as the full name of the user referred to. In some cases, if the author of a post intended the reference to be read as @user, this can change or obscure the post's intended meaning.
On which Mbin instance did you find the bug?
fedia.io
Which Mbin version was running on the instance?
1.8.0
To Reproduce
- View the post at https://fedia.io/m/[email protected]/p/1596322/My-hotel-at-tea-at-a-gup-pe-expectations-are-risen-to-new-altitudes-it
- View the same post on its original instance at https://vis.social/@baptnz/114052272846894756
- Observe that
@teain the original post has been replaced withtea groupin the mbin version. - Observe that this change alters the meaning of the sentence it occurs in.
Expected behavior
When viewed on mbin, the post should have the same meaning as it does when viewed on its original instance.
Screenshots
Mbin version:
Original version:
Desktop (please complete the following information):
- OS: Debian
- Browser: Firefox
- Browser Version: 135.0b7
tea group is the display-name of the account mentioned... Would it be enough if it was converted to @tea group?
The author of the post clearly intended for it to be displayed as @tea, and that is in fact how it's displayed on the original instance. Ideally it would be displayed as @tea on Mbin as well.
I would not say that The author of the post clearly intended for it to be displayed as @tea its just how a mention is looking on Mastodon...
The mention @tea is used in the post as a substitute for the word "tea." When the author talks about his "@tea expectations," he is clearly talking about his expectations for tea, the beverage, not for @tea, the gup.pe group.
You're absolutely right, I am sorry. It seems like I didn't properly read the post...
However platforms do render things differently and that was my main point. I myself am unsure whether I like the inline previews/components for user and magazine mentions in the rendered markdown... I thought it was a very cool idea and I think with magazine mentions it can look very good, but with microblog mentions, especially in busy comment sections, it can be very distracting...
Maybe it is time for another poll @melroy89 ? :D
I created a discussion thread in the mbinMeta magazine: https://gehirneimer.de/m/mbinmeta/t/516855/Discussion-Magazine-And-User-Mention-Rendering
You're absolutely right, I am sorry. It seems like I didn't properly read the post...
However platforms do render things differently and that was my main point. I myself am unsure whether I like the inline previews/components for user and magazine mentions in the rendered markdown... I thought it was a very cool idea and I think with magazine mentions it can look very good, but with microblog mentions, especially in busy comment sections, it can be very distracting...
Maybe it is time for another poll @melroy89 ? :D
Less is more 😅. So I'm also fine for disabling this inline markdown preview in microblog all together if that solves the problem again.
