MassBank-data icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MassBank-data copied to clipboard

JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt contact wanted

Open meier-rene opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

Dear all, after implementing an automatic test to check for problems similar to #13 i found a problem with JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt The peak list might contain two different spectra.

PK$PEAK: m/z int. rel.int.
  14.10826 36475 13
  15.09583 222688 81
  26.10593 73559 27
  27.11639 449105 163
  28.11312 374331 136
  29.13347 788534 286
  29.80832 47011 17
  30.12487 59097 21
  38.12244 31758 12
  39.13071 316878 115
  40.12874 84849 31
  41.14179 616729 224
  42.13915 415303 151
  43.1387 708455 257
  44.14659 172260 63
  45.08199 202944 74
  46.0992 77463 28
  47.10616 159675 58
  53.11076 111360 40
  54.13147 37750 14
  55.14271 199477 72
  56.13508 95786 35
  57.17133 494598 180
  58.15374 126469 46
  59.12688 177267 64
  67.13793 60353 22
  68.13357 792919 288
  69.15435 126760 46
  70.14899 84057 31
  71.17394 238975 87
  72.14914 30018 11
  73.25028 69003 25
  74.11656 271765 99
  83.17146 123791 45
  85.10854 174341 63
  91.13495 34416 12
  93.12413 60088 22
  95.15051 40090 15
  96.16142 183119 66
  97.18768 36897 13
  99.11687 79397 29
  105.66012 30252 11
  110.13925 82023 30
  111.16113 52938 19
  113.15047 55551 20
  113.67169 175718 64
  116.12024 66879 24
  123.15651 56371 20
  127.08559 60564 22
  136.15661 36760 13
  138.14722 298408 108
  139.15477 141469 51
  140.13857 35555 13
  142.10486 66036 24
  143.10454 32046 12
  143.73454 31880 12
  144.13416 35561 13
  155.11388 52262 19
  156.11776 46508 17
  157.10419 77936 28
  158.10339 42136 15
  166.17478 32350 12
  170.10137 271991 99
  171.10492 79761 29
  180.17858 45502 17
  184.11898 161572 59
  185.12064 285129 104
  186.11901 2751962 999
  195.1689 202761 74
  198.09722 94862 34
  200.03948 47050 17
  210.11173 60566 22
  212.08434 73157 27
  224.08631 45595 17
  226.07326 619225 225
  227.09087 87787 32              <-last line of first spectra
  129.02778 18900 7                <-first line of second spectra
  130.11347 42343 15
  136.1427 26075 9
  137.10019 25130 9
  138.11953 677826 246
  139.12352 80523 29
  140.11027 61803 22
  141.08029 95339 35
  142.08115 73738 27
  144.09759 159144 58
  149.20379 26721 10
  150.03273 24138 9
  152.1384 108578 39
  153.02915 38416 14
  154.01107 18706 7
  155.08419 422515 153
  156.11311 78871 29
  157.07738 86180 31
  164.15452 56191 20
  165.102 19225 7
  166.13771 231682 84
  167.14993 933539 339
  168.13903 29477 11
  169.04063 34261 12
  170.06958 564067 205
  171.04781 136229 49
  179.9786 14559 5
  182.03469 57553 21
  183.02114 26768 10
  184.0618 224532 82
  185.06897 394963 143
  186.03256 113767 41
  189.03165 18790 7
  196.06806 44105 16
  198.04149 1279391 464
  199.05639 342464 124
//

If I compare this peak list with JEOL_Ltd/JEL00033.txt I find essentially the first spectra (one peak is missing). That's why i suppose that this error is a copy&paste artifact and only the second spectra is valid for JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt. Is there any way to contact the owner of this records?

meier-rene avatar Jan 29 '19 14:01 meier-rene

Dear Rene,

I uploaded the data JEL record to MassBank.jp. I asked the contributor of JEOL Ltd whether they permit us to correct the data.

Takaaki


差出人: Rene Meier [email protected] 送信日時: 2019年1月29日 23:20 宛先: MassBank/MassBank-data CC: Subscribed 件名: [MassBank/MassBank-data] JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt contact wanted (#45)

Dear all, after implementing an automatic test to check for problems similar to #13https://github.com/MassBank/MassBank-data/issues/13 i found a problem with JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt https://massbank.eu/MassBank/RecordDisplay.jsp?id=JEL00034&dsn=JEOL_Ltd The peak list might contain two different spectra.

PK$PEAK: m/z int. rel.int. 14.10826 36475 13 15.09583 222688 81 26.10593 73559 27 27.11639 449105 163 28.11312 374331 136 29.13347 788534 286 29.80832 47011 17 30.12487 59097 21 38.12244 31758 12 39.13071 316878 115 40.12874 84849 31 41.14179 616729 224 42.13915 415303 151 43.1387 708455 257 44.14659 172260 63 45.08199 202944 74 46.0992 77463 28 47.10616 159675 58 53.11076 111360 40 54.13147 37750 14 55.14271 199477 72 56.13508 95786 35 57.17133 494598 180 58.15374 126469 46 59.12688 177267 64 67.13793 60353 22 68.13357 792919 288 69.15435 126760 46 70.14899 84057 31 71.17394 238975 87 72.14914 30018 11 73.25028 69003 25 74.11656 271765 99 83.17146 123791 45 85.10854 174341 63 91.13495 34416 12 93.12413 60088 22 95.15051 40090 15 96.16142 183119 66 97.18768 36897 13 99.11687 79397 29 105.66012 30252 11 110.13925 82023 30 111.16113 52938 19 113.15047 55551 20 113.67169 175718 64 116.12024 66879 24 123.15651 56371 20 127.08559 60564 22 136.15661 36760 13 138.14722 298408 108 139.15477 141469 51 140.13857 35555 13 142.10486 66036 24 143.10454 32046 12 143.73454 31880 12 144.13416 35561 13 155.11388 52262 19 156.11776 46508 17 157.10419 77936 28 158.10339 42136 15 166.17478 32350 12 170.10137 271991 99 171.10492 79761 29 180.17858 45502 17 184.11898 161572 59 185.12064 285129 104 186.11901 2751962 999 195.1689 202761 74 198.09722 94862 34 200.03948 47050 17 210.11173 60566 22 212.08434 73157 27 224.08631 45595 17 226.07326 619225 225 227.09087 87787 32 <-last line of first spectra 129.02778 18900 7 <-first line of second spectra 130.11347 42343 15 136.1427 26075 9 137.10019 25130 9 138.11953 677826 246 139.12352 80523 29 140.11027 61803 22 141.08029 95339 35 142.08115 73738 27 144.09759 159144 58 149.20379 26721 10 150.03273 24138 9 152.1384 108578 39 153.02915 38416 14 154.01107 18706 7 155.08419 422515 153 156.11311 78871 29 157.07738 86180 31 164.15452 56191 20 165.102 19225 7 166.13771 231682 84 167.14993 933539 339 168.13903 29477 11 169.04063 34261 12 170.06958 564067 205 171.04781 136229 49 179.9786 14559 5 182.03469 57553 21 183.02114 26768 10 184.0618 224532 82 185.06897 394963 143 186.03256 113767 41 189.03165 18790 7 196.06806 44105 16 198.04149 1279391 464 199.05639 342464 124 //

If I compare this peak list with JEOL_Ltd/JEL00033.txt https://massbank.eu/MassBank/RecordDisplay.jsp?id=JEL00033&dsn=JEOL_Ltd I find essentially the first spectra (one peak is missing). That's why i suppose that this error is a copy&paste artifact and only the second spectra is valid for JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt. Is there any way to contact the owner of this records?

You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/MassBank/MassBank-data/issues/45, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AQeon65shNFd6i4CAQmFgppi8E2fsd0tks5vIFiegaJpZM4aYJZS.

takaakin avatar Jan 30 '19 02:01 takaakin

Has there been any progress on this issue?

meier-rene avatar Apr 29 '19 10:04 meier-rene

Hi, Rene-san. I am responsible for the record. I transfered the mail to Dr. Takaya Sata, JEOL, Japan, because he is responcible the error on January 31, 2019. He wrote me that he need more time to confirm the error. I will write you when I get some responce from him. Sincerely yours, Takaaki Nishioka


差出人: Rene Meier [email protected] 送信日時: 2019年4月29日 19:28 宛先: MassBank/MassBank-data CC: [email protected]; Comment 件名: Re: [MassBank/MassBank-data] JEOL_Ltd/JEL00034.txt contact wanted (#45)

Has there been any progress on this issue?

You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/MassBank/MassBank-data/issues/45#issuecomment-487530000, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AED2RHYLUUJABCDH2YDKUZDPS3EUXANCNFSM4GTASZJA.

takaakin avatar Apr 29 '19 13:04 takaakin