Misplaced yticks when mirroring inside ticks and linking yaxes

[kimauth]

When using inside mirrored yticks, the right spines ticks seem not to be adjusted correctly upon changes to the yaxis.

set_theme!(Theme(
    Axis = (
        xticksmirrored = true,
        yticksmirrored = true,
        xtickalign = 1,
        ytickalign = 1,
    ),
))

f = Figure()
ax_t = Axis(f[1,1])
lines!(ax_t, rand(10))
ax_n = Axis(f[1,2])
lines!(ax_n, rand(10))

# linkyaxes!(ax_n, ax_t)
colgap!(f.layout, 12.)
linkyaxes!(ax_n, ax_t)

When swapping the linkyaxes! and colgap! commands, the ticks end up in a different position, but still not really correct:

This is on Makie v0.17.13.

[kimauth]

Here is another example of this, without linking axes this time. It's an example from the docs, I only added the yticksmirrored option.

using CairoMakie
using DelimitedFiles

volcano = readdlm(Makie.assetpath("volcano.csv"), ',', Float64)

f = Figure()
Axis(f[1, 1]; yticksmirrored=true)

co = contourf!(volcano, levels = 10)

Colorbar(f[1, 2], co)

f

[jkrumbiegel]

Yes good catch, there were some edits to observable updates with ticks a while ago, those must have broken whatever the mirroring uses. Or the mirroring itself was buggy from the start and just not visible in my specific tests.

[adityanprasad]

I have the same problem, except in addition to being misaligned, my mirrored inner-ticks also end up on the outside. This is without linking any axes.

	X = rand(100) .+ 100
	
	f = Figure()
	axisargs = (
			xticksmirrored=true,
			yticksmirrored=true,
			xtickalign=1,
			ytickalign=1, 
	)
	
	scatter(f[1,1], X, axis=(;axisargs...,))
	scatter(f[1,2], X .* 10, axis=(;axisargs...,),)
	scatter(f[2,1], X, axis=(;axisargs...,))
	scatter(f[2,2], X .* 10, axis=(;axisargs...,),)

Weirdly enough, this only seems to affect the plot at GridPosition[1,1] if it is created first. If I switch the order of construction, Makie seems to fix itself.

	X = rand(100) .+ 100
	
	f = Figure()
	axisargs = (
			xticksmirrored=true,
			yticksmirrored=true,
			xtickalign=1,
			ytickalign=1, 
	)
	
	scatter(f[1,2], X .* 10, axis=(;axisargs...,))
	scatter(f[1,1], X, axis=(;axisargs...,),)
	scatter(f[2,1], X, axis=(;axisargs...,))
	scatter(f[2,2], X .* 10, axis=(;axisargs...,),)

Btw, would it be possible to rename xticksmirrored to xtickmirrored (i.e. singular instead of plural). xticksmirrored and xminorticksmirrored are the only attributes that are plural: compare this to xtickalign, xtickcolor xtickformat etc. The only exception seems to be xticks, which you could justify because of common usage and the fact that it expects a range of values.

I am using Julia Version 1.8.0-rc3 on an M1 Mac and GLMakie v0.6.13

[egavazzi]

Soooo, I stumbled over that issue today as I had a similar problem with mirroring ticks... until I found out I was using an old version of Makie (v0.20.3). Everything works fine (including all examples here) under the latest version (v0.20.7), so some recent change fixed it 🥳

[jkrumbiegel]

was fixed in https://github.com/MakieOrg/Makie.jl/pull/3581