physionet-build icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
physionet-build copied to clipboard

Editor/Reviewer identity not properly anonymized

Open lilehman opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

Please anonymize the identity of the editor assigned to review projects. Instead, please provide [email protected] as a contact.

lilehman avatar Oct 18 '23 20:10 lilehman

The name is displayed in the submission history template for active projects, e.g.:

Screenshot 2023-12-02 at 2 54 21 PM

The code that needs editing is:

https://github.com/MIT-LCP/physionet-build/blob/54e57709490bb12a4b31e205a0f72cc03c469045/physionet-django/project/templates/project/active_submission_timeline.html#L190-L197

tompollard avatar Dec 02 '23 19:12 tompollard

Hiding name of the editor makes sense. But I think it would be better to have a different contact address for each project.

  • Ideally I'd want discussions to be archived and attached to the project - ideally visible on the site even if people prefer email as a medium.

  • We may want to have "guest editors" who wouldn't want (and shouldn't) receive communications about all submitted projects, and on the other hand it would be awkward for somebody to have to read editor@ and manually redirect messages to the appropriate person.

One idea would be to say:

To contact the editor, email <[email protected]>.

At present, this would do exactly the same as writing to [email protected]. But in the future it would be possible for us to archive such messages and/or send them to the appropriate people.

bemoody avatar Jan 04 '24 19:01 bemoody