UserGuide icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
UserGuide copied to clipboard

License for the user guide

Open IAlibay opened this issue 4 years ago • 6 comments

So I might not be looking at the right place, but as far as I can tell the user guide doesn't directly declare any type of license.

I guess the assumption is that it inherits MDA's GPLv2 license?

Given that the user guide is a really good teaching resource, I think it might be good to make it clear as to what the license is so that folks can be more confident in using parts of it in derivative works where possible.

IAlibay avatar Feb 10 '21 17:02 IAlibay

Given that it is more text than code, is it worth thinking about a CC license as well?

RMeli avatar Feb 18 '21 09:02 RMeli

I think a CC license would be the most appropriate. However, the user guide is backed quite a bit by docstring and those have been contributed under GPL. That may be an issue.

jbarnoud avatar Feb 18 '21 09:02 jbarnoud

Ideally a CC-BY4 license would be most appropriate, but I agree with @jbarnoud if anything in the userguide is taken out of the docs verbatum we'd probably have to adhere to GPL. @lilyminium might have a better view of things here, but maybe it's one of those we should be asking the numfocus folks?

IAlibay avatar Feb 18 '21 10:02 IAlibay

I was thinking more about a dual license model that I've seen multiple times in this scenario: CC for text and GPL for code? CC-BY-SA is reasonably aligned with GPL (I think).

Of course if you have access to NumFocus advice, they will probably know already how to handle this.

RMeli avatar Feb 18 '21 10:02 RMeli

I was thinking more about a dual license model that I've seen multiple times in this scenario: CC for text and GPL for code? CC-BY-SA is reasonably aligned with GPL (I think).

If we can do that then that sounds like the best solution to me

lilyminium avatar Feb 18 '21 10:02 lilyminium

Sounds good.

hmacdope avatar Feb 11 '24 22:02 hmacdope