lemmy-ui icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lemmy-ui copied to clipboard

Add "slow mode" without live updates

Open Nutomic opened this issue 4 years ago • 11 comments

In this mode, Lemmy would not insert new posts, comments or votes directly into the page, but just show an "update" button which inserts all the new items once clicked.

Mastodon has something similar:

Screenshot_20210120_024000

Screenshot_20210120_023906

Nutomic avatar Jan 20 '21 01:01 Nutomic

I'm thinking this will be an account setting, and basically just disable websockets, so all new info requires a page refresh.

dessalines avatar Jan 20 '21 14:01 dessalines

Actually I just noticed a related "bug". When the auto update happens and you are just composing a reply, then that draft gets lost, which is a quite serious flaw from a usability point of view.

poVoq avatar Jan 21 '21 16:01 poVoq

Can you replicate this? I've solved this a few times but people still say its happening.

dessalines avatar Jan 21 '21 18:01 dessalines

Not really, but I guess it happens when the update comes shortly after you start writing? I was about one sentence into a new reply on the main thread (not a comment reply) when someone replied to one of my previous comments and the auto-update caused the wipe of the draft.

poVoq avatar Jan 21 '21 19:01 poVoq

I just tried to mess around with this on https://enterprise.lemmy.ml by making two users, and having them open in different firefox containers. Comment replies, edits, deletes, don't seem to wipe the other users fields.

dessalines avatar Jan 21 '21 20:01 dessalines

I just tried to mess around with this on https://enterprise.lemmy.ml by making two users, and having them open in different firefox containers. Comment replies, edits, deletes, don't seem to wipe the other users fields.

I had it happen to me while composing a top-level comment and another comment was made (I don't remember if it was a reply or top-level comment).

In any case, I consider the live updates disruptive and jarring, so I'd appreciate an option to turn it off.

lboklin avatar Feb 04 '21 07:02 lboklin

#169 may make this moot.

dessalines avatar Feb 08 '21 04:02 dessalines

I don't think it does, because the purpose of slow mode is to prevent any rearranging or new things popping in, while with #169 new comments will still appear.

lboklin avatar Feb 08 '21 07:02 lboklin

By the way, this still happens in the web ui.

slash-zero avatar Jun 13 '23 02:06 slash-zero

I think this will become a major issue. Having the page shift around while trying to read content, write content or clicking links really hampers the user experience.

maxh- avatar Jun 13 '23 10:06 maxh-

+1 You're looking at the front page and then boom some random new post pops up and you're like wtf I just lost my place. I understand sorting by new and something comes in but not Hot or Active

jbjoeB avatar Jun 13 '23 16:06 jbjoeB

Please bump this, I’ve been trying to find a setting to disable the live inserts of new stories in All, I can never read a post before it vanishes!

fenn1c avatar Jun 13 '23 21:06 fenn1c

This will be fixed soon in 0.18

Nutomic avatar Jun 13 '23 21:06 Nutomic

honestly I just think live updates should be disabled for now, they add load to the servers which we don't need right now, and they're a bit buggy

Die4Ever avatar Jun 13 '23 23:06 Die4Ever

Not relevant as the next release removes live updates.

dessalines avatar Jun 13 '23 23:06 dessalines