laverna
laverna copied to clipboard
Laverna
Feature Request: WebDAV for storage
This is by far the sexiest self-hostable notes service. However, it's of little use to those of us that are trying to take our entire cloud private if it depends on Dropbox for permanent storage. Would it be possible to add support for WebDAV as a storage backend so that users of OwnCloud, Funambol, Pydio, etc. can use Laverna with our own backends?
@nakedhitman I agree that WebDAV support would be a nice option, however there is already the capability to self-host your storage using RemoteStorage. If you visit their webpage, they share the code for setting up a self-hosted server using a variety of different languages (node.js, C, PHP, Ruby, etc).
@andtheWings I actually looked at that already. While I'm more than willing to set up my own RemoteStorage server, I have been able to find exactly zero documentation on their website for setting up the server portion of the service. If you would be so kind as to point me to said documentation, I will go about my merry way and preach the good news of how to replace Evernote with a self-hosted Laverna/RemoteStorage server. Short of that, Laverna is useless to me.
It looks like the Node.js and C implementations have pretty good documentation on their Github readme files.
Digging further into their Github repos, I found they have a nicely-documented "starter kit". I will play with that tonight and report my findings.
@nakedhitman Is RemoteStorage an acceptable alternative to WebDav? How did your tinkering with the starter kit go?
Point is many of us will have something like ownCloud already. WebDAV gives the flexibility to support many of our existing cloud storage services. I would not want to create yet another storage service just for note taking.
I think actually this whole syncing data to some storage might be against the philosophy of laverna being an unhosted app. But still, considering people running laverna on an own server of any kind, saving notes to local storage would be nice, so that you can basically access your notes from anywhere.
+1 For general WebDAV. Although remoteStorage support exists at some degree, most hosting and self-hosting services support only WebDAV.
+1 webdav... we should't (ever) fiddle with the storage over HTTP...
With those projects, DAV shouldn't be too much problem https://github.com/aslakhellesoy/webdavjs https://github.com/sara-nl/js-webdav-client https://github.com/mikedeboer/jsDAV
RemoteStorage C implementation (why do we need run another http server?) stores data on people's home directories.
PHP implementation uses your own http server but needed rewrite rules (only for apache as far as I see), and a separate webfinger implementation.
I wanted to implement it on my own, but I gave up because soon I grew convinced JavaScript is a terrible language and I want to keep my sanity a little longer.
Anyway, here are some of my findings, hopefully they will help someone implement this functionality:
- the simplest way to access WebDAV is most likely https://github.com/perry-mitchell/webdav-fs
- with WebDAV, it is possible to get notified by the WebDAV server about changes in files using the SUBSCRIBE method with Call-back header, but the server does not have to implement it
- webdav-fs does not seem to support callbacks, so it would be required to periodically check for changes. In conjunction with the fact we cannot rely on working notifications, this seems to be a good start anyway
- I'm convinced that for someone who actually knows JavaScript it would be easy to modify the dropbox module to use webdav-fs, as that already contains periodical checks of the changes on the server side and it handles access credentials, too
Ah, just saw this comment! :) This library by @perry-mitchell must be what they did to integrate Nextcloud and Buttercup as I mentioned in https://github.com/Laverna/laverna/issues/635 cc @sallar @brantje
@wwebfor @wwwredfish let us know how we could help that Laverna can use Nextcloud as sync server. :)
Hi! We are using our own modules (open source) for integrating WebDAV: https://github.com/perry-mitchell/webdav-fs + https://github.com/sallar/dropbox-fs + https://github.com/perry-mitchell/any-fs built for this purpose in https://github.com/buttercup/buttercup :) Let me know if we can help
There’s also now a great blog by @perry-mitchell on how to Connect your web app to Nextcloud with WebDAV-fs. :)
Hello there, Please report to https://github.com/Laverna/laverna/issues/971#issuecomment-411423965 which explain the state of this project.
Have a nice day/night, Cheers, Nissar
