Effective icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Effective copied to clipboard

Hand clipping through blocks

Open An0therOne opened this issue 1 year ago • 15 comments

Screenshot_111 Screenshot_112 I'm making a modpack and edding effective causes this to happen, the player's hand clips through blocks, the only solution I found was to all around not have effective in the modpack, I'm leaving it here since I haven't seen somebody else have this issue.

Or maybe it's just an issue of compatibility, who knows, I'll leave the log here.

https://mclo.gs/vZM0Fq9

An0therOne avatar Sep 27 '24 22:09 An0therOne

Came here because I was having the same issue with my own modpack. Just tested on a completely fresh 1.20.1 instance running Quilt 0.26.4 (same versions as my modpack) and the issue doesn't happen, so it must be an incompatibility. I'll try adding a couple mods and see if I can narrow it down.

viscountexx avatar Sep 30 '24 16:09 viscountexx

Found it! It's Iris. The issue happens with V1.7.2+mc1.20.1 andV1.7.1+mc1.20.1, I tried testing older Iris versions, but frankly I got tired of trying to sus out random dependency mismatches and crashes. I'd assume this either happens in all Iris versions, or specifically 1.7.0 or something. Iris does have Sodium as a dependency, but the error only occurs when Iris is installed.

In my testing, the issue affects Effective 2.2.2+1.20.1 thru 2.3.2+1.20.1, and not any earlier.

viscountexx avatar Sep 30 '24 17:09 viscountexx

A bit more information I have collected in the hope its helpful. It's still occurring on with the new Iris update (1.7.5). While it occurs in the Overworld and Nether I don't seem to have the issue in the End.

I have one mod list where the issue isn't present despite being on 2.3.2 (Iris 1.7.5), I'm still trying to figure out why that is.

vesmaybevesper avatar Oct 08 '24 17:10 vesmaybevesper

I have one mod list where the issue isn't present despite being on 2.3.2 (Iris 1.7.5), I'm still trying to figure out why that is.

Any luck figuring it out? If not I could try testing a bit later today if you give me a list of mods + versions and loader version

Xiribidus avatar Oct 18 '24 07:10 Xiribidus

Any luck figuring it out? If not I could try testing a bit later today if you give me a list of mods + versions and loader version

Never got a noti for this sorry. I got distracted by other projects and never got around to testing it (though I have confirmed its not resource or shaderpack related nor does it seem to be 3D Skin Layers). Here's the mod list if you're still willing to look into it: 1.20.1 Quilt 0.26.4 image image

Let me know if you need any more info from me for your testing, I've made sure notifications for this are on now.

vesmaybevesper avatar Nov 02 '24 19:11 vesmaybevesper

Blanket fixed it for me.

magistr-of-code avatar Dec 07 '24 08:12 magistr-of-code

still happening for me even with Blanket

drippyV2 avatar Dec 17 '24 19:12 drippyV2

Does it still happen in the latest alphas?

doctor4t avatar Jan 04 '25 14:01 doctor4t

just tried with iris 1.8.8 for fabric 1.21.1 and effective 2.4.8-1.21.1 it does not happen so its fixed there atleast can i ask if the fix would be backported to 1.20.1?

steventylerseanherr avatar Feb 22 '25 10:02 steventylerseanherr

it does seem fixed in modern versions for me as well, but am also having the issue on 1.20.1

nellePoint avatar Feb 25 '25 04:02 nellePoint

Everyone!

I found a way for it to work with Iris, I used a shaderpack called Sildurs Vibrant Shaders Lite and it worked it's not clipping no more, I'm not sure if it works with other shaders but the shader I gave works.

Josh-Des avatar May 04 '25 14:05 Josh-Des

Still occurs in 1.20.1 with the latest version of both iris and effective

amzelee avatar May 13 '25 04:05 amzelee

Fixed! Sorta... It's something in the iris properties file in the config folder. Did some testing with two modpacks, one I made prior to the issue a few months back and a recent one, and what makes the difference is that properties file. Without it, hand glitch, with the right version from the old modpack, hand doesn't phase at all.

XXMarionetteXX avatar Jun 04 '25 16:06 XXMarionetteXX

No clue as of right now what particular property it is though...

XXMarionetteXX avatar Jun 04 '25 16:06 XXMarionetteXX

Versions I used were effective 2.3.2, iris 1.7.5, and sodium 0.5.11. This is on fabric 1.20.1 0.16.10

XXMarionetteXX avatar Jun 04 '25 16:06 XXMarionetteXX