lnreader icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lnreader copied to clipboard

[Feature request] MyNovelList, local database to register whatever we read, locally

Open Palloxin opened this issue 1 year ago • 5 comments

Describe your suggested feature

No internet required; No database; No hoping the tracker has your book "addable" like on myanimelist limited archive, which doesnt allow many webnovels, or western anime. ANY, any book, becomes addable to your own local list, on LNReader, backupable.

———

Premise: the novel subject is vast, and no website encompasses it fully. Novel Updates accepts only asian novels, no western, not even from RoyalRoad, nor real books.

Add a way to record down whatever we read (e.g. the bible) in a somehow comfortable way, locally. It has to be just bare-bone Ui, very very low maintenance, and no shiny sub-feature:

  1. + button to add novels specs (use Edit Novel screen window, recycle)
  2. A way to add read chapters manually. Also the score from 1 to 100
  3. Basic filters to sort and stuff, already present in the app, recycle it.
  4. Way to backup it
(maybe this, just as ispiration)

Why

The premise.

Also tier list sharing. In the novel community it's a frequent and popular custom to rec stuff to newbies. But it's roughly made; they don't have a place to record them all (see premise), and frankly... they often forget what they read, especially 'veterans':

It's somehow common.

Other details

A little spark is enough to attract, one day, a dev that likes it, and develop this feature further. For example, making the local database a secondary library, with entries, covers and all, but without content (maybe only with favored chapters saved)

Acknowledgements

  • [X] I have searched the existing issues and this is a new ticket, NOT a duplicate or related to another open or closed issue.
  • [X] I have written a short but informative title.
  • [X] If this is an issue with a source, I should be opening an issue in the sources repository.
  • [X] I have updated the app to version 2.0.0.
  • [X] I will fill out all of the requested information in this form.

Palloxin avatar Dec 01 '24 17:12 Palloxin

I found a funny discord channel where users record their reading progress. Maybe it's that bad.

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/a230a605-3ec2-4842-b23f-5242c142ee8f

Palloxin avatar Jan 24 '25 15:01 Palloxin

I really don't see the point of this. It feels just like redundancy. Why would you want save your progress and novels again parallel to the actual novel and progress?

CD-Z avatar Jan 24 '25 15:01 CD-Z

Myanimelist, anilist and many others exist. NU accepts only asian stuff, many other novels missing. And can only rate 1-5.

Yes the app can keep the progress, but it needs an entry and a plugin (or imported epub). Novelist is just little text easily backup-able.

Cab you imagine the flood of entries just to keep the progress as a "marked as read" like on myanimelist?

NovelList can accept anything. The Bible? sure, Mobydick? Your uncle secret book he shared with 4 people? we got it. Every, single, novel.

Palloxin avatar Jan 24 '25 16:01 Palloxin

Still I think there aren't many people who would use this inside of LNReader. It would be better to just extend what already exists.

CD-Z avatar Jan 24 '25 16:01 CD-Z

NovelList can be added and then extend what already exists into it. Like an automatic infor retrieve from an entry to NovelList, but that is for a future after NovelList implementation

Palloxin avatar Jan 24 '25 16:01 Palloxin