Simply-Improved-Terrain icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Simply-Improved-Terrain copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon KdotJPG

YUNG's Better Caves overwrites this mod

Open Pannoniae opened this issue 3 years ago • 9 comments

When using it together with YUNG's mods, this mod's changes simply don't apply. There is no error in the log, just silently overwritten.

Pannoniae avatar Jun 19 '21 08:06 Pannoniae

~~I'm having this same issue.~~ Actually, after having everything on the latest update (Forge, YUNG's API, YUNG's Better caves, YUNG's Better mineshafts, YUNG's Better Stronghold and I even have Subterranean Wilderness) things seem to work together. I can clearly see the changes made by Simply Improved Terrain and YUNG's mods.

DoctorMeta avatar Jun 25 '21 02:06 DoctorMeta

@Pannoniae Interesting. Are you using Fabric or Forge? I have been running the two together on Forge for a while. Just now testing in Fabric, I also had success. Fabric versions: image (Fabric loader is 0.11.3-1.16.5)

Fabric screenshot: image

Would you be able to list which mods+versions you have?

KdotJPG avatar Jun 28 '21 07:06 KdotJPG

Sorry for not replying earlier. I'm using forge, not fabric. These are the versions I'm using (please note I have ~100 mods loaded, but tested everything in vanilla biomes):

  • Forge 36.1.32
  • SimplyImprovedTerrain-0.3.2-Forge
  • YungsApi-1.16.4-Forge-6
  • BetterCaves-Forge-1.16.4-1.1.2

Also using, but may be unrelated:

  • subwild-1.2.1
  • Quark-r2.4-312
  • BetterMineshafts-Forge-1.16.4-2.0.4
  • BetterStrongholds-1.16.4-1.1

Here are some screenshots: I'm 99% sure this is Improved terrain world-gen 2021-07-02_15 52 49

I'm 99% sure these caves are generated by YUNG's mods 2021-07-02_15 50 14

DoctorMeta avatar Jul 02 '21 14:07 DoctorMeta

@DoctorMeta Oh thanks for the verification on your end! That helps nail down both platforms as working. Now just hoping that @Pannoniae is able to come list their mods and versions so we can compare and find what the root cause of their incompatibility issue might be.

KdotJPG avatar Jul 02 '21 21:07 KdotJPG

I've narrowed it down to a quite minimal set of mods - http://prntscr.com/19gf38s With only (almost) all of YUNG's mods and this, I get vanilla terrain.

Pannoniae avatar Jul 08 '21 09:07 Pannoniae

In fact, just installing YUNG's API breaks it. I forgot to note that this is latest forge. (.1.32)

Pannoniae avatar Jul 08 '21 10:07 Pannoniae

Still an issue in latest forge (.2.0). If I install YUNG's Caves, Simply Improved Terrain doesn't take effect. Interestingly, it doesn't happen with all the other YUNG's mods.

Pannoniae avatar Jul 22 '21 23:07 Pannoniae

Can also confirm this one happening for me too.

KKotik avatar Aug 11 '21 12:08 KKotik

Revisiting this, and am having still having incredible difficulty replicating it.

I've tried all permutations of the following:

  • Single Player / Server
  • Forge 36.1.32 / 36.2.39

with the following mods:

image

In all cases, I still see the cave and terrain changes at the same time.

image image

EDIT: to clarify, I still really would like to fix it!

KdotJPG avatar Apr 05 '23 05:04 KdotJPG