RandomExtensions.jl icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
RandomExtensions.jl copied to clipboard

A lot of ambiguities due to too general `rand`signatures

Open thofma opened this issue 3 years ago • 1 comments

We are still using this quite heavily in Oscar land, but after playing around with https://github.com/JuliaTesting/Aqua.jl (which helps detecting method ambiguities), I noticed that RandomExtensions.jl leads to a lot of method ambiguities. For example, the methods

rand(X, ::Type{Tuple}, n::Integer)
     @ RandomExtensions ~/.julia/packages/RandomExtensions/qAD6J/src/containers.jl:53
rand(X, t::Type{<:Array}, dims::Integer...)
     @ RandomExtensions ~/.julia/packages/RandomExtensions/qAD6J/src/containers.jl:106

will make the pass-through methods

rand(T::MyAbstractType, v...) = rand(GLOBAL_RNG, T, v...)

ambiguous for certain input types (note that I cannot pin down the type of v directly, since T is abstract and there are many possible combinations).

They are usually fine in practice, but it just looks bad. There are so many, that ignoring them might hide real ambiguities.

thofma avatar Oct 03 '22 16:10 thofma

One problem with these methods in "containers.jl" is that they are doing type piracy, so the plan is to split the bulk of this package into a non-pirating part, which Oscar could be updated to depend on (last time I checked, Oscar was not depending on methods defined in this file).

rfourquet avatar Mar 31 '23 12:03 rfourquet