juliaup
juliaup copied to clipboard
JuliaLang
Add alternative installation instructions
Linux & Mac: I couldn't find specific instructions, but I'm guessing they exist, as it sounds like Juliaup should work on these platforms.
Windows: For some, installing from the Store may not be an option. How should these people install Juliaup?
It would be nice if the README listed these installation instructions.
The only option that is ready at this point is the Windows Store option. We are getting closer with Linux and MacOS support, but at this point it is not ready for general consumption or feedback, so for now we should wait with install instructions in the README until things are ready :) But then, yes, agreed, we need to add them! I'll keep this issue open to track that.
Related to this: I understand that juliaup should update itself. Does this, too, rely on a connection with the Windows Store? Getting the Windows Store to work is very hard, so after the first install, it would be good to not rely on juliaup communicating with the store.
Yes, the version from the Windows Store gets updated by the Windows Store. It solves a lot of problems as doing background updates is not trivial...
My current plan is to next figure out automatic self-update for Linux and Mac, and then come back to Windows and see whether we can improve the situation for folks where the Windows Store is in some form blocked.
[…] doing background updates is not trivial...
What exactly do you mean by 'background updates'?
Off the top of my head, Powershell (pwsh) warns that an upgrade is available on start, and pip likewise warns at least when used to install a package (and maybe in more cases). Both require the user to initiate the upgrade – typically through manual download in the case of pwsh, but a simple one-liner in the case of pip (and rustup, and stack, and…). I'm fine with the latter strategy.
Does the new-ish Windows package manager, winget, change the picture at all, or is that just a CLI for the Store app?
[…] or is that just a CLI for the Store app?
It is not, but it can function as one:
PS ~ > winget search julia
Name Id Version Source
-----------------------------------------------------
Julia 9NJNWW8PVKMN Unknown msstore
Julian Date Selector 9NSGP4VDNW0R Unknown msstore
Julia Julialang.Julia 1.6.2 winget
I tried to circumvent the Store by using winget, but it doesn't work: installing 9NJNWW8PVKMN still requires logging in.
I tried to circumvent the Store by using
winget, but it doesn't work: installing 9NJNWW8PVKMN still requires logging in.
This is blocked by https://github.com/microsoft/winget-cli/issues/1585#issuecomment-974509235.
