PipePipe icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PipePipe copied to clipboard

[Bug] Unable to rewind back more than 30s on live streams

Open phlaster opened this issue 10 months ago • 4 comments

Checklist (Your issue will be automatically closed if you delete this part)

  • [x] I make sure that there are no existing issues - open or closed - which I could contribute my information to.
  • [x] I understand that issues with limited impact, such as those occurring on specific devices or under specific network conditions, will not be fixed.
  • [x] I am able to reproduce the bug with the latest version given here: CLICK THIS LINK.
  • [ ] I have attached the error report in the issue.

Describe the bug Many releases ago I remember, it was possible to rewind up to 1 hour back from live timestamp, where now it is only around 30s. Is it technical limitation or an oversight?

Frequency All live streams

Steps to reproduce the bug Open any Live stream, that started more than 30s ago, you won't be able to rewind more than ~30s

Device (e.g. Pixel 9 Pro) Redmi note 8

Error report None

Additional context

phlaster avatar Feb 27 '25 17:02 phlaster

I think it's because we are using different playing method. It might still possible to rewind back lives more, but I need time to do more investigation and its priority is relatively low.

InfinityLoop1308 avatar Mar 01 '25 22:03 InfinityLoop1308

As an aside, this would make PipePipe - as far as I know - the only open source app to support playback of livestream beyond the ~30s latest seconds from livestream. Major omission on the whole alternative youtube frontend space in general.

WilliamKimball0 avatar Apr 20 '25 21:04 WilliamKimball0

Rewinding YT livestreams works perfectly in LibreTube app, which uses NP Extractor to handle the streams. I guess it suggests this functionality is feasible to implement.

spvkgn avatar Aug 30 '25 12:08 spvkgn

https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe/pull/12601

It needs to use DASH manifests instead of HLS to get rewind back on livestreams.

spvkgn avatar Sep 25 '25 03:09 spvkgn

I'm also requesting this.

mentl-m0rii avatar Dec 01 '25 22:12 mentl-m0rii