idaes-pse icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
idaes-pse copied to clipboard

Examine reason for solver failures in Flash workshop example

Open andrewlee94 opened this issue 4 years ago • 4 comments

See IDAES/examples-dev#142 and IDAES/examples-dev#144.

Something strange is happening with the repeated solves of the Flash unit in the first workshop example. From examining the various model states throughout the example, I had the following observations:

  1. There are minor differences in the final solution (i.e. last three to four places in the floats) for solutions that otherwise should be the same. Notably, I saw two different model states: the first deterministic solution, and the solution after re-initializing the model from any other state. However, the fixed variables are identical in all cases, so any variation must be due to scaling?
  2. Re-initializing the model prior to generating lots works, so that suggests that is the more stable solution. Thus, something is not quite right with the first deterministic solution?

This needs to be investigated further - my first impression is to try scaling the model better and see what happens (which will require the scaling tools).

andrewlee94 avatar Jul 31 '20 18:07 andrewlee94

@carldlaird I know it is unlikely that you will be able to give much insight without looking at the model, but do you have any ideas?

andrewlee94 avatar Jul 31 '20 18:07 andrewlee94

This is definitely still relevant.

andrewlee94 avatar Nov 20 '20 14:11 andrewlee94

@andrewlee94 Ping me over email and let's setup a time to discuss.

carldlaird avatar Nov 20 '20 14:11 carldlaird

Sorry @andrewlee94 I just assumed given the dates that this had been resolved or was in wont-fix state

dangunter avatar Dec 01 '20 04:12 dangunter

This is old enough that I am going to assume it is either fixed or no longer matters.

andrewlee94 avatar Feb 14 '23 20:02 andrewlee94