hanabi-live icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
hanabi-live copied to clipboard

Support more suits

Open DarthGandalf opened this issue 3 years ago • 8 comments

e.g. BGA supports 7 suits

DarthGandalf avatar Feb 13 '22 18:02 DarthGandalf

bga sucks though

Zamiell avatar Feb 13 '22 19:02 Zamiell

Seven suits really does seem like too many. There aren't any official printings of the rules that call for that many, are there?

rogers-j avatar Feb 13 '22 20:02 rogers-j

Rainbow+Black powder (=white reversed) is on bga. I believe that's official? Can someone confirm.

Romain672 avatar Feb 13 '22 20:02 Romain672

black powder is official, yeah. They just combine all the existing suits in one game. That is, 5 normal suits, rainbow, and the black powder (aka white reversed)

DarthGandalf avatar Feb 13 '22 20:02 DarthGandalf

bga sucks though

it does, however this is one place where we're the ones missing feature

DarthGandalf avatar Feb 13 '22 20:02 DarthGandalf

https://rnrgames.com/Content/RRGames/images/productrules/Hanabi_BlackPowderExpansion_rules.pdf is clear about the new suit being the sixth, not seventh

rogers-j avatar Feb 13 '22 20:02 rogers-j

we're the ones missing feature

i dont think adding unfun, stupid features purely for the sake of adding "missing" features is worth it

Zamiell avatar Feb 13 '22 21:02 Zamiell

its the same reason i deny most of the variant requests i get

Zamiell avatar Feb 13 '22 21:02 Zamiell

Closing this as wontfix since it doesn't seem like there is much interest for having more than six suits, I also agree 7 seems too many

Feel free to re-open comment if you want to make a case for 7+ suits

vEnhance avatar Nov 10 '22 12:11 vEnhance