android-youtubeExtractor icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
android-youtubeExtractor copied to clipboard

Legal question

Open andrzejwiech opened this issue 3 years ago • 7 comments

I have a general question. Is extracting youtube URL and then playing it in other than youtube player legal? Also if it is, does that not violate and of google policies? Asking as I consider using it my app but fear rejection in app review.

andrzejwiech avatar Mar 08 '21 20:03 andrzejwiech

These ways of getting a YouTube URL violates 100% the policy of google, so you wont be able to upload your app to the store (you can, but some day will be removed)

Dolanpls avatar Mar 10 '21 06:03 Dolanpls

Many thx @Dolanpls. What is the point of having this lib then? I guess other than "google play store" stores? And why 651 stars?

andrzejwiech avatar Mar 10 '21 07:03 andrzejwiech

You can upload your app into another market or even distribute your APK in your own web. This is the bad point of use this libs 😅 but if you dont want to pay the expensive YouTube API key limit, you only have these options

Dolanpls avatar Mar 10 '21 07:03 Dolanpls

Right I see, I actually have other problem, as I am building Android TV app and there you cannot use youtube api. So I am only left out with option of playing trailer in webview based libs which comparing to native with extracted URL looks really bad. But well it is what it is. Thanks again.

andrzejwiech avatar Mar 10 '21 07:03 andrzejwiech

On the other hand comment to authors, I think it should be clearly stated in lib description that it violates YouTube policy.

andrzejwiech avatar Mar 10 '21 07:03 andrzejwiech

I would tell you to look for another option because this repo seems to be abandoned

Dolanpls avatar Mar 10 '21 08:03 Dolanpls

Which one is? At this point I use https://github.com/PierfrancescoSoffritti/android-youtube-player which is not Android TV dedicated so I have to tweak it a bit mostly with regards to DPAD handling.

andrzejwiech avatar Mar 10 '21 08:03 andrzejwiech