HSE icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
HSE copied to clipboard

About the veg-fru dataset

Open abcdvzz opened this issue 7 years ago • 4 comments

Veg-fru dataset has a test set which is much bigger than the train set and val set. I'd like to know if you can tell me which two of them are used as the training set and validation set during training phase. And which one of them is used in your paper to get the top-1 accuracy? Thank you very much.

abcdvzz avatar Oct 04 '18 14:10 abcdvzz

Veg-fru dataset has a test set which is much bigger than the train set and val set. I'd like to know if you can tell me which two of them are used as the training set and validation set during training phase. And which one of them is used in your paper to get the top-1 accuracy? Thank you very much.

We train our model on the training set, and evaluate it on the test set to get the top-1 accuracy.

tianshuichen avatar Oct 05 '18 00:10 tianshuichen

So: training: train set, validation: test set, top-1 accuracy: test set. However, in the paper of veg-fru, top-1 accuracy is obtained in the val set. So there might be something wrong in your comparison results of veg-fru dataset.

abcdvzz avatar Oct 05 '18 05:10 abcdvzz

We copy the results of HybridNet and CB-CNN from table 5 in the VegFru paper. In the caption, the authors clearly state that the results are evaluated on the test set. It seems nothing is wrong.

tianshuichen avatar Oct 05 '18 12:10 tianshuichen

I have tested your model on vegfru. It seems that the model has only 0.8671 top-1 acc.

Zjay avatar Nov 11 '21 10:11 Zjay