[GMSCompat] Cannot login to Pinterest with Google (NameNotFoundException: com.google.android.gms)

[TaeHagen]

Clicking sign in with Google does nothing, despite Play Store being installed in same profile and working fine.

ADB logs printed upon clicking button:

08-18 15:27:23.015  1328  2155 I CredManSysService: starting executeGetCredential with callingPackage: com.pinterest
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: Error getting info for ServiceInfo{c8c1e3a com.google.android.gms.auth.api.credentials.credman.service.GoogleIdService}
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: android.content.pm.PackageManager$NameNotFoundException: com.google.android.gms
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfoAsUser(ApplicationPackageManager.java:522)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfo(ApplicationPackageManager.java:505)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServiceInfos(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:401)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServices(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:431)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.constructSystemServiceListLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:142)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getOrConstructSystemServiceListLock(CredentialManagerService.java:247)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.newServiceListLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:182)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.infra.AbstractMasterSystemService.getServiceListForUserLocked(AbstractMasterSystemService.java:608)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getCredentialProviderServicesLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:328)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.runForUser(CredentialManagerService.java:286)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.initiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:438)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.-$$Nest$minitiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:0)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.prepareProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:699)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.executeGetCredential(CredentialManagerService.java:573)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.credentials.ICredentialManager$Stub.onTransact(ICredentialManager.java:179)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransactInternal(Binder.java:1529)
08-18 15:27:23.018  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransact(Binder.java:1468)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: Error getting info for ServiceInfo{8376048 com.google.android.gms.auth.api.credentials.credman.service.RemoteService}
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: android.content.pm.PackageManager$NameNotFoundException: com.google.android.gms
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfoAsUser(ApplicationPackageManager.java:522)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfo(ApplicationPackageManager.java:505)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServiceInfos(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:401)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServices(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:431)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.constructSystemServiceListLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:142)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getOrConstructSystemServiceListLock(CredentialManagerService.java:247)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.newServiceListLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:182)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.infra.AbstractMasterSystemService.getServiceListForUserLocked(AbstractMasterSystemService.java:608)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getCredentialProviderServicesLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:328)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.runForUser(CredentialManagerService.java:286)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.initiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:438)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.-$$Nest$minitiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:0)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.prepareProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:699)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.executeGetCredential(CredentialManagerService.java:573)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.credentials.ICredentialManager$Stub.onTransact(ICredentialManager.java:179)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransactInternal(Binder.java:1529)
08-18 15:27:23.019  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransact(Binder.java:1468)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: Error getting info for ServiceInfo{de406 com.google.android.gms.auth.api.credentials.credman.service.GoogleIdService}
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: android.content.pm.PackageManager$NameNotFoundException: com.google.android.gms
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfoAsUser(ApplicationPackageManager.java:522)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfo(ApplicationPackageManager.java:505)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServiceInfos(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:401)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServices(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:431)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.constructSystemServiceListLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:142)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getOrConstructSystemServiceListLock(CredentialManagerService.java:247)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getCredentialProviderServicesLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:332)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.runForUser(CredentialManagerService.java:286)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.initiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:438)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.-$$Nest$minitiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:0)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.prepareProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:699)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.executeGetCredential(CredentialManagerService.java:573)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.credentials.ICredentialManager$Stub.onTransact(ICredentialManager.java:179)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransactInternal(Binder.java:1529)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransact(Binder.java:1468)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: Error getting info for ServiceInfo{c8638f4 com.google.android.gms.auth.api.credentials.credman.service.RemoteService}
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: android.content.pm.PackageManager$NameNotFoundException: com.google.android.gms
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfoAsUser(ApplicationPackageManager.java:522)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.app.ApplicationPackageManager.getApplicationInfo(ApplicationPackageManager.java:505)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServiceInfos(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:401)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.service.credentials.CredentialProviderInfoFactory.getAvailableSystemServices(CredentialProviderInfoFactory.java:431)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.constructSystemServiceListLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:142)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getOrConstructSystemServiceListLock(CredentialManagerService.java:247)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.getCredentialProviderServicesLocked(CredentialManagerService.java:332)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.runForUser(CredentialManagerService.java:286)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.initiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:438)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService.-$$Nest$minitiateProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:0)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.prepareProviderSessions(CredentialManagerService.java:699)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at com.android.server.credentials.CredentialManagerService$CredentialManagerServiceStub.executeGetCredential(CredentialManagerService.java:573)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.credentials.ICredentialManager$Stub.onTransact(ICredentialManager.java:179)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransactInternal(Binder.java:1529)
08-18 15:27:23.020  1328  2155 E CredentialProviderInfoFactory: 	at android.os.Binder.execTransact(Binder.java:1468)
08-18 15:27:23.022  3884  4176 I CredManProvService: GetCredentialResponse error returned from framework

Thank you, please fix as I can't log in to my Pinterest account at the moment.

[thestinger]

You haven't disabled or uninstalled Play services, right?

[TaeHagen]

No, the Play Store opens and works fine.

[thestinger]

And Network isn't blocked for either?

[TaeHagen]

I'm sending this from the phone and have no issues browsing the web, everything seems fine yet sign in with Google still does nothing and prints same error.

[thestinger]

The Network permission is granted to both Play Store and Play services though, right?

Is this with a work profile?

[TaeHagen]

This is with the default profile after setup.

[thestinger]

Does a reboot fix it?

[TaeHagen]

Just rebooted; still broken.

[ar-qun]

Same issue.

[jonas-w]

Same issue also for the app "Notein"

[thestinger]

It's caused by lack of privileged access and is currently expected. We'd need to figure out a way to implement a compatibility layer for this specific approach.

[flexagoon]

Same for "Mymind"

[flexagoon]

~@thestinger I want to try working on this issue, but I don't really have any prior experience, so I have some questions.~

~The way I assume this can be solved is:~

~1. Add a checkServiceWhitelist function (and proper IPC intents) into GmsCompat, which would use GmsCompatConfig to get the list of services that should be publicly accessible~ ~2. Patch upstream PackageManager's package resolution code to add a special case if GmsCompat is installed and the requested name is whitelisted, in which case the name would be resolved as if it was a system app~

~Does an approach like this make sense?~

~Alternatively, CredentialManager could be patched to reroute google sign in requests to GmsCompat, which would implement a proper shim. This approach would be less versatile but potentially more secure because the scope would be limited to those specific requests~

[flexagoon]

Upon further inspection of the AOSP codebase, it seems like there's a much simpler solution. I'll try setting up the dev environment and fixing this.

[thestinger]

This has been implemented for our next release.