ps-analysis-tool icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ps-analysis-tool copied to clipboard

[QA] Discrepancy in PSAT Cookie w.r.t. Application Tab

Open kjnanda opened this issue 1 year ago • 4 comments

Revisiting another round of QA for V0.4.0 as requested

Scenarios Observed so far :

Observed Scenarios:

1. Occasionally, PSAT displays only a subset of cookies, while the rest appear in alternative frames such as 'Unknown Frames.'
2. At times, PSAT successfully shows all cookies within its dedicated frame.
3. PSAT experiences delays in presenting the remaining cookies. and sometimes, the remaining cookies fail to appear altogether.
4. Notably, certain frames within PSAT display cookies that are absent in the Application Tab.

  • [ ] PSAT does not show complete set of cookies as Application Tab.

Test site - https://edition.cnn.com/

It is been observed that for https://acdn.adnxs.com frame only some cookies were missing. Application tab shows all the cookies but those all cookies were not present in PSAT Extension.

Screenshots

Application Tab PSAT
image image

Now, further investing this issue I have found -

Observation Screenshot
Those missing cookies were present under Unknown Frames as shown in the screenshot below. image
The cookies take quiet a long time to appear. https://github.com/GoogleChromeLabs/ps-analysis-tool/assets/15173772/5500a3a0-1e45-4cfe-ad41-af83da860c62
After a few seconds I was able to get all the cookies in this frame image

  • [ ] Some more discrepancy as mentioned above for other frames
Frame name Application Tab PSAT
https://assets.bounceexchange.com image Screenshot 2024-01-02 at 12 49 23

  • [ ] PSAT Shows more cookies than Application Tab
Frame name Application Tab PSAT
https://s.amazon-adsystem.com image image
  • [ ] PSAT - There are some frame which has cookies in it where as Application Tab does not show cookies for the same.

kjnanda avatar Jan 02 '24 07:01 kjnanda

@kjnanda Some of these might be solved once performance fix branch is merged to develop.

amovar18 avatar Jan 15 '24 10:01 amovar18

Cross-verified it with v0.5.0 and able to reproduce the issue

PSAT does not show complete set of cookies as Application Tab.

Application Tab PSAT tab
image image

pavanpatil1 avatar Feb 09 '24 11:02 pavanpatil1

@pavanpatil1 Please could you re-test against the v0.6 release?

maitreyie-chavan avatar Mar 18 '24 07:03 maitreyie-chavan

Hi @amovar18, Still able to see some discrepancy with the application tab.

Application Tab Privacy sandbox tab
image image

Application Tab Privacy sandbox tab
image image

pavanpatil1 avatar Mar 19 '24 10:03 pavanpatil1