Function to allow easier annotations outside the map region

[seisman]

The original idea comes from my old post (in Chinese) 8 years ago. The recent issue report https://github.com/GenericMappingTools/pygmt/issues/2001 and forum question reminds me this tricky again. So I would like to see if it can be done in PyGMT or even GMT.

The problem

If someone wants to plot a map and make annotations outside the map, he will face at least two difficulties:

1. The annotation is outside the map region. It's impossible to specify its location using a valid geographic coordinate system, although it's possible to use text module's -D option to offset the annotations.
2. It's difficult to plot a line that crosses the map boundary (related to https://github.com/GenericMappingTools/gmt/issues/5766)

The GMT CLI solution

The solution is actually easy. We just need to define a new, bigger Cartesian frame, write annotations and draw lines in the new frame, and revert to the original frame when finished.

Here is a working solution using GMT CLI:

gmt begin map png
	  gmt coast -Rg -JH20c -Ggray -Slightblue
	  
	  ############################################################
      # Define a Cartesian frame. 
      # Now all locations are given with respect to this frame.
	  gmt plot -R0/25/0/15 -Jx1c -Ba1f1g1 -T
	  echo 21 10 ANNOTATION | gmt text -F+jBL
	  echo 14.5 7.5 21 10 | gmt plot -Sv0.3c+s+be+gblue -W1p,blue
	  # Revert to the original frame
	  gmt plot -Rg -JH20c -T
	  ############################################################

      # now all locations are given with respect to the original geographic frame
	  echo -93 37 | gmt plot -Sa0.5c -Gred
gmt end show

As you can see, here I define a new Cartesian map frame using -R0/25/0/15 -Jx1c, so the frame is 25 cm x 15 cm. I also use -Ba1f1g1 to draw the gridlines so that I can easily determine the location of "annotation" and start/end points of the vector. The intermediate figure looks like this:

In the final figure, we don't want to see the gridlines and the Cartesian frame. So we just need to remove -Ba1f1g1. Thus, the final script is:

gmt begin map png
	  gmt coast -Rg -JH20c -Ggray -Slightblue
	  
	  ############################################################
      # Define a Cartesian frame. 
      # Now all locations are given with respect to this frame.
	  gmt plot -R0/25/0/15 -Jx1c -Ba1f1g1 -T
	  echo 21 10 ANNOTATION | gmt text -F+jBL
	  echo 14.5 7.5 21 10 | gmt plot -Sv0.3c+s+be+gblue -W1p,blue
	  # Revert to the original frame
	  gmt plot -Rg -JH20c -T
	  ############################################################

      # now all locations are given with respect to the original geographic frame
	  echo -93 37 | gmt plot -Sa0.5c -Gred
gmt end show

Proposing a new module for GMT

The above syntax is straight forward but it's not elegant, because we still have to revert to the original frame. Perhaps GMT can add a new module (e.g., ruler or annot) to simplify this. With this new module, the new syntax will look like:

gmt begin map png
	  gmt coast -Rg -JH20c -Ggray -Slightblue

	  ############################################################ 
      gmt ruler begin -S25/15 -Ba1f1g1
		echo 21 10 ANNOTATION | gmt text -F+jBL
	  	echo 14.5 7.5 21 10 | gmt plot -Sv0.3c+s+be+gblue -W1p,blue
      gmt ruler end
	  ############################################################

      # now all locations are given with respect to the original geographic frame
	  echo -93 37 | gmt plot -Sa0.5c -Gred
gmt end show

The PyGMT version

The equivalent PyGMT syntax will look like this:

import pygmt

fig = pygmt.Figure()
fig.coast(region="g", projection="H20c", land="gray", water="lightblue")

with fig.ruler(width=25, height=15, showframe=True):
    fig.text(x=21, y=10, text="ANNOTATION")
    fig.plot(data=[14.5, 7.5, 21, 10], style="v0.3c+s+be+gblue", pen="1p,blue")

fig.plot(x=-93, y=37, style="a0.5c", color="red")
fig.show()

It's easy to wrap the proposed GMT's ruler module. If if ruler is not implemented in GMT, the Figure.ruler() function is still doable in PyGMT. The only difficult I can see is how to remember the original map projection and region parameter before entering Figure.ruler, so that we can revert to the original frame when exiting Figure.ruler.

[seisman]

It seems @joa-quim also implemented a similar feature in GMT.jl (https://www.generic-mapping-tools.org/GMTjl_doc/examples/misc/mix_paper_geog/) recently.

@PaulWessel Do you think it should be done in GMT or not?

[PaulWessel]

Shit, I had written half a page in response and whoops somehow GitHub decided to clear the box...

I will write more later but the essence of my comment was, yes, we need a module with begin/end. My suggestion was gmt cartesian but ruler is OK too. I think paper is to nondescript. I think no clipping is default, and -Cg (clip to geographic area) and -Cr Clip to rectangular area are exclusive options. Not sure if any other option is required?

[seisman]

I'm transferring the issue to the upstream GMT repository.

[joa-quim]

Close this?