FreeTube icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
FreeTube copied to clipboard

[Feature Request]: Change "Favorites" playlist title & icon to "Watch Later"

Open kommunarr opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Guidelines

  • [X] I have searched the issue tracker for open and closed issues that are similar to the feature request I want to file, without success.
  • [X] I have searched the documentation for information that matches the description of the feature request I want to file, without success.
  • [X] This issue contains only one feature request.

Problem Description

The "Watch Later" button is a more familiar & welcoming label & iconography than the Favorites icon & labeling, which appears more dated.

Proposed Solution

Rename the Favorites playlist to "Watch Later". Change the "unstarred" icon to the fa-clock. Changed the "starred" icon to the fa-check.

Alternatives Considered

Change the name but not the icons. Or change the icons but not the label. Or don't implement this feature.

Issue Labels

visual improvement

Additional Information

No response

kommunarr avatar Jan 02 '24 22:01 kommunarr

"Watch Later" is how I've been using that list because it was so easy to add to it.

aleksejrs avatar Jan 06 '24 08:01 aleksejrs

If the idea is to provide a familiar experience for those migrating from YouTube, I propose removing the extra button entirely and having only the button that opens the list of playlists. This cuts down on the complexity of the UI, and really, that button is only there for convenience.

Charsy89 avatar Feb 18 '24 00:02 Charsy89

<rant about youtube's UX>

My main complaint with YouTube is a usability frustration due to incoherent design. It's the only reason I'm looking at alternative front-ends. In this case, I care much more about usability than privacy; the problem is that YouTube is offering me neither.

I like to queue up a lot of videos to watch and watch them all in one go. YouTube's suggestions feed has that nice little 'Watch Later' button on the thumbnails, very much like this project's favorite star. But on the home and search result pages of YouTube, that button doesn't exist and you need to click the triple dot drop-down. Worse yet, is YouTube's notification UI that doesn't have playlist features at all!

Ingesting videos from bell notifications to a playlist becomes a 5~6 click workflow: ctrl+lmb to open in a new tab, lmb tab, lmb triple dot (only sometimes), lmb 'Save', lmb 'Watch Later', lmb to close tab.

It's absurd compared to suggested videos that take only one click! The only alternatives are to use a third-party playlist plugin with right-click context menu options, or leaving a dozen tabs open.

</rant about youtube's UX>

I really hope this project gets fully-featured playlists and a very easy-to-use and design-coherent Watch Later list.

Having UX that doesn't make the user want to jump off a bridge would be an amazing selling point for any front-end, and would make it an attractive alternative to the YouTube site for even less privacy-focused users.

alaestor avatar Feb 29 '24 19:02 alaestor

Alternative has been implemented in #4825

Change the icons but not the label.