media-ui icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
media-ui copied to clipboard

UX: Functionality of clipboard is unclear

Open lorenzulrich opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

The term clipboard is normally used to copy or move "content" between "storages".

To me, it looks as if the Clipboard in the Media UI can only be used to delete multiple assets at once. While this is a valid use-case, I'm not sure it's an expected (sole) use-case for a Clipboard.

I would expect deleting multiple assets by multi-selection in the file list (which is also an established concept in Neos - see document and structure tree).

For the clipboard, I would imagine it could be used for moving many files at once.

Slightly related: I think that the "Flush clipboard" icon is not an intuitive choice:

image

Affected Versions

Neos: 8.3 UI: 8.3.4 Media Module: 0.13

lorenzulrich avatar Oct 12 '23 08:10 lorenzulrich

The first use case for the clipboard was to prepare a list of assets which you want quick access to later in the media selection when working on content.

Then I added "delete" as first batch action and there is an open issue to add more actions like assign collections, tags, etc.

So you can browser through your media, collect assets and then work with them.

The multi-selection in the list has the disadvantage that you loose the selection when paginating. Though we also have an open issue for the batch actions in the list view. And also the drag&drop part is still not implemented and is an open issue.

Sebobo avatar Oct 13 '23 07:10 Sebobo

I agree that the icon should be changed. Not sure yet which one would fit.

Sebobo avatar Oct 13 '23 07:10 Sebobo

Already fixed in b93fa681fb7a2d8c2a262224cc405ebc0e7d5294

Sebobo avatar Jul 22 '24 07:07 Sebobo