FGA icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
FGA copied to clipboard

Custom Game Area (black bars) megathread

Open reconman opened this issue 3 years ago • 1084 comments
trafficstars

This thread is for automatically calculating Custom Game Area values if needed.

If you don't have any black bars, stop reading, you will not find a solution to your problem here.

A recent update fixed black bars on most devices, you only need to set the "camera notch" display option to "Auto adapt" for FGO.

If you still have black bars, post a screenshot in the following format:

How it should look like

Doesn't work, left black bar is covered by play button.

Doesn't work, too many black areas along the borders

reconman avatar Aug 28 '22 14:08 reconman

Hi, I have a Samsung Galaxy S21+ 5G and would like assistance in finding the offsets. image0screenshotautomata

Taritsu-23RP avatar Aug 29 '22 22:08 Taritsu-23RP

@Taritsu-23RP No offsets needed, read the text above again.

Also you don't even have black bars.

reconman avatar Aug 29 '22 22:08 reconman

@Taritsu-23RP No offsets needed, read the text above again.

Also you don't even have black bars.

Then I must be doing something wrong with the app since it's not detecting the screen correctly

https://photos.app.goo.gl/VDNLZ2Rx6JPLZ7zP9

Taritsu-23RP avatar Aug 29 '22 22:08 Taritsu-23RP

@Taritsu-23RP Restart FGA's service. You just broke screen detection by using Android's recorder.

reconman avatar Aug 29 '22 22:08 reconman

Hello, I use a tablet called UMIDIGI A11 tablet and it has screen size of 10'4 inch can someone help me set the game area if it is possible to fix using the offset, since when I use fga it doesn't work properly, it misses a lot of buttons.

Davincisan avatar Aug 30 '22 09:08 Davincisan

@Davincisan Does it have black bars? If yes, post a screenshot. If not, open a bug report.

reconman avatar Aug 30 '22 15:08 reconman

@Davincisan Does it have black bars? If yes, post a screenshot. If not, open a bug report.

Thanks for the quick reply. I don't think it have black bars, sorry I'm not good with electronics but it looks like this Screenshot_20220831-023131

A video of what happens https://youtu.be/NRBqtSWwA4M I can't issue a bug report sorry

Davincisan avatar Aug 30 '22 19:08 Davincisan

@Davincisan Does it have black bars? If yes, post a screenshot. If not, open a bug report.

Thanks for the quick reply. I don't think it have black bars, sorry I'm not good with electronics but it looks like this Screenshot_20220831-023131

A video of what happens https://youtu.be/NRBqtSWwA4M I can't issue a bug report sorry

You have skill confirmation turned on in fgo so you also need to turn it on in fga too, by default fgo will always have skill use confirmation turned on the first time you start playing. Most players usually turns it off after playing fgo for awhile because it's much more convenient to use skills with one click that's why fga has skill use confirmation turned off by default. So if you have it on in fgo then you need to turn it on in fga, if it's off in fgo then it should be off in fga too

vybze avatar Aug 30 '22 20:08 vybze

@Davincisan https://github.com/Fate-Grand-Automata/FGA/wiki/Troubleshooting#uses-skills-on-the-wrong-servant-or-doesnt-use-skills-at-all

reconman avatar Aug 30 '22 20:08 reconman

@Davincisan Does it have black bars? If yes, post a screenshot. If not, open a bug report.

Thanks for the quick reply. I don't think it have black bars, sorry I'm not good with electronics but it looks like this Screenshot_20220831-023131 A video of what happens https://youtu.be/NRBqtSWwA4M I can't issue a bug report sorry

You have skill confirmation turned on in fgo so you also need to turn it on in fga too, by default fgo will always have skill use confirmation turned on the first time you start playing. Most players usually turns it off after playing fgo for awhile because it's much more convenient to use skills with one click that's why fga has skill use confirmation turned off by default. So if you have it on in fgo then you need to turn it on in fga, if it's off in fgo then it should be off in fga too

Thanks it's working now, sorry for the trouble caused 😇

Davincisan avatar Aug 30 '22 21:08 Davincisan

working with a friend of mine to help them set up FGA, and it mostly works but it is unable to spam NP's, looked at his phone had has quite a bit of black bars, hoping you could fix this Screenshot_20220830-202206

Mordred0131366 avatar Aug 31 '22 03:08 Mordred0131366

@Mordred0131366 Device name?

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 05:08 reconman

I want to play on my Samsung Galaxy Note S20 Ultra without the notch showing. I hate seeing the notch when I play, and I want to stop showing full screen (with notch showing) while using FGA, then having to switch it back to not show when I want to play for myself.

I change this by setting to FGO/FGA to fullscreen, then setting the camera cutout in the options -> fullscreen app -> camera cutout to:

FGO NA and JP, I have set this to Hide camera cutout. FGA app, I have also set it to Hide Camera cutout.

Of course, what happens is, the screen size is different than expected by FGA because there is a black bar, so screen presses sometimes work, sometimes not.

Attached below is a screenshot of my play area. I think I measured it correctly and have set my custom game area to: Left 67 and 0,0,0

Based on testing this seems to be working but I want to make sure my screen measurement makes sense. I couldn't find a good description on how to measure (I'm sure it is somewhere, I just couldn't find it) so I based it off of a couple of threads where screen shots were shared and official responses had the custom game area information.

I also understand that if I keep it this way, when I run FGA I need to keep the black bar on the left, as flipping the screen will mess with the offset. I am fine with this.

Screenshot_20220831-081047_FateGO 5320

slerch666 avatar Aug 31 '22 17:08 slerch666

@slerch666 So far every Samsung user was able to get rid of their black bars.

Your left offset is 68, you can rotate your screen all you want with the current FGA version.

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 17:08 reconman

@Mordred0131366 Device name?

Oh, my bad, it's a pixel 6

Mordred0131366 avatar Aug 31 '22 17:08 Mordred0131366

Thanks for verification!

I can get rid of the black bars, but ONLY if I leave the camera notch showing, which I do not like playing with. It annoys me that the notch is there and sometimes blocks a tiny bit of art, so I hide the camera notch, which adds that bar you see in the screen shot.

Thank you again! Really appreciate all you do here!

slerch666 avatar Aug 31 '22 17:08 slerch666

@slerch666 I'm planning on adding a new setting for automatically applying the notch because now a few users have black bars in 3-button navigation mode. That would replace measuring the black bars in the future for situations like yours.

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 19:08 reconman

@Mordred0131366 left=169, right=51

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 19:08 reconman

I wrote it in the description above, now a bot will measure the black bars for you if you post an image. The only limitation is that the black bars must not be covered by anything.

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 19:08 reconman

Pixel 5A

Screenshot_20220831-155956

Cithriaa avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 Cithriaa

Pixel 5A

Screenshot_20220831-160642

Cithriaa avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 Cithriaa

@musaabali Your offsets are left: 368, right: 2025, top: 1041, bottom: 34

This can't be right 😰

vybze avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 vybze

@musaabali I'll update the description with your first screenshot to warn users about errors with dark screens.

I'll check why your second screenshot didn't work.

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 reconman

@musaabali Your offsets are left: 201, right: 65, top: 0, bottom: 0

github-actions[bot] avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 github-actions[bot]

Reason was that the black borders weren't blackest black. I adjusted the black threshold in the script.

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 reconman

Thank you. If you use the picture at the top of the page, could the ID be cropped or covered?

Cithriaa avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 Cithriaa

@musaabali Done.

reconman avatar Aug 31 '22 21:08 reconman

Screenshot_20220831-184030_FateGO Samsung Galaxy tab s7 FE

sayyid011 avatar Aug 31 '22 23:08 sayyid011

it cant go hire than 999

sayyid011 avatar Aug 31 '22 23:08 sayyid011

@reconman @sayyid011 Your offsets are left=1117, right=1444, top=1599, bottom=2 can i have this fix?

sayyid011 avatar Sep 01 '22 00:09 sayyid011