SUPIR icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
SUPIR copied to clipboard

Add timeout to `requests` calls

Open pixeeai opened this issue 1 year ago • 4 comments

Many developers will be surprised to learn that requests library calls do not include timeouts by default. This means that an attempted request could hang indefinitely if no connection is established or if no data is received from the server.

The requests documentation suggests that most calls should explicitly include a timeout parameter. This codemod adds a default timeout value in order to set an upper bound on connection times and ensure that requests connect or fail in a timely manner. This value also ensures the connection will timeout if the server does not respond with data within a reasonable amount of time.

While timeout values will be application dependent, we believe that this codemod adds a reasonable default that serves as an appropriate ceiling for most situations.

Our changes look like the following:

 import requests
 
- requests.get("http://example.com")
+ requests.get("http://example.com", timeout=60)
More reading

Powered by: pixeebot (codemod ID: pixee:python/add-requests-timeouts)

pixeeai avatar Apr 01 '24 16:04 pixeeai

FYI - This change was autogenerated from a new trending GitHub app - called Pixeebot. A code-quality GitHub App; like Dependabot, but for source code.

pixeeai avatar Apr 01 '24 16:04 pixeeai

FYI - This change was autogenerated from a new trending GitHub app - called Pixeebot. A code-quality GitHub App; like Dependabot, but for source code.

60 second is very low in some cases

what is default timeout?

FurkanGozukara avatar Apr 01 '24 16:04 FurkanGozukara

@FurkanGozukara :wave: I'm Dan, one of the developers on the pixee team. Great question! Since therequests library does not have a default timeout it's going to hang until it gets a response, this could be a few seconds to several minutes. This PR suggests 60 seconds as a default(as it may be good enough for 95% of use cases). As you pointed out, that may be on the lower side in some cases. If you find that to be the case for you, we recommend increasing that value as needed.

dunningdan avatar Apr 01 '24 20:04 dunningdan