spatial-framework-for-hadoop icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
spatial-framework-for-hadoop copied to clipboard

Allow projection change with ST_Transform

Open PanierAvide opened this issue 10 years ago • 7 comments

First of all, thanks for this useful framework. Currently, it doesn't support projection change, you can only change the SRID in metadata but it doesn't modify object coordinates in returned data. Adding a function with similar to ST_Transform in Postgis (see http://postgis.net/docs/ST_Transform.html) would be very useful, for example for creating buffers in a metric projection.

PanierAvide avatar Oct 09 '15 21:10 PanierAvide

Cross-reference https://github.com/Esri/geometry-api-java/issues/64

randallwhitman avatar Oct 09 '15 21:10 randallwhitman

Maybe related: #83

randallwhitman avatar Mar 02 '16 23:03 randallwhitman

I would be also very interested in this feature, as well willing to help. I guess this could be implemented by adding an existing library for projections such as proj4j or cts. Are there any plans to support ST_Transform in the future?

chaosmail avatar Nov 10 '16 17:11 chaosmail

Are there any plans to support ST_Transform in the future?

We [Esri-Members] currently have no plans that I know of to work on that ourselves. This is Open-Source and accepts contributions.

randallwhitman avatar Nov 10 '16 19:11 randallwhitman

Cross-reference https://geonet.esri.com/thread/186465-geometry-vs-geography

randallwhitman avatar Nov 30 '16 19:11 randallwhitman

Side note relating to above-referenced proj4j - the ~Esri UC 2018 Q&A~ states that Esri is "funding a portion of the work to enhance/update PROJ4" (under "What are Esri's contributions to the open source community?")

randallwhitman avatar Jul 11 '18 21:07 randallwhitman

Discussion on #186 is more detailed, so I'll mark this one a duplicate of that one.

randallwhitman avatar Sep 30 '22 04:09 randallwhitman