Advanced Rocketry Fuel Loader only accepts Advanced Rocketry Rocket Fuel

[BranDynamite]

Modpack version 1.83

Issue The Crystallizer Multiblock no longer require 2 coils but instead a fluid input hatch and a fluid output hatch in place of the coils

Logs https://i.imgur.com/DA0mlro.png

[BranDynamite]

Also the Rolling machine multiblock is just broken, all the block placements are completely messed up

[NielsPilgaard]

Sounds like it just changed? Do they still work? Possible duplicate of #1943

[BranDynamite]

well maybe it has been changed, but the crystallizer does not have any fluid crafting recipes. The crystallizer and rolling machine still work. Also I don't know if I should make a separate issue for this, but the fuel loader isn't accepting any liquids

[NielsPilgaard]

Hmm, sounds like a separate issue, I'll change this one to the Fuel Loader thingie.

[NielsPilgaard]

The Rocket Fluid loader does accept fluids, I can't reproduce the issue.

[BranDynamite]

Are you on version 1.83? Also I do not see any of the side configs in the gui. Here are some screenshots showing the fuel loader not accepting liquid oxygen or starlight https://i.imgur.com/E1UaiEd.png https://i.imgur.com/Bfna9Kj.png

[NielsPilgaard]

Yes I'm on version 1.83 Are you using the Rocket Fuel Loader? The Fuel Station label in the screenshots suggest otherwise.

[BranDynamite]

actually I meant to say fueling station, as you cannot load fuel into the rocket using the rocket fluid loader

[NielsPilgaard]

I wonder what the Rocket Fluid Loader does :P

You are sorta correct, the Fueling Station only accepts Advanced Rocketry Rocket Fuel at the moment, it should accept more.

[BranDynamite]

Is there a config file for what fuels it accepts?

[NielsPilgaard]

Yep, see here: https://github.com/NillerMedDild/Enigmatica2Expert/commit/86b75b776198b7a43ac3eb1bfdddd431510c6503

[msparkles]

Outputs the following with above fix:

[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Start registering liquid rocket fuels
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Registering fluid rocketfuel;2 as rocket monopropellant
[19:28:15] [Server thread/WARN] [advancedrocketry]: Fluid namerefinedfuel;2 is not a registered fluid!
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Registering fluid pyrotheum;2 as rocket monopropellant
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Registering fluid neutron;8 as rocket monopropellant
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Registering fluid ic2uu_matter;16 as rocket monopropellant
[19:28:15] [Server thread/WARN] [advancedrocketry]: Fluid nameliquidstarlight;3 is not a registered fluid!
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Registering fluid hydrogen as rocket bipropellant
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Registering fluid oxygen as rocket oxidizer
[19:28:15] [Server thread/INFO] [advancedrocketry]: Finished registering liquid rocket fuels

With that, liquid starlight and refined fuel do not work.

Also, I'm not familiar with AR, but shouldn't liquid oxygen work, too?

[msparkles]

Correct config:

S:rocketFuels <
    rocketfuel;2
    refined_fuel;2
    pyrotheum;2
    neutron;8
    ic2uu_matter;16
    astralsorcery.liquidstarlight;3
 >

[AntsForBreakfast]

I can load blazing pyrotheum no problem but cant fly to luna with a rocket

[dooms247]

The corrected config leaves out Mekanism Liquid Oxygen, which the questbook mentions you can use.

[msparkles]

I did ask about Liquid Oxygen, but it remained unanswered

[NielsPilgaard]

Right, I'll get that re-added too :)

[Terra-B-Welch]

has this been addressed at all? Having just gotten into advanced rocketry I'm wondering, if the server owner adds in the fix mentioned above to the server config, will it work?

[NielsPilgaard]

has this been addressed at all? Having just gotten into advanced rocketry I'm wondering, if the server owner adds in the fix mentioned above to the server config, will it work?

It will yes.

[Arithmion]

Question about this: The original mod uses the electrolyser to create hydrogen and oxygen, then you have two options: Create the bipropellant engine and use both the liquid hydrogen and the liquid oxygen to fly, or use the chemical reactor to create rocket fuel for the monopropellant engine. I saw above that you were planning on adding oxygen in as a viable fuel like the other fuels. Was the intention in this modpack to change the default behavior to an easier behavior, so that only liquid oxygen is needed as a monopropellant? Or was the intention to use liquid oxygen + hydrogen as a bipropellant fuel? The config file lists hydrogen as the only viable bipropellant fuel, so the liquid oxygen may need to be added there rather than the rocket fuels list mentioned by Mg138 (a few lines above it).

If the intention is to have the oxygen be a bipropellant fuel, I recommend changing the QuestBook to clarify that Liquid Oxygen and Hydrogen are viable bipropellant fuels, and either recommending that the player visit the wiki (http://arwiki.dmodoomsirius.me/AdvancedRocketry/1.12.2/blocks/RocketEngine.php) or adding this line into the QuestBook (directly from the wiki): There are two types of engines each with a basic and advanced engine. Monopropellant uses 2 mB/t of rocket fuel. Bipropellant uses 1mB/t each of hydrogen and oxygen and requires 1 of each tank on the rocket.

Please also note that if the intention is to have the player use the bipropellant engine, this requires more titanium, which will likely force the player to use the Advanced Metallurgic Fabricator from Modular Machinery.

Thank you so much, I love your pack!

Advanced Rocketry

The Official Advanced Rocketry Wiki

[NielsPilgaard]

Iirc the bipropellant engine wasn't implemented when we made the quests :P Sounds like liquid oxygen shouldn't be a viable monopropellant fuel now, we'll get that sorted 👍... one day, hopefully

[Arithmion]

After further research, I learned that the bipropellant fuel list is only supposed to contain hydrogen, and the oxidizer is in a separate list a few lines below it. So as it stands now, nothing is needed to make liquid oxygen work with bipropellant engines, but it still doesn't work as a monopropellant of course. (The mekanism oxygen doesn't work, only the nuclearcraft/AdvRocketry.) Seeing as this is the case, I would personally suggest removing the liquid oxygen from the questbook list of monopropellant fuels completely, now that bipropellant has been added, and just implementing Mg138's suggestion. Sorry for any obnoxiousness my previous post caused!

[toastonrye]

Correct config:

S:rocketFuels <
    rocketfuel;2
    refined_fuel;2
    pyrotheum;2
    neutron;8
    ic2uu_matter;16
    astralsorcery.liquidstarlight;3
 >

I updated my advancedRocketry.cfg and restarted my server but the fueling station still doesn't take astral starlight? v1.83 of the modpack.

Edit: Originally I used this: https://github.com/EnigmaticaModpacks/Enigmatica2Expert/commit/86b75b776198b7a43ac3eb1bfdddd431510c6503 But what is pasted above works

[GrimReaper1982]

Hello there,

i just found this threat before i was reporting the issue with the rocket fuels in 1.83. Since i found out yesterday that the rockets vom AR only accept the AR rocket fuel, i was testing things out and looked into my old E2E Versions (1.79a for example).

If you replace the following lines in the AR config for the accepted fuels, all the mentioned fuels will work again in 1.83:

---

List of fluid names for fluids that can be used as rocket fuel

S:rocketFuels <
    rocketfuel
    rocket_fuel
    refined_fuel
    pyrotheum
    neutron
    liquidoxygen
    ic2uu_matter
    astralsorcery.liquidstarlight
 >

---

I dont know if the ";" als delimiter is a problem. This needs to be tested still, but the lines ive posted work 100% :)

/cheers