CommandHelper icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
CommandHelper copied to clipboard

Static analysis exception "Procedure cannot be resolved" when procedure exists

Open Anatoliy057 opened this issue 5 years ago • 3 comments

Static analysis will throw exception with message "Procedure cannot be resolved" for all user procedures in this case:

# main.ms
proc _path() {
    return('test-2.ms')
}

proc _test() {
    console('test')
}

include('test-1.ms')
# test-1.ms
include(_path())
# test-2.ms
_test()
ms.lang.IncludeException: There was a compile error when trying to include the script at C:\Users\A-y57\Dev\minecraft\plugins\CommandHelper\test-2.ms
Procedure cannot be resolved: _test :: test-2.ms:1
        at <<include test-1.ms>>:C:\Users\A-y57\Dev\minecraft\plugins\CommandHelper\test-1.ms:1.9
        at <<main code>>:C:\Users\A-y57\Dev\minecraft\plugins\CommandHelper\main.ms:9.2

If replace _path with 'test-2.ms' - everything works If disable static analysis, everything works

Anatoliy057 avatar Aug 11 '20 13:08 Anatoliy057

You cannot use procedures defined in dynamic includes (e.g. include(arg) where arg isn't a hard-coded string) outside of those includes. Static analysis happens at compile time, and dynamic includes are simply not known at that stage. The solution is to hard-code all paths in your includes, where you can also use include_dir() to include all files in a certain directory in a static way.

Pieter12345 avatar Aug 11 '20 14:08 Pieter12345

As a side note, keep in mind that when using dynamic includes, static analysis can no longer analyze these included files because they are not known at compile time. This means that you might get some exceptions in runtime that static analysis would have otherwise caught earlier (in compile time) otherwise.

Pieter12345 avatar Aug 11 '20 14:08 Pieter12345

I would like to attach a (suppressable) compiler warning if dynamic includes are used, with basic information about what kinds of error they may cause, so that things like this can be understood without having to file a bug report. So let's leave this open as a placeholder for adding that compiler warning.

LadyCailin avatar Aug 13 '20 15:08 LadyCailin