lightning icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lightning copied to clipboard

For an invoice generated via an offer, decodepay isn't working anymore, while pay still is

Open hMsats opened this issue 1 year ago • 5 comments

Issue and Steps to Reproduce

Lightning node 1: lightning-cli offer any test returns:

lno1pgz8getnwstzzq5gsfzq98zep9vnqw9tr8exn9ruwgx7xs37fyterdrv0jf0wcnekc

Lightning node 2: lightning-cli fetchinvoice offer=lno1pgz8getnwstzzq5gsfzq98zep9vnqw9tr8exn9ruwgx7xs37fyterdrv0jf0wcnekc amount_msat=200000 returns:

{
   "invoice": "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",
   "changes": {}
}

Lightning node 2: lightning-cli decodepay 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 returns:

{
   "code": -1,
   "message": "Invalid bolt11: Bad bech32 string"
}

Lightning node 2: lightning-cli pay lni1qqgdwu2v5mqskzml6u80u2haalxruzsyw3jhxaqkyypg3qjyq2w9jz2exqu2kx0jdx28cusdudprujghjx6xclyj7a38ndjjqvps6szcyyp9uwjmywwmguzvqqujrhutf3rxhzr5pxr062tdnae8er3q06dsnvdqnqpg3qjyq2w9jz2exqu2kx0jdx28cusdudprujghjx6xclyj7a38ndsrpqzq4alcv65d6qaahfr4kyqv0at8pmtuxrqamcqx653hc8xlw2cszqkuvduq78d75tyhmgrdczy2kjefrl6yksf73yd6ft0waag405yaauqr9qsu2lf426qxupuj3d733nj4y7gsh2sjk5gzsq9s35nqw4g87wccyrsw0u60thk63n2rduhzltv85vr6pgsuqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqjqqqqqqqqqqqqq8fykt06c5sqqqqqpfqyvjap3j4gyz2np6nh8xdxzh5lnsas674cqga8wsftfxqstw285wze7k89lz4e02srqvx5pvppq2ygy3qzn3vsjkfs8z43nunfj378yr0rgglyj9u3k3k8eyhhvfumduzqjupanmexql7gj0whkplur993ze0hp3a8h4l7zqh83nexj4htn5t4zkau3tu9acljl8dyaqurwygg97yx093u8s2md8l26kkh2e9ylgg returns:

{
   "destination": "02888244029c5909593038ab19f269947c720de3423e491791b46c7c92f76279b6",
   "payment_hash": "9530ea77399a615e9f9c3b0d7ab8023a77412b498105b947a3859f58e5f8ab97",
   "created_at": 1689917890.076,
   "parts": 1,
   "amount_msat": 200000,
   "amount_sent_msat": 200000,
   "payment_preimage": "11db5d5a20c209c3565a25625228629d117f57e1272f6455b7cd2675bdda0fd9",
   "status": "complete"
}

For "normal invoices" decodepay is ok:

Lightning node 1: lightning-cli invoice 200000 bla bla returns:

{
   "payment_hash": "3a08ace3783e74d290e2609e290dd921b31d20b8e8bfcb85ddc359cd0bb86281",
   "expires_at": 1690523179,
   "bolt11": "lnbc2u1pjt5xatsp5pkk7a6k90pq4us94jdrhnrqj0dsy2460lxs29m2z5v4gj99rmsxspp58gy2ecmc8e6d9y8zvz0zjrweyxe36g9cazluhpwacdvu6zacv2qsdq9vfkxzxqyjw5qcqpjrzjqv7n3cr7y4qk9qs5eqvyeak9vgc3qkv8yd37nafckt69gdzp3ddu2zah4qqqg7sqqqqqqqqqqqqqphgq9q9qxpqysgq6mtf5m8zgtm3vmhdlvrjm089jtknk2reuweskvf2htk9radjtgf83a906qnhf9p594ul3sz6h562fptuup8kp2nqaupvmz2hmugyr7cqksqqhu",
   "payment_secret": "0dadeeeac578415e40b59347798c127b6045574ff9a0a2ed42a32a8914a3dc0d"
}

Lightning node 2: lightning-cli decodepay lnbc2u1pjt5xatsp5pkk7a6k90pq4us94jdrhnrqj0dsy2460lxs29m2z5v4gj99rmsxspp58gy2ecmc8e6d9y8zvz0zjrweyxe36g9cazluhpwacdvu6zacv2qsdq9vfkxzxqyjw5qcqpjrzjqv7n3cr7y4qk9qs5eqvyeak9vgc3qkv8yd37nafckt69gdzp3ddu2zah4qqqg7sqqqqqqqqqqqqqphgq9q9qxpqysgq6mtf5m8zgtm3vmhdlvrjm089jtknk2reuweskvf2htk9radjtgf83a906qnhf9p594ul3sz6h562fptuup8kp2nqaupvmz2hmugyr7cqksqqhu returns:

{
   "currency": "bc",
   "created_at": 1689918379,
   "expiry": 604800,
   "payee": "02888244029c5909593038ab19f269947c720de3423e491791b46c7c92f76279b6",
   "amount_msat": 200000,
   "description": "bla",
   "min_final_cltv_expiry": 18,
   "payment_secret": "0dadeeeac578415e40b59347798c127b6045574ff9a0a2ed42a32a8914a3dc0d",
   "features": "02024100",
   "routes": [
      [
         {
            "pubkey": "033d38e07e2541628214c8184cf6c562311059872363e9f538b2f45434418b5bc5",
            "short_channel_id": "767912x1146x0",
            "fee_base_msat": 0,
            "fee_proportional_millionths": 221,
            "cltv_expiry_delta": 40
         }
      ]
   ],
   "payment_hash": "3a08ace3783e74d290e2609e290dd921b31d20b8e8bfcb85ddc359cd0bb86281",
   "signature": "3045022100d6d69a6ce242f7166eedfb072dbce592ed3b2879e3b30b312abaec51f5b25a12022078f4afd0277494342d79f8c05abd34a4857ce04f60aa60ef02cd8957df1041fb"
}

While my bolt12 lightning game kept working, this made my hacked version of Spark-wallet stop working. That's how I noticed, although a bit late. I'm going to add decodepay into my game as an extra check (when this issue has been fixed).

getinfo output

"version": "v23.05-289-g5afd0ab",

hMsats avatar Jul 21 '23 06:07 hMsats