Edirom-Online icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Edirom-Online copied to clipboard

getAnnotationsOnPage.xql could return "wrong" data.

Open nikobeer opened this issue 9 years ago • 2 comments

It should be possible to exactly specify where annotations are gathered from. As I understand annotations are searched everywhere in '/db/contents/'? So if you have multiple MEI files with annotations you will possibly get "wrong" annotations (see l. 78).

Example from OPERA: working with two MEI files for prerelease final correction -> only "the first" (archived) MEI file is taken into account?

Further problem: This seems to be completely independent from getting annotations for the Annotations List and View? Here the correct file is found (specified). As a consequence you could get different annotations in annotation view compared to source view.

Would it be possible to centralize annotation management within Edirom?

nikobeer avatar Mar 29 '16 20:03 nikobeer

this is true, while the annotation list is populated from the work.mei the getAnnotationsOnPage searches for all mei:annot in prefs:edition_path

bwbohl avatar Mar 23 '21 10:03 bwbohl

I would suggest to define corresponding getAnnotations functions in the annotation module.

bwbohl avatar Mar 23 '21 10:03 bwbohl

this seems connected to #156 and #240

bwbohl avatar Nov 07 '24 09:11 bwbohl

@hizclick yet another one for the collection?

bwbohl avatar Nov 07 '24 09:11 bwbohl

@nikobeer, is this issue already resolved or how can we reproduce the issue?

hizclick avatar Dec 06 '24 15:12 hizclick