simple-tab-groups icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
simple-tab-groups copied to clipboard

Avoid triggering the downloads panel when STG backups are run in the background (Firefox 98+)

Open rubcap opened this issue 2 years ago • 7 comments

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. When the backup function in STG is enabled, it apparently triggers the download panel in Firefox v98+ to open as well. However, the panel doesn't show the created STG .JSON file, only older downloads. Firefox v98+ users using STG with the backup function enabled may be confused why the panel opens seemingly randomly.

Describe the solution you'd like STG backups don't trigger the download panel in Firefox at all. This is a background process that doesn't need my attention. And if they really must trigger the panel, I preferably want the panel to show the name/folder of the created JSON file.

Describe alternatives you've considered

  • Disabling the backup function in STG.
  • Manually setting browser.download.alwaysOpenPanel in about:config to FALSE.

Additional context Firefox v98 introduced a change in download management, making the download panel pop up after each finished download (unless you set browser.download.alwaysOpenPanel in about:config to FALSE) and making more use of the OS's default "Downloads" folder. This idea is to let users find and open their downloads more easily and interruption-free (although one could argue that popping up the panel every time is actually introducing interruptions?).

Thx in advance. Love your add-on!

rubcap avatar Mar 23 '22 21:03 rubcap

Wow thanks!

My download panel kept opening at "random" times and I had no idea why, it was getting really annoying. Now I know why. It's strange that the panel itself does not show any downloads, so there is no clue that it is STG making a backup in the background. I think I also have other add-ons that are saving stuff at regular scheduled intervals, so I guess they are also causing this issue...

SpaceClicker avatar Mar 24 '22 08:03 SpaceClicker

Yes, this is very annoying. Like @SpaceClicker said I thought this appears to be random but at some point I saw that there was a download finishing with something like "STG" in the name and therefore concluded it had to be the STG backup.

s0m3guy avatar Mar 25 '22 10:03 s0m3guy

I can confirm it is related to STG. I was recording my screen while it happened and it was one of the STG auto backup filenames that popped out for a moment, and then disappeared.

ShingenPizza avatar Apr 05 '22 04:04 ShingenPizza

Yeah, but that's not STG's fault, Mozilla is thinking about how to solve that. See https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1759231

nekohayo avatar Apr 12 '22 03:04 nekohayo

Now happily following this (and bug 1759231) to get this annoyance sorted out.

bryanpedini avatar Apr 20 '22 22:04 bryanpedini

Looks like this is fixed in FF101, which should be released at the end of May.

rddunphy avatar May 05 '22 13:05 rddunphy

Looks like this is fixed in FF101

FF 103.0.2 (64-bit) user here. issue still persists...

bryanpedini avatar Sep 08 '22 19:09 bryanpedini