WirelessPalaControl icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
WirelessPalaControl copied to clipboard

WPalaControl unstable

Open abcklaus opened this issue 10 months ago • 18 comments

Hi,

I am using the WPalaControl with Palazzetti "Marianne" stove. For any reason the WPalaControl seems to be unstable.

The uptime in the status indicates that the device is restarting. In this example the uptime is about 2h. Actually the last power cycle is about 20h ago ...

Image

In Home Assistant I am using the Palazzetti integration. Also here I am observing availability issues:

Image

I other issues I have seen that the power supply may be a problem. But after trying three different power supplies I am pretty sure that this is not the root cause.

Any Idea what I can do?

Thanks

Michael

abcklaus avatar Feb 02 '25 17:02 abcklaus

Hi,

This may happen if there is some Wifi connectivity issue. What is the percentage next to your wifi network in Config page?

Domochip avatar Feb 03 '25 10:02 Domochip

It’s 58%. Distance between access point and Domochip is about 5m.

abcklaus avatar Feb 03 '25 10:02 abcklaus

Could you try to expose it differently to increase Wifi reception. And check if that improves the situation.

Domochip avatar Feb 03 '25 10:02 Domochip

ok, thank you. I didn't expect that the quality of the wifi connection may cause issues like that.

In the meantime I did some tweaks in my environment and will observe.

abcklaus avatar Feb 03 '25 13:02 abcklaus

I did some tweaks in my wifi environment. The quality is now between 90 and 100%

Image

Today in the morning (07:40) I see that the uptime is again just 2h. Means that the device has restarted at about 05:00

Image

Is the wifi connection still an issue?

abcklaus avatar Feb 06 '25 06:02 abcklaus

Hi,

Before going more in technical research, is it possible for you to use the MQTT integration (native for this module)? I want to clarify if that come from HTTP endpoints or not

Domochip avatar Feb 07 '25 06:02 Domochip

ok, no problem. I have deactivated the Palazzetti integration in HomeAssistant and activated the MQ integration.

abcklaus avatar Feb 07 '25 07:02 abcklaus

The MQTT Integration is active for some days now.

But there is no improvement. The uptime is still just some hours. The max value I have seen is 1d.

In HA the stove becomes unavailable from time to time.

abcklaus avatar Feb 11 '25 21:02 abcklaus

Hi,

Sorry I was off these last two weeks. mm, sounds like an hardware problem. Which WPalaControl HW version do you have (1.1 or 2.0) (it's written on the box and on the PCB). Did you build it yourself or bought it ready to use and where?

Domochip avatar Feb 23 '25 16:02 Domochip

Hi,

I am using Version 2.0.. I bought it at Tindie.

abcklaus avatar Feb 23 '25 17:02 abcklaus

Have you bought it from me or from DIYPala?

Domochip avatar Mar 03 '25 14:03 Domochip

I bought it from you. Order number is #515307

abcklaus avatar Mar 04 '25 19:03 abcklaus

ok Do you see a kind of pattern of the restart? Next steps would be to monitor via USB from a computer and flash some test firmware (going deeper then). Is it something you are comfortable with? otherwise a return/refund is always possible.

Domochip avatar Mar 05 '25 07:03 Domochip

Hi, yes, flashing some firmware is no problem. I am familiar with that.

I have here an Lolin D1 mini from another project. What do you think - is it worth to flash your firmware to check if the issue is located in the other D1 mini?

abcklaus avatar Mar 06 '25 06:03 abcklaus

yes, can be a good first test.

Domochip avatar Mar 06 '25 07:03 Domochip

I used a Lolin D1 Mini v4.0. I have compiled and flashed the firmware with vscode/platform io. For and reason this device seems not to be compatible. As soon as i have connected my stove, the stove Shows the error E0004. So I moved back to the original D1 mini.

abcklaus avatar Mar 06 '25 20:03 abcklaus

ok, found the reason why my D1 mini is not working. The pins are soldered on the other side of the board.

Image

abcklaus avatar Mar 07 '25 15:03 abcklaus

ok, found a workaround ;-)

Image

Let's see how the new D1 mini will behave ...

abcklaus avatar Mar 07 '25 16:03 abcklaus

During the last days I have monitored the device. Unfortunately switching the D1mini did not help. I am observing the instability. In most cases the device does not have an uptime larger than several hours.

abcklaus avatar Mar 22 '25 18:03 abcklaus