dockstation icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
dockstation copied to clipboard

Open-source?

Open STaRDoGG opened this issue 6 years ago • 19 comments

@igor-lemon , Just curious, how come you don't upload the source here on GH so others can (potentially) contribute, and move the development along a lot faster? It's been close to half a year since the last release, and it seems to be a software that people are liking to use, but dev is moving at a crawl.

STaRDoGG avatar Sep 11 '19 13:09 STaRDoGG

Agreed, looks like is not open source, since sources are not available. Why is used an Apache license if you are not uploading the sources? Wanted to debug some issues I'm having but I found no way to debug

cronopio avatar Sep 18 '19 16:09 cronopio

Ouch, I am curious if this is even acceptable use of GitHub usage terms, apparently is use of github to host a closed source project.

ssbarnea avatar Oct 15 '19 18:10 ssbarnea

I also just wanted to get the source as this app wants its users to login now, and I wanted to check what my credentials are really needed for. :) @igor-lemon, could you please comment on this and provide the respective sources? Thank you for this app and for your help! :+1:

redtux avatar Nov 02 '19 16:11 redtux

+1, where is the source?

relrod avatar Nov 04 '19 08:11 relrod

They seem to have no intention to OSS this, with is a pitty. They just place the GitHub badge prominently on their website to trick people into thinking it is. But it is not, see #174.

luckydonald avatar Nov 11 '19 23:11 luckydonald

I think @igor-lemon is keeping it closed source so that in the future he can make it more business oriented and make this a product that can generate a good outcome. I don't know if that's good or not but I still would love if this was open source. Maybe open sourcing it opens up new opportunities you wouldn't have with it being closed source, given the current trend of all things open source.

jamezrin avatar Nov 12 '19 20:11 jamezrin

It definitely appears that keeping it closed source is holding back the software's progress.

STaRDoGG avatar Nov 13 '19 03:11 STaRDoGG

Hi guys! I wrote about it many times, the current DockStation is proprietary and we don't have plans to make it open source. The current GitHub repository just for support and user's issues. I apologizeе for not answering for a long time.

igor-lemon avatar Jan 02 '20 16:01 igor-lemon

@bristea which section?

luckydonald avatar Jan 02 '20 17:01 luckydonald

RIP DockStation

ssbarnea avatar Dec 13 '20 10:12 ssbarnea

@igor-lemon can you share your plan?

https://twitter.com/dock_station current status: 1 release every 2 years..

5 days ago in #274 you wrote that you work alone now, and just few hours per week. That is a big difference compared to 2016, when you quit your job to create DockStation. https://medium.com/@dockstation/dockstation-and-why-we-created-it-6ecb800fe067

In 2017, #50 you wrote there will be a community and enterprise edition. Is it still the plan?

Pasqualle avatar Mar 28 '21 09:03 Pasqualle

@Pasqualle These plans are no longer relevant. I don't want to predict anything yet and talk about plans because according to the plans I should have already released the release more than a year ago. :D The 95% of the release was ready for a long time, but I stumbled on one very complex feature (long syntax + short syntax with AST support).

igor-lemon avatar Mar 28 '21 11:03 igor-lemon

I should have written why I am asking about a plan. If you do not have a business plan with DockStation any more, and you do not receive any income from it, why the source code is still not open? Why do you prefer to keep it proprietary?

Pasqualle avatar Mar 28 '21 15:03 Pasqualle

DockStation @dock_station·Sep 10, 2020 Hi there! We haven't published anything for a long time. I just want to say that the project is not dead and we're still working on it. We'll publish a very large update soon.

https://twitter.com/dock_station/status/1304170378936422402?s=20

soon? when then?

eshirvana avatar Jun 21 '21 04:06 eshirvana

Looks like the original project was kitematic, isn't it?

barakethan avatar Jul 17 '21 13:07 barakethan

For any future readers, let's be honest; this project is abandonware, regardless of what the author keeps saying. The repo should be archived.

The only way to get a modern version of this app would be to clone it from scratch as best you can, and then build forward from there.

STaRDoGG avatar Jul 17 '21 13:07 STaRDoGG

I moved away from this , I use free web- based open source app instead now:

Portainer.io

eshirvana avatar Jul 17 '21 14:07 eshirvana

https://github.com/DockStation/dockstation/issues/280#issuecomment-1090269898

As I understand the current project will not be open source. Igor is willing to create a new project, even as open source in case there is a strong sponsor.

Pasqualle avatar Dec 20 '22 12:12 Pasqualle

@Pasqualle Don't bother, this project is as good as dead, we have https://podman-desktop.io/ which is open-source.

ssbarnea avatar Dec 20 '22 12:12 ssbarnea