dfips
dfips copied to clipboard
DeFiCh
DFIP: payout 50% of DEX-fee to DUSD loans & introduce real negative interest rates
DFIP Overview
- Requester(s): @kuegi @DanielZirkel
- Reddit discussion thread (optional): https://www.reddit.com/r/defiblockchain/comments/wfs4zx/more_incentives_for_dusd_loans_to_reduce_dexfee/ and https://www.reddit.com/r/defiblockchain/comments/wgb6cc/additional_explanations_to_my_learnings_from_the/
- Proposal fee (50 DFI) txid: 3b96249a5b21e0af4ac106771d1d73a649e5498ef376d99cb4c4923acfcca42e
Describe your proposal
For details please follow the provided reddit posts.
We propose 2 improvements for a long term stabilization of the DUSD price. Point 1 (DEX fee payout) also provides a possible short term solution to the DEX fee and massive positive price impact on DFI:
- payout 50% of the DEX-stabilization-fee to holders of DUSD loans and adaption of DEX fee formula
- introduce real negative interest rates on DUSD in case of a DUSD premium and permanently deactivating the DUSD-Futureswap.
Payout 50% of the DEX-stabilization-fee to holders of DUSD loans
The main reason for the DUSD discount is an imbalance between the circulating DUSD and the DFI price. There are too many DUSD in the system, so to stabilize the price, we need to change that imbalance.
The payout of 50% of the DEX-fee incentivizes the creation of DUSD loans. Since the creation of DUSD loans requires (at least) 150% collateral, more loans actually take liquidity out of the market. 50% of this liquidity must be DUSD/DFI, but numbers show that it will likely be far more than that.
This leads to 2 positive effects: due to the increased amount of DUSD loans, the high DEX-stabilization-fee will be reduced. And due to the reduced DUSD and DFI liquidity in the system, there will be a strong positive impact on the DUSD and DFI price. A rising DFI price also leads to more DUSD being locked in the DUSD-DFI pool which takes even more DUSD out of circulation.
Since this is not yet implemented, we propose the following process until it can be implemented in the consensus:
The payout should be "simulated" via negative interest rates on DUSD loans (possible in v3). With DEXFee30 being the paid DEX-stabilization-fee from the last 30 days and DUSDLoans being the maximum amount of DUSD loans in the last 24 hours, the negative interest should be calculated as
negInterest = (DEXFee30 * 0.5 * 12.16) / DUSDLoans
The negInterest should be updated every day at the same block as the DEXFee is updated right now. Also the same procedure as the DEX-fee (announcing one day in advance of the new value)
For the first 7 days after activation the used DEXFee30 should be set to max(3 500 000, DEXFee30). This is because we burned 3.5 mio DUSD in the 30 days before August 12th and this makes the effects in the first week after activation predictable.
For day 8-14 after activation the used DEXFee30 should be set to max(DEXFee30, 3500000 * (14-day)/6 + DEXFee30*(day-8)/6) to smooth out the transition between the initial payout and the actual DEXFee in case the first weeks effects already lead to a strongly reduced DEXFee and/or DUSD burn.
As a reference: 3.5 mio DEXFee30 with 10 mio DUSD loans (current amount of DUSD loans) would result in 212% APR paid out to those loans. With 100 mio DUSD loans it would still be 21% APR.
The new formula for the DEX-stabilization-fee should start at 30% algo ratio and be calculated as
DEXFee = (2 ^ ((AlgoRatio - 30)/10) - 1) / 4
Introduce real negative interest rates on DUSD
In case of a DUSD premium, the interest rate of DUSD should become negative and not be capped at 0. The DUSD interest rate should be calculated as interestRate = - ((2 ^ (DUSDPremium/10) - 1)*20). Since this is increasing strongly above 5% premium it should provide a strong enough incentive to create more DUSD loans and sell them at a profit.
Therefore the FutureSwap should no longer be needed and can be permanently deactivated. This also reduces the risk of getting too many algo DUSD into the system again.
How does this DFIP benefit the DeFiChain community?
More collateral locked up in the vaults provides positive price pressure on both DFI and DUSD, benefiting the whole community in increased prices and a strengthened DUSD.
Negative interest rates instead of the DUSD FutureSwap provide a more stable and less attackable DUSD-peg by providing a healthier algo ratio.
Non-obligation
I understand that vote of confidence for DFIP carries no obligations by any developers to implement the proposals. DeFiChain is a community projects. Pull requests can be submitted by community and reserved to be evaluated for safety and general community acceptance.
Where will the additional DUSD from negative interest rate on step 2 come from . (should be capped to the max of the burned ones?)
This is absolutely crucial and timely. Thanks again for the initiative @kuegi @DanielZirkel
Where will the additional DUSD from negative interest rate on step 2 come from . (should be capped to the max of the burned ones?)
negative interest is created from the blockchain. Can be seen as newly created algorithmic DUSD. IMHO it must not be capped. In reality it is capped by the created DUSD and won't create extreme amounts. (specially compared to the corresponding DUSD loans.) It definitly creates less algorithmic DUSD and in a far healthier way than DFI burn or futureSwap.
Lets do it! When is the next voting round and could be be implemented straight after that?
Where will the additional DUSD from negative interest rate on step 2 come from . (should be capped to the max of the burned ones?)
negative interest is created from the blockchain. Can be seen as newly created algorithmic DUSD. IMHO it must not be capped. In reality it is capped by the created DUSD and won't create extreme amounts. (specially compared to the corresponding DUSD loans.) It definitly creates less algorithmic DUSD and in a far healthier way than DFI burn or futureSwap.
Wouldn't it be better to shorten the loan? Consider both dangerous. More inflation to combat the effects of inflation.
Where will the additional DUSD from negative interest rate on step 2 come from . (should be capped to the max of the burned ones?)
negative interest is created from the blockchain. Can be seen as newly created algorithmic DUSD. IMHO it must not be capped. In reality it is capped by the created DUSD and won't create extreme amounts. (specially compared to the corresponding DUSD loans.) It definitly creates less algorithmic DUSD and in a far healthier way than DFI burn or futureSwap.
Wouldn't it be better to shorten the loan? Consider both dangerous. More inflation to combat the effects of inflation.
its not more inflation fighting inflation. its inflation if the demand is higher than the supply (DUSD premium). so inflation to fight deflation.
and the interest reduces the needed payback and it can't go above the size of the loan. once the accumulated negative interest reaches the size of the loan, the loan is gone and no more negative interest accumulates.
Where will the additional DUSD from negative interest rate on step 2 come from . (should be capped to the max of the burned ones?)
negative interest is created from the blockchain. Can be seen as newly created algorithmic DUSD. IMHO it must not be capped. In reality it is capped by the created DUSD and won't create extreme amounts. (specially compared to the corresponding DUSD loans.) It definitly creates less algorithmic DUSD and in a far healthier way than DFI burn or futureSwap.
Wouldn't it be better to shorten the loan? Consider both dangerous. More inflation to combat the effects of inflation.
its not more inflation fighting inflation. its inflation if the demand is higher than the supply (DUSD premium). so inflation to fight deflation.
and the interest reduces the needed payback and it can't go above the size of the loan. once the accumulated negative interest reaches the size of the loan, the loan is gone and no more negative interest accumulates.
Agree. My misstake. I had the current (inflated) situation in mind. Your solution would maybee lead to dUSD premium.
signmessage 8VKs5jqADhwRTHVXsf8hhMmJm5r8FpWF7h dfip-2208-a-yes
IBjYKA8+MvyOdecjdL7lNrQnhsRbfK2P/EiO/bpzn3N+dFiUS4116VQ/SQh2cMphyx6EsKprbCmhjF0Ekw9NRGg=
signmessage 8P24qRzccs9FJXkqrrzPZGa2aNXxqBkrmb "dfip-2208-a-yes" HyiS/Wd3iPEy1AG5QXKjQ7wTF80UiTJSegLILF7nwtmyTlaRMQds0/MsVJ8c+OVETGJjthKfO+2g8MdoUa36iV8=
signmessage 8cXiD6ye5SPy1EqUF7PiyqQsWsJs5mtMuJ dfip-2208-a-yes IIA9VNI3LylkQzWcp0sGI02braGC9Hk/GKgU5/9c0gKBGhET9rgT/M+x/2tYaS+IHFiH7Dy9N4y4s9GMiY8wsyw=
signmessage 8cXiD6ye5SPy1EqUF7PiyqQsWsJs5mtMuJ dfip-2208-a-yes IIA9VNI3LylkQzWcp0sGI02braGC9Hk/GKgU5/9c0gKBGhET9rgT/M+x/2tYaS+IHFiH7Dy9N4y4s9GMiY8wsyw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MXn7LR75PA8dFny44d1aJHU41LudvA5YP dfip-2208-a-yes H5tLHWU6blzTuZpoa9OoShc21U04lufssyDRgJZGvL0RPeH18NNwwAGRmMoOGMTU5/V/6ByA7dNI+JfQuo3z25Q= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cRvM1FUZGxJMX2t57rHiFRMpQYri5j88w dfip-2208-a-yes H0n7Gmvygj1AdhqWrCEXn9U/Fh3A0eveBvoQ2kVBD+vrRkwJfxO1WYE/RWt3C0bvbTPFUQT3T2n684g0f6bKFjs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8XdPrkNzxqb7itMh4Wqv9DRorgXCmNT2mK "dfip-2208-a-yes" H6hi0uhuC1wuGXoj7oHBlIhvgzGH0tJmic8LRSSjmKLBADUvmDRo5qW6Zv01eeeKHhECjU/VFtZCIgH79kOCRas= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZrvphYmSaoDPeQoN2VKDRVYmTtzUbHy6v "dfip-2208-a-yes" IG+vMSO4iuOJxM+sDrrUQDHXRsYITXku/vxbFobZTQ8NUAadObixEQvEWhq+1+vMgglN4NrpiWcsTNdqY/Gq53w= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KEDzEw9NrnHBopKarB7HqzogNABobMsxX "dfip-2208-a-yes" IDZSRosoyiNh6qjLFe+BTGQOR33BQBSxBZ0c/mzAh1XNLvP6xWQHDvgnjNvzYYC/MJFfs1ImvuONgazvFFNcfeU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8R1Y2kRmrrfh46Q2ZVWNsZ1889Vir44x7b "dfip-2208-a-yes" IG94fVsy6xeFeZLcI0GcM6ZsbkFTfERNjWZvCwRQWqfpOz97ot1QOyrIaTFK6YegDw41186PO4D30ONPK2uTols= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HPnsynQRTgSEi5QjZXq5CSWDmYn83C5rR "dfip-2208-a-yes" H4Y7x/KKeN71aUt6PYUW3Uuj9H/TWC9hzjjbILBRUcl6clw1+Aa0/DXH0xw0TZHPvN
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Zg2ohcLuvCpotCu7SmEDdksdxEaMKZrKP "dfip-2208-a-yes" IMfbQxgK9RobL6xwR6AkIXKbjOjc8hYNZB6m/QTN2Z1VXf8QSpPPTVSq1ZLC02TAMSaItTwX45vGnZJwL9ZWLzg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H6fv2NtJQ9Q559rXjkzdZkMceQzdKgyTo "dfip-2208-a-yes" IP8eilF1F0MlXW2RPHDaVDI+GftNWlKKAaNx1Eweh3CmGKZRzz0ZpHdo7w9Upv7gixutLdhbtzJYfYTQhypUk1w= $ defi-cli signmessage 8LLNJSfspvTQ4ygY9vMYyhuuph5ifzchJy "dfip-2208-a-yes" H9MWlbNx3a8bdsulMtAhNyhs/L+UxZ+gVhokPNq8UMNlW2vyH/DOx5HZtvN22d9UJauRv8BbpJmsnUsmPK3f6wU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WhqJyDLXLiJgePFTVkUHpRZ9CfFaoQNLL "dfip-2208-a-yes" IOl4qlPUo9+J6ABL9VuHhf8jDaZuNHttlFnTZ673qNQPHZ/s8jJruc8JCNksviLAVnyXLU8G3tmT+KhfkVQp/l0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8LhSrRi4mpVtjY7R7reGT3Uv5embLfRYLt "dfip-2208-a-yes" H1lMfhYureIXUkD2Vp8/DbZBtJSRWhyvr2KlvlQtg6MGYrj40fxON0OuYNk3d/cgZYElwGx3pLbwZzpw0LVG0e0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8JNF4s8E6awasceNvFVwfDwkVtMx8CD6yE "dfip-2208-a-yes" IKfUZBaqmtp1VV3wGGMMvAGoihHZuN/KXgzQC87XnSCrbXWK7DrtWXgy0nY9wGP5SiJOaw4zdivCf9ffflzAGDU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WrWAoAxiVunh8myGioaCEyRa4jT9eXzhX "dfip-2208-a-yes" H84Af5gqNd5jaxHUxUrNJXN7S6FavqlVxbvjCXaZ+R+0AbwP8vTfTBs4Pbt5kkx9gdKNYDzJC1+p+vwVumQ+OAk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YFcW6UoxBoGLpNbmRsV38VRyfPiTyZXow "dfip-2208-a-yes" II+VVX9LyUyED5SZh/tG7iYjpLRLi0CN/Q8mQpD+K5wUSRGN9cjpeFQEp7kZnmh010GJcdXuWa7TWXNwJ0erW60= $ defi-cli signmessage 8P4CGnPt7r2nkxgY467rASz2f666xPK9ge "dfip-2208-a-yes" H2XHhwtnD634Aj+QVuwF/N8K8desCvnUNipv4esQg5+/dVHmh4ZEHyic29TyDkvNExHmoZg7Tigha+yn7WMy6aA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8RKgsRnAGBcmwouuFdSjMFitDNLH5qegY2 "dfip-2208-a-yes" H1cK7YSHnyVl025HqNvkX9MgK/0JYQPJj25aOTme+kdGaNkk/+WOQRF+MGIOv1KnngkaCKn7VD7VC48f59GOx2w= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dXgX2qd82eyF4qRUhanypMTrcvVf86rVN "dfip-2208-a-yes" IA82ZVrsvCF9Z0/wzLCv/gPPl5gVPFEjoWS1xFG4knAEZxUk+2cJXmgqInoXZ6cKn4lTNZ3LwSN97QrjaiThV/I= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Y8kN74DNNGPZbxDHCCzH5yNW4nM1kJhtd "dfip-2208-a-yes" IKMURvYyTTTv8SH6E/AQ4XHX0Bc37nd9qaBWb9YoCKmwae1xzz/MED29uJ49580APPLRcbPYTJPZD4ZLf+c0Pw8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8aHyACpxxie5jd8dyWBW1kRe3zEj5tfBJi "dfip-2208-a-yes" Hz0AKike7Wk5EgUnkwOnThvAVIzLTNqRKBZi9tOU+te8JmEro8i606BwXQXIhd+9//lIlRrxAwRvoYQtm7Yo+mQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MCZXAe21DsUj7fPuzZMe1WzgU9QbCkk1k "dfip-2208-a-yes" H7UWz7Quk0CH3bBL/uGLOKfXHE1pShwDbAgQn0rBbYsdBTMMwbjPeTAOvBzNScglnRBCdiq0z2Wn/47ncer9a+o= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZDmnnExsJYiV5s2vARnwidT41h2211e4D "dfip-2208-a-yes" IAlaWW8mY5HcB5HjxAxXmAqEtp75YP7L9W/VYOHEirktLWWMvLxAGqZ0CFrAVgD0/8cRkXFPG7br5eEa7TDHA8g= $ defi-cli signmessage 8L3pLcQda6ZvyghvN9VyhMggUogEPSuoVs "dfip-2208-a-yes" IOMOE1iykW6dkFKNs+c5jouShjYXLB22j2ZQw/tEsah8fMOu08uOH4Y2NmhNoqypDvbcm6R88VR2Uyy4YQ1K/3E= $ defi-cli signmessage 8T7VCXxiwEnQGwPFcSbLcuMiDErqPXdP1A "dfip-2208-a-yes" H6gcfXwyDGm1nYuB1bfmaYc4YC/DUC2kRAiVK2QIzhVtCZdpX7c6zDqSlS+q/BdzP+PKNI1DvgkceZis10azRNc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Zgjtp5UfoRhyF4X7cMUPHUw462wJLRQ7k "dfip-2208-a-yes" Hxy9wXiWPPcxk2THhgT+y1kXfsYJxwpMg2CBUd+iZgbnLiXCmv6McxaLMFvieDHETQPmGBFt/+IYUAJIft2mdN0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YVzv1NBcseNh4mt9JDqu6ZvegHCW6hdYA "dfip-2208-a-yes" IHvBSs49rsoPIcMZARfUETtBdM/243e2latFukrsNkbaX7R0x/zAoRgij6/+namlqpn464jonXkDeczbo4uPT2A=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GGvTvVRkWnsnXzQhMgw7dKQhuS3nSMgiw "dfip-2208-a-yes" HyAmHpfch8/3OHww4flGnCk343+HEkRRYF3rwpV5/w2FQTACtn4ACHDyz4sZ4R9OuCuhoL9oQ+TjLruHX6tsya4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8V8PY2bHJhpji5SgWAEn8gcd7VXMJVdA84 "dfip-2208-a-yes" H9Z9vp4h4TsNfnCb7EK0TXEI19NHa+IRh6AhHBEvzThUcnhYOIhAs+0P5tDXmNYddb+qRffl664B9NndzNJ3rVY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WhLwsQGJa5umXBipD2hap7pnFAm4aLq3r "dfip-2208-a-yes" H7spVjjNiY0JuUwmRN3xGWvODfWGDmUrBbq6nh5UuRZ/Sr95V5NYGUgUSU/jU7jSNo8+CmX3HQsnrlYA0cBcvAQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8d65UV6LRj1wjgtaJhoAhdhaUYq6zrEndu "dfip-2208-a-yes" IAE6g3xYJwTCdOJP+wADsHaSPBYP+zO6yqcxOL+FN/WEE+9BI7RcFAlc5faxLmZD3wcEWqXmthgE1XCZctsctRI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8GX3eS9vbBKzQP6b3pEkzABYou71CUPpbm "dfip-2208-a-yes" H8EgSnS5MhdMnChfUjunCXXEOIwoa1X2mLwFcttro7QCENltaZKM1mowZi63t5tP+LH/h02ncT8AsaDcRIQRLxo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JQgeF5rCqLkEoiSsW7f5Eb7z6CgucY7Nj "dfip-2208-a-yes" HzQf5DVOUehri0gFPUKCi9voW/EA1N6jgLUxH5wwzwotcgRgvPR4MzxxpKvZp0yCv58d654E0ApD9/6CBf1mThE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8VxohuNsyCDRCxTA7so5ar2jUFGXVdmU7Q "dfip-2208-a-yes" H85SFGowrM00Vd6WuoA0Gq10Mk574rGfDW1kXgs0wvbJMe0ASmiugpm1BNa7rPEnLb3GIlcdnA0lwOYpqheIvuY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HbdJdcMG9ZgdA3e5KDU7eQQb52je3gt15 "dfip-2208-a-yes" IOiSPyS6kbv0YxjI6xnhmPHkfaTBYZtoTRFuh9TTSqxFHiABW+swPzd252WPx77OeypU87ugbsY5qWyldiRL3Uk= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Wed9aMxrB6cdXrphCze6JaL8RszH8GURm "dfip-2208-a-yes" HyUZKVDJS6KQV9ubaA9TF7VVsjBMOKVkR3r+4XIqbHUUbHbgZ3wl0I2jD7GazoV93owhVaOIic1YrIgtTFI4Pz8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8X3KaUcjjwUFoZSRCTGEHe4SfW3eQYdhaF "dfip-2208-a-yes" H6O+TxnJKUnUi0GNjxF2QV7O5QrlclTt79CDuXrUxmeTFSosEU3+aFkRmMeVQ+BgRk3sm8+nObyWtcnLZjZKT+8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Rt2wuBuWM3q8UVZJDb1EvRvbEswFthhYY "dfip-2208-a-yes" H428Lrps8HbcZDkpoiQ/JzVqy6v5dSGqrafWy9Kz5QStacvtKkEN0tmFcP5/+MciJUoTMi3bmh+ZBeNzMuz6OK0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8cWBMKZ114bMEfU1D4cEhPLcJNQCLboJ7W "dfip-2208-a-yes" H8jmMTvI9ho6a5+5Zoe+aPUkT2YoHDz4ryp1cdCBbF/CRWPLuE4m8I/XV76k1PJNV6VJb6tk/o8F6oNWCmFHfYA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WwSDFBLcdf3onf1khvmNUTi2rArwQsh6Y "dfip-2208-a-yes" H+YH+rtpuHVPKdn818vNxP2ngXxA/85oCxOpmhM5BI+LehuL8ot/pQJLme5sJy/7FgibJPy0gIJILKZQTJU35fE= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Waw4AquJbY2yboLjgQhSjV5MJyneC4bvR "dfip-2208-a-yes" HzU6KZT8n4zoZDqCtdjJMGOP6fDsb5H2YYQs0ZhpqwV6eDUikvi8Syl6VuHNzSqu6VPmMPlQClDE2unuW8AG22Y= $ defi-cli signmessage 8SxytTDhbwr4TdywMnKDr98hfnKieNmM1i "dfip-2208-a-yes" IIKHS+j3J4mVh/hg4x+rP1EWVTpA2/ySgVhKoaSJn0lnCOhicNn/t0iR1AoyAUWsf97Yl74hs+UDvoPPS30AloM= $ defi-cli signmessage 8H9uoNTVa4DxfURmpjfZhRKmyi5uT2PTzJ "dfip-2208-a-yes" ID3J24nq05YN9LaiWVTW0mYQwxheuzZpk8IcMTl6mRLsQXrJGJvXoYEsrTPUmKAZ2vVraIj8fJvxjyaicCuaEP0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KGnZ74yjaTvBtqh3mSXpq72LZqgYu1rGh "dfip-2208-a-yes" H/DuIN17KCC+vYzmy7EL1sqYAZ09oy9e6t6AEMTcgfbqNsI1QPM67EYcR+Bx3E4bbMhUimBNYmmZMB80WctwQ64= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ZzzKLdXTLA55d1gSp6SFWcFneAG4SCfcA "dfip-2208-a-yes" IKoZC8hbSRlgP/iodOgbJu9v7xLfrid2MSXjZbvLOFR4CODBH2IX5xS8t3AsiDNrBvN7JDM2E9H3Iem9nekKgF0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WvZMpGeVoH41fRLh5rrFXFnFqxWs9wb4A "dfip-2208-a-yes" IAQ1LDKPFjWn3bfUh8ImBHuEcqGyj4ZHssZrcj5Pev76ErNXHE6sFxIdX8UQqYtezqXlN7SQo8DkpYBbhlEMU5o= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WVqN8QfWsCPUyYqgDAkbSSPad998ZsJ7K "dfip-2208-a-yes" INsJOTufMQ6ph+18kXGQsBttiff5ed+2WqKdvjKfC4uBRxLXGX4JqpoY37sK5bNT3+2w9urmJf3eiJ8bWHQI1Gs= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bXUUW3jT3DnG9ZviSpSvxSBKcWpmDFEAH "dfip-2208-a-yes" IGrh7Zeo6RqrUVbPdcQDdK8CeKiH3OtGJo6KGvrOGp7vKDkgbf5A7v4nJUx5cJ91IKxHFLMZQrd9/5904o2Flvg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UYTLFLKx8gQ5KCkQfebLGULt7UeYY5xie "dfip-2208-a-yes" H1ZLrhCRWck8gABC2MriQu370mhh1pnOPYcmE8tEVrVhQ/p3jX7ws1xsE0KpZ2R/wtpDDwHBgZoRQoMAENCL9iQ= $ defi-cli signmessage 8ePmDfuYP1mVJU9rZA9dnUYcMe5PuihezM "dfip-2208-a-yes" HwZzosY4hZ4/XAVAC6c0E53hP+gUgyC/QWO6uTyEIugVRCPc81l5f8WeWTJ1Rwv5qjum5zVWbAHucJu+9B62NYI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8bfckraDUDewQTNrcv22Tiwx5oCdudy1mD "dfip-2208-a-yes" H4892qHlcis4RMsqON/k1CkOAAlNMc7gmQjwKp7ehlMRZG5W8jIli6iOhw1qulgsVAlcjvG/bhpwzRd2SfRz+Hc= $ defi-cli signmessage 8KbPiD7yQpjCvsoLZM3HLAnYfF8RvVTbDs "dfip-2208-a-yes" IDUEcR0JrajvrvM0S/DUHfooYIP7g9TIR1mh3pvNtuz5FiI7ttss9pbkzKI/7C6EOloXrvnQIfX7/72ggy3oLgI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UbnNSCq2zpVCwVp9D6HSd1wBd9NdYyWgp "dfip-2208-a-yes" H+NzBxltw6+Nv7OSWEyaMA14hOyLVBMW+LsBWFDmo6EQNuYmWyseNxxlK/W49pHsz5v17rjnQvCSYN/RXNXM3fo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HwvE3zhYr7fcsTFu8bh1a7TQueuWC6KQ3 "dfip-2208-a-yes" H2iAYC/8xAqXTODGcGIeoREgf3o2uUnr0ytZWhPnKpO7I8AZlV9tNGtP9jAkOE6XGSQ4Em3s7REEfIo7IjQxg9k= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Lup7XrpLTJNuHQkQd3meaPJ5ShbgyJKCE "dfip-2208-a-yes" H8kyeNPCZ2gxLaiqo0tNz2r4igl5LR2VbjpFg+FpaNTcdQHLWlzHPFUw9/PP03vEcL8uerQxl0ArzosNczGTAfk= $ defi-cli signmessage 8WdhaX88XjKUmiPJ7aSM3N4Q7XByxcXcSY "dfip-2208-a-yes" HyJKmg4SsmvLPSiZm5Te8ZCtQlMOw32K4Q3+Jiq5papiE6fhCbqJUTxiNh8eYyUa669jsqANpZuDwbPEiphaIlM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8dHAnJi54oYpvJhsU8S5VwrivBVzRrxigw "dfip-2208-a-yes" ILqrogyOLHWsLb86ZqB1rlDqvdiuAqe1qPvFSJtvbqx3SqeDkn5SMRxTosO2brrK5RA1rpc+9ei82Fpu0u0odXg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YsADyyC6zyUTx7WTS9qis8AFDGfGF1U2d "dfip-2208-a-yes" H/YJ+yyDR+U5h2eKBhej4yYYnUoWsxqC2ZgC+TSjI+zPQiziQOUl5FFhUQm9E6z/J/BQxh0ANQDF0CN7fymK8sI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8SuT1zu4NyPXcVE5MrPpTDNNC2urvb63qD "dfip-2208-a-yes" H0wXPEoHbE947OQEhafDvjBhp/5x0sDCU5NnEdkdc+aqCv3Mx3JgW8kVHVHkqpC5W8RgbWWZru//oTpgPxCeVDk= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UEfh3wR95Y4FN6hHqztWf38ReBwauynFE "dfip-2208-a-yes" Hx5pjITdjCJtkn+MSRv07cybB0ClFCvIDOtJV1vY+u8WCEvy11H2a2fVgGE1Zf/GmFJRh8mLS0T8d0Mqds3j4Uo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8MszDngTzYfTdzs73VKQzQWZfDuG1xrdKu "dfip-2208-a-yes" IJek0kLikesPAgSHdRJY64Qf+mR12ipT5L8cvsCJ6FIzZ2VOAfNj6A/Ud+gCSqSy9QAltwcTb/dyIt73MvXjdcw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZTVsLfxKDvGUKxjVoEpQ6R3DBadvNLPa3 "dfip-2208-a-yes" IDctWFgQQnYlRv2L+L+CP8Hp6Cj+55kn5VmzTzUqXH2CYcwkbxRa5J/1tZVxncPgXZpP7D2rz7MHRkSxsm+tgjQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TNXjkrxucbByZL2uqWV7rSWmcuek3Jxeh "dfip-2208-a-yes" IFETT0T+cZJTj3R5KYle5piTMQ7ci3Yw2R8bgkWSExiAQCRu+/oWzmZ2J5ujwa7JJpAv9qv0OQrRbVQo5ZEFuuU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GVvJb4DeD2du6LtRuuurApoGrrUDsidJL "dfip-2208-a-yes" H6ClqZGceYU0KX/dDHKjqihJBkUcV75d6r4/macm/DL7V6GTxwbobYX5bFX7QAsLjWIYQ+eLS/poT0Z8ZE1dLyI= $ defi-cli signmessage 8S5fGmiKDam7GuRPtn3E489X8FyMpXyWD4 "dfip-2208-a-yes" IB01G/6BlapK72A7dfqzTTULGqeMoc+uCNTkXJkvP7DkGAvDqc8ch9ZX3huSvaAxIVtb8FHE3w9vFilbkG6zAVg= $ defi-cli signmessage 8FbhMMBrUcvqqafe3LxwmRNrFJVxwJ4RXh "dfip-2208-a-yes" INN96nlzdWakeTY67DIj+Bf0laHZxDZ+fRfxD4CTC62XU7qpIhjbzR93URyJ0d0A3soDkHglNWdF/0p8hCQzkAA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8W51RgRwPv5oGaRxygJKm2PX5RyJUe9tMj "dfip-2208-a-yes" INkq1mUGvzyNbelmMS/5M717nSQQgZMFbFTX9WZGL2o8QzCCTPLjuy3e9i0vRZNnAF7LbUiQzmnn8ruYrlZJsww= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YSX9mrxdWsyZ8ZCazF5r3wvs921utgLqi "dfip-2208-a-yes" IP9BQ7+tUi9Z7Bt9QLYhpv1MYYC4/i3jALpLIXbrVYsQeeFli5+x0gboIkLWHlcqq5pQY1lw/ZlK1c6kph6ptA4= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Fschm6onivsmqApQoNvNAZK9VHTgrcPYk "dfip-2208-a-yes" H4u4Ib09KldVRBj4uEcMpIjDXFCFuO7gcj2TEXgsDnX4Nm1PuNOMi1ERDIrj9VRKEB8CiVRvFyJZiglOS89WLuU= $ defi-cli signmessage 8JSpPYYsortvhD1aVd7uTLyVZRbYpDWWW2 "dfip-2208-a-yes" IOQ9cMBmA11l0oBkKEmhdZCVhgh57BI2oywRhcWK7As8b+j9Bgdg9IG+bU4h610qsZaxvCTNgdSLqIc90GDBuB0= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YAZQvKLFnZdrg5KuKwPPET6bxGqxDHxcJ "dfip-2208-a-yes" IPNn3rMGB+h7LIyQ42Hub7HgyFab/6PXOs188n5ECsYLCtah0msdQW2EtDCrrkn2cBN4xPp/pYchpbblD1UjdPA= $ defi-cli signmessage 8YAcgexeMmPy852bcJi7J9B1YwaeUYQvrZ "dfip-2208-a-yes" H6Rp9LnAmjl3U9l1qSkdveK4sTr0CZIZk6FoqQH2R0uDeLnBRNyTaqoJYaWY728KfMo0cq3BYYFK9wnRfAXNwcY= $ defi-cli signmessage 8Hhw3meymvVuPhaYfnaqx2o6TBcvW7jhT7 "dfip-2208-a-yes" H8Ql9lMsmBpl0xG0HVs2DA3SPs0XT/xrwyH9obyycyr+Ihv5d2uT+RFlV/ApY079yftrv9o38CiK0dPz7s/yk80= $ defi-cli signmessage 8UJiGBnt1psSLXZVq1W7XuwL4LtiAJqajA "dfip-2208-a-yes" IHEqGPcjreWE4+uBPehs+jjKSAtUmT4cwNTDJp+TkxhtTmCQz3bXafS7EDKiKdb3I7fopsB432MenQbBlcLvgLE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ap2nRBnB2TMajneshsCrSHj46otNxZCrt "dfip-2208-a-yes" Hx0hnlJm+T75aZIwq3Klnsu0X7qfU2OfKHCofsh5SK3cPv9mkm85CU1Xw2FX1uj7645iEJngQA0+FYzKc4F1azo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8G2w2AWFcVrnemPrDBN5gGfB5Wkh7VtNKo "dfip-2208-a-yes" H6XrLQSX7FqzK+fsMErVN5TjREbTLOXjRWCGjtOi+jg1aRPJydfF3mX9vHjksGWicNeK4QyIOdvLo+EJQ18kIeI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8G5f9wYGiTULo9hb1UW1MyrEgbWJWNcTa7 "dfip-2208-a-yes" H98Ti1yCqJiqsi5T39ZYLygmAaVnOsx1+IXJfjPSdKH1PjoQNs7lbqYBgXNlDmhIePfdcFTdiRz8I6P7WB7lKZ8= $ defi-cli signmessage 8JHTBsQtTW7CivBBNCx41zHS9CEVxhTeAb "dfip-2208-a-yes" H+IsI75VAi2psMahFbKbKFkllxdA21+IJiMO6INr306gbPPyzj5AXYM50sLoST+5Ak5KCginvnMTj537/9P+zr8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZQSD1W9zPuS5yP6jw6VeWRL51EwZe6wjk "dfip-2208-a-yes" H/TyGdXaLdH02QcY+KJLsHlhX5SIn+ha1iOmvgVsVhYuNkViCdYwVo5IjDnHs4OiFKn3tF2I9lvTFefbMRtC4Zo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8dkVtrSBHwvMW6uWWJnWyMMJxA8YcCYeso "dfip-2208-a-yes" H0Z+RnHuaJJ21Q4U1drPdRLvRtOvbIDxxkUo5bv6h9a5e2emStyKkds/LcmazRd5xcrhuwbkmaoTqmOrLvzJYFo= $ defi-cli signmessage 8HTHu1wVifCh8tspax3WYnntqQhUSBnf5c "dfip-2208-a-yes" IL+hsuR4coZkBpNRBzKOtjOOyDLS/Ih8z6QpDOjEWQLPI+F0uGg5m+EdD+nFyH8gdlQTl3B7KsJW4Z/0u/OOi14=
