publicgoods-candidates icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
publicgoods-candidates copied to clipboard

Add DPG: African Highlander Farmer II

Open dpgabot opened this issue 2 years ago • 5 comments

Automatic addition of a new digital public good submitted through the online form available at https://digitalpublicgoods.net/submission

dpgabot avatar Jun 21 '22 00:06 dpgabot

FYI - African Highland Farmer is built with Unity

nathanbaleeta avatar Jun 21 '22 09:06 nathanbaleeta

Checklist for conducting technical review against DPG Standard:

  • [x] Clear Ownership
  • [ ] Platform Independence
  • [x] Documentation
  • [x] Mechanism For Extracting Data
  • [x] Do No Harm By Design
  • [x] Data Privacy & Security
  • [x] Adherence to Standards & Best Practices
  • [x] Adherence to Privacy and Applicable Laws
  • [x] Inappropriate & Illegal Content
  • [x] Protection From Harassment
  • [x] Development & deployment countries

nathanbaleeta avatar Jun 30 '22 13:06 nathanbaleeta

African Highlander Farmer II needs to prove independence from Unity which is a mandatory & proprietary component required for the digital solution to function by indicating the existence of open functional alternatives that can be used without significant changes to the core product

nathanbaleeta avatar Jun 30 '22 13:06 nathanbaleeta

African Highlander Farmer II needs to prove independence from Unity which is a mandatory & proprietary component required for the digital solution to function by indicating the existence of open functional alternatives that can be used without significant changes to the core product

Thanks for the update @nathanbaleeta much appreciated, however, the codes for AHF were built using Unity as an engine. Unity in no way used, changed, published, or modified directly/indirectly. Unity encourages Open-source projects in unity, below is their open-source advocacy site: https://unity.com/open-projects

Kindly confirm this as the AHF game complied with platform Independence the above to the best of our knowledge.

osinkolu avatar Jul 04 '22 09:07 osinkolu

African Highlander Farmer II needs to prove independence from Unity which is a mandatory & proprietary component required for the digital solution to function by indicating the existence of open functional alternatives that can be used without significant changes to the core product

Thanks for the update @nathanbaleeta much appreciated, however, the codes for AHF were built using Unity as an engine. Unity in no way used, changed, published, or modified directly/indirectly. Unity encourages Open-source projects in unity, below is their open-source advocacy site: https://unity.com/open-projects

Kindly confirm this as the AHF game complied with platform Independence the above to the best of our knowledge.

@osinkolu According to the DPG standard indicator #4 - platform independence, African Highlander Farmer II has mandatory dependencies (Unity) that create more restrictions than the original license. Until the project is able to demonstrate independence from Unity and/or indicate the existence of functional, open alternatives, it still is not platform independent

Hint: can African Highlander Farmer II be maintained or modified outside Unity perhaps using an open alternative game engine like Godot?

nathanbaleeta avatar Jul 05 '22 10:07 nathanbaleeta

Digital solutions that are no longer active, or do not provide the required documentation needed for review, will be removed from the DPG Registry as per the archiving policy.

nathanbaleeta avatar Nov 17 '22 09:11 nathanbaleeta