Redfish Service Validator issue related to Oem Schema

[manipk01]

Hi All,

When i ran the Redfish Service Validator to validate redfish service. Below mentioned issue came for the URI

URI:

/redfish/v1/Systems/{{instance}}

Issue:

ERROR - contoso : EntityType resource does not contain required @odata.id property, attempting default /contoso

Response:

{ "@odata.context": "/redfish/v1/$metadata#ComputerSystem.ComputerSystem", "@odata.etag": ""1697014972"", "@odata.id": "/redfish/v1/Systems/{{instance}}", "@odata.type": "#ComputerSystem.v1_16_0.ComputerSystem", ................... ................... ................... "Oem": { "contoso": { "@odata.type": "#Contoso.v1_0_0.Contoso", "property1" : "value" "property2" : "value" } } ................. ................. ................. }

Schema (Contoso_v1.xml) : Schema File.zip

When i change the Entity type to complex type in schema part

<EntityType Name="Contoso" BaseType="Contoso.Contoso"> <Annotation Term="OData.Description" String="This property shall specify a valid odata or Redfish property."/> <Annotation Term="OData.LongDescription" String="This property shall specify a valid odata or Redfish property."/> <Property Name="property1" Type="Contoso.v1_0_0.property1" Nullable="false"></Property> <Property Name="property2" Type="Contoso.v1_0_0.property2" Nullable="false"></Property> </EntityType>

to

<ComplexType Name="Contoso" BaseType="Contoso.Contoso"> <Annotation Term="OData.Description" String="This property shall specify a valid odata or Redfish property."/> <Annotation Term="OData.LongDescription" String="This property shall specify a valid odata or Redfish property."/> <Property Name="property1" Type="Contoso.v1_0_0.property1" Nullable="false"></Property> <Property Name="property2" Type="Contoso.v1_0_0.property2" Nullable="false"></Property> </ComplexType>

it is working fine. So whether we can change to complex type for fixing this error or it needs to check from tool side. Complete schema file is attached for your reference.

Please check and confirm it.

Thanks, Mani P K

[mraineri]

That behavior looks correct then. When you define something as an EntityType in CSDL, the expectation is it's a resource with a durable URI (shown by an @odata.id propert). OEM objects are not intended to be like this; they are just JSON objects in a resource, which means you need to use ComplexType to define that structure.

[mraineri]

Closing; issue with the OEM definition and not the tool