ConsistencyPlus
ConsistencyPlus copied to clipboard
ConsistencyPlus
Having Consistency+ and Universal Graves in a modpack causes multiblocks from other mods to break on a dedicated server; probaby an incompatibility with Polymer
Describe the bug:
When I add Consistency+ to my modpack and join a server with the same modpack, any multiblocks from different mods stop rendering, render incorrectly or only render correctly when a block near them is updated (by either simply right-clicking or placing a block on it).
Originally, I reported the issue on the Waystones mod github here: https://github.com/ModdingForBlockheads/Waystones/issues/546, but after further testing came to a conclusion that the only reliable way to replicate the issue was to install Consistency+.
Initially, I thought it was the problem with Waystones mod because that's the first mod which I found to be broken on the server, but after hours of testing different mod combinations I found out that just having Consistency+ in the modpack will cause multiblocks from other mods to break just like Waystones. However, not a single mod directly conflicts with Consistency+, meaning if you load just X mod and Consistency+ there won't be any issues. But as soon as you cross a certain amount of mods that add new blocks and Consistency+ is present, multiblocks break. Without Consistency+ no issues appear, even if you add a lot more mods to the pack.
Versions:
Minecraft version: 1.18.2 C+ version: 0.5.0 (in my logs I was using RC3 version, however, the release version also causes the issue) Fabric API version: 0.51.0
Other mods:
Full list of mods required to reproduce the issue: https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/7eea0c2703631e73a3ad1a945c3b36c5 (Carpet, its addons and Fabrication can be ignored, since they don't add any new blocks)
Logs:
Logs following reproduction steps 1 and 2 (everything is fine): https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/ef09f9862a8d7523446a6aa8fa8362b0
Logs following reproduction steps 3 and 4 (multiblocks break): https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/a512bfe30c51b965a5ae9e14e4eccfb0
To Reproduce:
- Install these mods: https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/7eea0c2703631e73a3ad1a945c3b36c5
- Launch the game, join a server with the same mods; place a waystone, make sure it works
- Close the game, install any of the following mods: Adorn, Blockus, Chipped or, possibly, any other mod that adds a lot of new blocks. I chose Adorn.
- Launch the game, join the server and observe that waystones are now visually broken. However, Waystones isn't the only affected mod, if you place cables from the Tom's Simple Storage mod next to each other so they connect, you can also observe that, once connected, they become invisible until you right-click a block next to it (or place a block next to it). edit: Another example of broken multiblocks: beds from MultiBeds; platforms from Platforms mod; escalators, automatic doors and all the other multiblocks from Minecraft Transit Railway, openable and connectible windows from Macaw's Windows.
Alternatively:
- Install all the same mods, or even way more of your choice (I believe they must be adding new blocks, not even necessarily multiblocks)
- Make sure that everything is working as intended
- Then add Consistency+ and observe that all the multiblocks broke
Expected behavior:
Multiblocks from any mod should render correctly at all times.
Screenshots:
Broken Waystones as an example, the same applies to all multiblocks I mentioned previously
Placing a waystone down, you can see that the waystone doesn't render at all
Right clicking on the ground next to the waystone with an empty hand, or the waystone itself, renders the bottom half of the waystone
Placing 2 blocks next to it (or even where it's actually supposed to be) makes the whole waystone render, but incorrectly - runes aren't glowing, no particles around the stone
Right clicking a waystone (even when it's invisible) opens the GUI like normal, but the name is "invalid" and can't be changed
Additional info:
The issue does not happen in single-player at all. Let me know if I can provide any more info.
So the issue is that with mods/modpacks that add large amounts of blocks, once a certain threshold is reached, multiblocks stop rendering properly until updated?
Yes, but only when Consistency+ is also installed, and only in multiplayer. Having all the same mods, and even more, but without Consistency+ doesn't produce the issue.
Also when you "fix" it by updating nearby blocks, it only stays "fixed" until you interact with it again. For instance, if you open a window from Macaw's Windows. Waystones will only properly render if you reload the chunk its in and break after you teleport, ~~but it's the only outlier I could find, all the other multiblocks remain rendered until interacted with.~~ actually, scratch that, beds from MultiBeds and platforms from Platforms mod appear completely broken, some blocks from these mods remain broken even after updating nearby blocks, so there's that. The only real way to fix it is to remove Consistency+.
I can quickly cook up a test mod that outputs how many blocks were added just to see if theres an arbitrary or non-arbitrary number that has been hit.
I can quickly cook up a test mod that outputs how many blocks were added just to see if theres an arbitrary or non-arbitrary number that has been hit.
That should at the very least rule out the amount of blocks as the reason for the bug, because right now it's really only my assumption after hours and hours of testing all sorts of mod combinations. I use a lot more mods than needed to replicate the issue, but from my testing it seems that only adding mods that introduce new blocks matters. Which is how I managed to narrow down the list and find a way to consistently reproduce the issue.
Try this mod and send log of it (Unzip it before adding) projectdiag-1.0.0.zip
Sorry, took a while, followed my steps to reproduce the issue + added the test mod. Also for some reason just adding one extra mod during step 3 is no longer enough, so I added 2 instead (Adorn + Blockus). Interestingly, it doesn't break waystones anymore, unless I install my entire modpack, but openable windows from Macaw's Windows, MultiBeds and all the other multiblocks I tested still break with just the selection of mods I listed before.
Here are the results: https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/917c1095f7e03c9d373fb74fc62e52d4
If you want me to test anything further, I'll have to do it tomorrow, but I will try to help as much as I can.
edit I should've also mentioned that whereas waystones break by simply placing it (or used to break with just roughly 80mods, I don't know what caused it to fix itself, I'll test it longer tomorrow to figure out what happened as the only thing I did was to run the test mod alongside the pack) and MultiBeds' beds instantly become broken upon placing, other blocks don't always automatically become multiblocks, as such you need to form a multiblock first by combining it, e.g. Macaw's Windows will look fine until you combine and/or open them, platforms from Platforms mod will render fine until you combine them together (just place 2 blocks called "Floor" on top of each other for instance) etc.
Basically, if a block is not a multiblock by itself, combine it into one in order to reproduce the issue.
Blockcount was at 7779.
Closest possible arbitrary and code limits I see near it are 4096, 5000, and 7500. Test with as little mods as possible if you can.
I reduced the amount of mods needed to basically the essentials: https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/7eea0c2703631e73a3ad1a945c3b36c5.
However, with these mods, not all multiblocks break. First of all, Waystones no longer break as I mentioned yesterday, unless way more mods are installed, as such I excluded it from this list and tests. Second, Macaw's Windows don't break with this selection of mods, to reproduce the issue with windows you need a couple more, I added Decorative Blocks and its addon Decorative Winter. Third, MultiBeds' beds aren't broken with these mods, you need to add 1 more for it to break, I added Decorative Blocks without the addon. Multiblocks from Platforms still consistently get broken.
I don't think the block count has anything to do with it (though, just for the record, with this limited selection of mods it reaches 5767), but I still believe C+ does, because removing it solves the issue, even if I add a lot more mods to the pack.
Something of note I found out while testing this selection of mods: removing C+ solves the issue; removing Universal Graves solves the issue; removing Adorn and its dependency Kotlin solves the issue; removing Simple copper pipes solves the issue. Removing anything other than C+ from a large modpack does not solve the issue, it only does with this very limited selection of mods and only if C+ is also installed.
Out of curiosity launched my entire mod pack with C+ and without, with C+ the Block count is at 11598 and all sorts of multiblocks are broken, without - 8969 and not a single multiblock is broken, so that 7779 block count was probably not the issue. Or rather it might only become problematic if C+ is installed.
Is it possible that C+ somehow prevents the server from properly sending packets to the client or something like that? Because the server is aware that there is a block, it won't let you walk through it, you will keep rubberbanding back until you force the block to appear. Very similarly to so called "ghost blocks". I have no other ideas as to what's going on here.
It seems unlikely, but did we somehow 3-5 way error with these?
What does "3-5 way error" mean?
Jello causes the same issue as C+. They have C+ listed as an optional dependency, so whatever they include from C+ into Jello causes the same issue as C+ itself. Might be helpful, might not, just letting you know.
Out of curiosity launched my entire mod pack with C+ and without, with C+ the Block count is at 11598 and all sorts of multiblocks are broken, without - 8969 and not a single multiblock is broken, so that 7779 block count was probably not the issue. Or rather it might only become problematic if C+ is installed.
Is it possible that C+ somehow prevents the server from properly sending packets to the client or something like that? Because the server is aware that there is a block, it won't let you walk through it, you will keep rubberbanding back until you force the block to appear. Very similarly to so called "ghost blocks". I have no other ideas as to what's going on here.
yes. this happened in my modpack before when there were too many blocks (in this case, it was due to chipped). Weird stuff happened, it interfered with KubeJS and REI. I believe there is a vanilla cap with the total amount of blocks you can have. this happened a while ago though so I forgot the outcome of the fix, I wish I could be more help. but here to say that stuff definitely happens when a threshold is hit
yes. this happened in my modpack before when there were too many blocks (in this case, it was due to chipped). Weird stuff happened, it interfered with KubeJS and REI. I believe there is a vanilla cap with the total amount of blocks you can have. this happened a while ago though so I forgot the outcome of the fix, I wish I could be more help. but here to say that stuff definitely happens when a threshold is hit
I had a modpack on 1.17.1 with practically every fabric mod out there and had no such issues. And right now I'm running a large modpack on 1.18.2 that works completely fine as long as C+ isn't installed. I doubt it's a vanilla limit or a limit at all, that was just my guess before I ran the tests.
My issue was on 1.18. I have 330 mods in my pack along with c+ right now and multiblocks are working fine for me. My pack has about 10 blocks.
On Sun, May 1, 2022, 1:28 PM Footage2-Amply-Pounce @.***> wrote:
yes. this happened in my modpack before when there were too many blocks (in this case, it was due to chipped). Weird stuff happened, it interfered with KubeJS and REI. I believe there is a vanilla cap with the total amount of blocks you can have. this happened a while ago though so I forgot the outcome of the fix, I wish I could be more help. but here to say that stuff definitely happens when a threshold is hit
I had a modpack on 1.17.1 with practically every fabric mod out there and had no such issues. And right now I'm running a large modpack on 1.18.2 that works completely fine as long as C+ isn't installed. I doubt it's a vanilla limit or a limit at all, that was just my guess before I ran the tests.
— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ConsistencyPlus/ConsistencyPlus/issues/108#issuecomment-1114329244, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIL5CKEDZBE3AQWGWGITMCDVH3SQLANCNFSM5UETYESA . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>
10k* this is on 1.18.2
On Sun, May 1, 2022, 2:54 PM C J @.***> wrote:
My issue was on 1.18. I have 330 mods in my pack along with c+ right now and multiblocks are working fine for me. My pack has about 10 blocks.
On Sun, May 1, 2022, 1:28 PM Footage2-Amply-Pounce < @.***> wrote:
yes. this happened in my modpack before when there were too many blocks (in this case, it was due to chipped). Weird stuff happened, it interfered with KubeJS and REI. I believe there is a vanilla cap with the total amount of blocks you can have. this happened a while ago though so I forgot the outcome of the fix, I wish I could be more help. but here to say that stuff definitely happens when a threshold is hit
I had a modpack on 1.17.1 with practically every fabric mod out there and had no such issues. And right now I'm running a large modpack on 1.18.2 that works completely fine as long as C+ isn't installed. I doubt it's a vanilla limit or a limit at all, that was just my guess before I ran the tests.
— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ConsistencyPlus/ConsistencyPlus/issues/108#issuecomment-1114329244, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIL5CKEDZBE3AQWGWGITMCDVH3SQLANCNFSM5UETYESA . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>
I have 330 mods in my pack along with c+ right now and multiblocks are working fine for me. My pack has about 10 blocks.
My issue is reproducible with just 14 mods. Maybe I should change the title.
I'm curious though about your modpack, could you post your modlist whenever you can, please? I'll compare it to mine and see if I still get the issue with your pack.
Edit: also are you playing on a dedicated server? If not, then you were having a totally separate problem, as my issue happens only on a server. Single-player is unaffected.
My issue is reproducible with just 14 mods. Maybe I should change the title This is certainly one of the more bizarre issues we've had reported. Is there any chance it could be an incompatibility with a specific mod rather than of some sort of limitation that C+ hits?
I have 330 mods in my pack along with c+ right now and multiblocks are working fine for me. My pack has about 10 blocks.
My issue is reproducible with just 14 mods. Maybe I should change the title.
I'm curious though about your modpack, could you post your modlist whenever you can, please? I'll compare it to mine and see if I still get the issue with your pack.
Edit: also are you playing on a dedicated server? If not, then you were having a totally separate problem, as my issue happens only on a server. Single-player is unaffected.
My problem that I wrote about is irrelevant to what you mentioned about multi blocks, but yes at that time it was on both server and single player.
additionaladditions: Additional Additions 4.0.0
additionalbars: Additional Bars 3.0.0
additionalentityattributes: Additionalentityattributes 1.0.0+1.18.2
adorn: Adorn 3.4.0+1.18.2
advanced_runtime_resource_pack: Runtime Resource Pack 0.5.7
advdebug: Advancements Debug 2.3.0
adventurez: AdventureZ 1.4.10
ae2: Applied Energistics 2 11.0.0-alpha.5
ae2wtlib: AE2WTLib 11.0.0-alpha.2
agape_space: Space Dimensions 0.5.8
alloy_forgery: Alloy Forgery 2.0.13+1.18
annotateddi: Annotated DI 2.1.0+1.18.2
aopalliance_aopalliance: aopalliance 1.0
apoli: Apoli 2.3.3
appleskin: AppleSkin 2.4.0+mc1.18.2
arcanus: Arcanus 1.29
architects_palette: Architect's Palette Fabric 1.7
architectury: Architectury 4.2.50
armorpointspp: Armorpoints++ 3.0.0
artis: Artis-Recrafted 2.4.0+1.18.2
attributefix: AttributeFix 14.0.1
autoconfig1u: Auto Config v1 Updated 3.4.0
autorun: AutoRun 0.4.0
badpackets: Bad Packets 0.1.2
balm-fabric: Balm 3.0.0+0
banhammer: BanHammer 0.5.0+1.18.2
bcc: BetterCompatibilityChecker fabric-1.0.5
bclib: BCLib 1.4.5
beenfo: Beenfo 1.18.2-fabric0.47.10-1.3.3
betteradvancements: Better Advancements 0.2.0.129
betteranimalsplus: Better Animals Plus 1.18.2-11.0.5
betterend: Better End 1.1.0
betternether: Better Nether 6.1.1
bewitchment: Bewitchment 1.18-17
bhmenu: BHMenu-Fabric 1.17.1-1.18.2-1.3
bitsandchisels: BitsAndChisels 2.6.8
blockbot-api: BlockBot Api 1.0.0
blockbot-discord: BlockBot Discord 2.0.0-beta
blockus: Blockus 2.4.5+1.18.2
blue_endless_jankson: jankson 1.2.1
bno: Basic Nether Ores 1.18.2-7.2.0-Fabric
bookshelf: Bookshelf 13.0.13
bosses_of_mass_destruction: Bosses of Mass Destruction (Beta) 1.3.6-1.18.2
botania: Botania 1.18.2-431-FABRIC
buildinggadgets: st'ructure tools 1.0.21
byg: Oh The Biomes You'll Go 1.4-RC-10
cacao: Croptopia's Chocolaterie 1.1
calio: Calio 1.5.1
capybara: Capybara 1.0.4
cardinal-components: Cardinal Components API 4.1.4
cardinal-components-base: Cardinal Components API (base) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-block: Cardinal Components API (blocks) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-chunk: Cardinal Components API (chunks) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-entity: Cardinal Components API (entities) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-item: Cardinal Components API (items) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-level: Cardinal Components API (world saves) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-scoreboard: Cardinal Components API (scoreboard) 4.1.4
cardinal-components-world: Cardinal Components API (worlds) 4.1.4
carpet: Carpet Mod 1.4.69
carpet-extra: Carpet Extra 1.4.72
carpet-tis-addition: Carpet TIS Addition 1.33.0
carrier: Carrier 1.10.0
catwalksinc: Catwalks Inc. 1.3.0
chalk: Chalk 2.0.0+1.18.2
charm: Charm 4.1.0
chisel: Chisel Refabricated 1.4.5
clienttweaks: Client Tweaks 7.1.0
cloth-api: Cloth API 3.2.64
cloth-basic-math: cloth-basic-math 0.6.0
cloth-client-events-v0: Cloth Client Events v0 3.2.64
cloth-common-events-v1: Cloth Common Events v1 3.2.64
cloth-config: Cloth Config v6 6.2.57
cloth-config-lite: cloth-config-lite 2.0.6
cloth-datagen-api-v1: Cloth Datagen v1 3.2.64
cloth-utils-v1: Cloth Utils v1 3.2.64
clumps: Clumps 8.0.0+8
com_electronwill_night-config_core: core 3.6.4
com_electronwill_night-config_toml: toml 3.6.4
com_eliotlash_mclib_mclib: mclib 18
com_eliotlash_molang_molang: molang 18
com_fasterxml_jackson_core_jackson-annotations: jackson-annotations 2.13.1
com_fasterxml_jackson_core_jackson-core: jackson-core 2.13.1
com_fasterxml_jackson_core_jackson-databind: jackson-databind 2.13.1
com_flowpowered_flow-math: flow-math 1.0.3
com_github_dimensionaldevelopment_poly2tri_java: poly2tri.java 0.1.1
com_google_inject_guice: guice 5.1.0
com_moandjiezana_toml_toml4j: toml4j 0.7.2
com_typesafe_config: config 1.4.1
com_velocitypowered_velocity-native: velocity-native 1.1.0-SNAPSHOT
computercraft: CC: Restitched 1.100.5
conditional-mixin: conditional mixin 0.2.0
config2brigadier: Config to Brigadier 1.1.1
conjuring: Conjuring 1.0.22+1.18
consistency_plus: Consistency Plus 0.5.0+1.18.2
cosmetic-armor: Cosmetic Armor 1.3.1
craftingtweaks: Crafting Tweaks 13.0.0
crawl: Crawl 0.10.6
creativecore: CreativeCore (Fabric) 2.6.10
creeperspores: Creeper Spores 1.8.0
croparia: Croparia 3.8.3
croptopia: Croptopia 2.0.0
crowdin-translate: CrowdinTranslate 1.4+1.18.2
curse_maven_wthit-3707010: wthit-3707010 440979
customportalapi: Custom Portal Api 0.0.1-beta50-1.18
damagetilt: Damage Tilt 1.18-fabric-0.1.2
dankstorage: Dank Storage 1.18.2-3.7
dark-enchanting: Dark Enchanting 0.7.0+1.18.2
darkutils: DarkUtilities 10.0.4
dawn: Dawn API 3.3.0
de_poiu_apron_apron: apron 2.1.1
deathlog: DeathLog 0.2.7+1.18
dimdoors: DimensionalDoors 4.0.4
disenchanter: Disenchanter 0.1.6+1.18
dml-refabricated: Deep Mob Learning: Refabricated 1.18.2
dml-refabricated-base: DML: Refabricated - Base 1.18.2
dml-refabricated-events: DML: Refabricated - Vanilla Events 1.18.2
dml-refabricated-modular-armor: DML: Refabricated - Glitch Armor 1.18.2
dml-refabricated-rei: DML: Refabricated - REI Integration 1.18.2
dmlsimulacrum: Deep Mob Learning: Simulacrum 0.5.3-beta
doom: Doom Fabric 4.2.3
doublejump: Double Jump Mod 1.0.1+mc1.18
dragonloot: DragonLoot 1.0.10
dripstone_fluid_lib: Dripstone Fluid Lib 1.2.0
dummmmmmy: MmmMmmMmmMmm 1.18-1.5.0
dusk: Dragonfight Mod 1.18.2-2.1
earthbounds: Earthbounds 1.18.2-1.1.0b
earthtojavamobs: Earth2Java 1.8.0+1.18.2
eldritch_mobs: Eldritch Mobs 1.11.0
elementalcreepers: Elemental Creepers: Refabricated 1.4.2+1.18.2
enchantment_force: enchantment_force 0.1.7
exlineawnings: Exline's Awnings fabric-1.18.2-v1.0.2
exlinefurniture: Exline's Furniture fabric-1.18.2-v2.0.5
expandedstorage: Expanded Storage 7.3.12
experiencebugfix: Experience Bug Fix 18
explorerscompass: Explorer's Compass 1.18.2-2.1.0-fabric
extended_drawers: Extended Drawers 1.0.2+mc.1.18.2
extragenerators: Extra Generators 1.2.1-BETA+1.18
extraorigins: Extra Origins 1.18-10
fabric: Fabric API 0.51.1+1.18.2
fabric-api-base: Fabric API Base 0.4.4+d7c144a860
fabric-api-lookup-api-v1: Fabric API Lookup API (v1) 1.6.0+2373a54560
fabric-biome-api-v1: Fabric Biome API (v1) 8.0.4+7b0f312660
fabric-command-api-v1: Fabric Command API (v1) 1.1.9+d7c144a860
fabric-commands-v0: Fabric Commands (v0) 0.2.8+b4f4f6cd60
fabric-containers-v0: Fabric Containers (v0) 0.1.21+d7c144a860
fabric-content-registries-v0: Fabric Content Registries (v0) 3.0.3+d82b939260
fabric-convention-tags-v1: Fabric Convention Tags 1.0.1+474e4f7960
fabric-crash-report-info-v1: Fabric Crash Report Info (v1) 0.1.11+3ac43d9560
fabric-diagonal-panes: Fabric Diagonal Panes 0.6.1
fabric-dimensions-v1: Fabric Dimensions API (v1) 2.1.17+2540745460
fabric-entity-events-v1: Fabric Entity Events (v1) 1.4.8+d7c144a860
fabric-events-interaction-v0: Fabric Events Interaction (v0) 0.4.19+d7c144a860
fabric-events-lifecycle-v0: Fabric Events Lifecycle (v0) 0.2.14+d7c144a860
fabric-furnaces: Fabric Furnaces 2.1.1-1.18.2
fabric-game-rule-api-v1: Fabric Game Rule API (v1) 1.0.13+d7c144a860
fabric-item-api-v1: Fabric Item API (v1) 1.4.0+4457765560
fabric-item-groups-v0: Fabric Item Groups (v0) 0.3.11+91896a4960
fabric-language-kotlin: Fabric Language Kotlin 1.7.4+kotlin.1.6.21
fabric-language-scala: Fabric Language Scala 1.1.0+scala.2.13.6
fabric-lifecycle-events-v1: Fabric Lifecycle Events (v1) 2.0.3+2d83e92c60
fabric-loot-tables-v1: Fabric Loot Tables (v1) 1.0.11+d7c144a860
fabric-mining-level-api-v1: Fabric Mining Level API (v1) 2.1.0+81ea5b3c60
fabric-networking-api-v1: Fabric Networking API (v1) 1.0.21+d882b91560
fabric-networking-v0: Fabric Networking (v0) 0.3.8+b4f4f6cd60
fabric-object-builder-api-v1: Fabric Object Builder API (v1) 2.1.0+fe4ddef060
fabric-particles-v1: Fabric Particles (v1) 0.2.12+526dc1ac60
fabric-permissions-api-v0: fabric-permissions-api 0.1-SNAPSHOT
fabric-registry-sync-v0: Fabric Registry Sync (v0) 0.9.8+0d9ab37260
fabric-rendering-data-attachment-v1: Fabric Rendering Data Attachment (v1) 0.3.7+d7c144a860
fabric-rendering-fluids-v1: Fabric Rendering Fluids (v1) 2.0.2+54e5b2ec60
fabric-resource-conditions-api-v1: Fabric Resource Conditions API (v1) 2.0.3+91b7aa6660
fabric-resource-loader-v0: Fabric Resource Loader (v0) 0.4.18+2de5574560
fabric-screen-handler-api-v1: Fabric Screen Handler API (v1) 1.2.0+1f6558e860
fabric-transfer-api-v1: Fabric Transfer API (v1) 1.6.0+2373a54560
fabric-transitive-access-wideners-v1: Fabric Transitive Access Wideners (v1) 1.0.0+bd8a4a1860
fabricenchantments: Fabric Enchantments 0.7.2
fabricloader: Fabric Loader 0.13.3
fabricshieldlib: Fabric Shield Lib 1.5.3-1.18
fabrictailor: Fabric Tailor 1.8.1
fallingtree: FallingTree 3.5.0
farmersdelight: Farmer's Delight 1.18.2-0.2.1
farmingforblockheads: Farming for Blockheads 10.0.0
feature_nbt_deadlock_be_gone: Feature NBT Deadlock Be Gone - Fabric 2.0.0+1.18.2-rc1
ferritecore: FerriteCore 4.2.1
fiber: fiber 0.23.0-2
fireplacelib: Fireplace Lib 6.3.1+1.18.2
fireworkfrenzy: Firework Frenzy 1.9
flan: Flan 1.18.2-1.7.6
fluidtank: Fluid Tank 18.5.0-fabric
forgeconfigapiport: Forge Config API Port 3.2.0
ftblibrary: FTB Library 1802.3.6-build.115
ftbquests: FTB Quests 1802.3.8-build.101
ftbteams: FTB Teams 1802.2.6-build.51
gearreborn: Gear Reborn 1.18.2-0.1.12
geckolib3: Geckolib 3.0.38
genesis: Genesis 1.18.2-1.0.1
givemehats: Give Me Hats! 1.8.0
go-fish: Go Fish 1.5.0-1.18.2
gobber2: Gobber2 2.5.72
goldenhoppers: Golden Hoppers 1.3.0
graveyard: The Graveyard 1.7
graveyard_biomes: The Graveyard Biomes 1.1
grounded_origins: Grounded Origins 1.1.3
guardiansgalore: GuardiansGalore 1.18.2-3.0
gud_recipe_confidence: Recipe Confidence 1.0.2
hammermod: War-Hammers Mod fabric-1.18.2-v1.0.1
harvest_scythes: Harvest Scythes 2.5.0
hookshot: Hookshot 25.0
horseinfo: Horse Info 0.4.1-1.18
horsestatsvanilla: Horse Stats Vanilla 4.1.10
hoverpets: Hover Pets 0.3.2
hyperlighting: Hyper Lighting 1.2.2
iceberg: Iceberg 1.0.38
impaled: Impaled 1.1.1
impersonate: Impersonate 2.5.0
improved-stations: Improved Stations 2.1.0
incantationem: Incantationem 1.1.3+1.18.2
incubus_core: Incubus Core 1.6.6+1.18.2
inmis: Inmis 2.5.3-1.18.2
interference: Interference API 1.3.9
io_leangen_geantyref_geantyref: geantyref 1.3.11
itemfilters: Item Filters 1802.2.7-build.25
jankson: Jankson 4.0.0+j1.2.0
java: OpenJDK 64-Bit Server VM 17
javax_inject_javax_inject: javax.inject 1
jsonem: JsonEM 0.1.1
justenoughkeys: Just Enough Keys 0.5.3
kanos_config: Kanos Config 0.2.0+1.14.4-1.19
kibe: Kibe 1.9.7-BETA+1.18
kjsextras: KubeJS Extras 2.0.0
konkrete: Konkrete 1.3.3
krypton: Krypton 0.1.9
ktdatataglib: KtDataTagLib 1.6.5+1.18.2
kubejs: KubeJS 1802.5.1-build.372
kyrptconfig: Kyrpt Config 1.3.4-1.18
lazydfu: LazyDFU 0.1.2
libblockattributes: LibBlockAttributes 0.10.2
libblockattributes_core: LibBlockAttributes (Core) 0.10.2
libblockattributes_fluids: LibBlockAttributes (Fluids) 0.10.2
libblockattributes_items: LibBlockAttributes (Items) 0.10.2
libgui: LibGui 5.3.2+1.18.2
libninepatch: LibNinePatch 1.1.0
libra: Libra 0.4.2
lifts: Lifts 1.4.1-BETA+1.18
lightestlamp: Lightest Lamps 1.0.0
lithium: Lithium 0.7.9
lovely_snails: Lovely Snails 1.0.4+1.18
luckperms: LuckPerms 5.4.21
macawsbridgesbyg: Macaw's Bridges - BYG 1.18.2-1.0
maelstrom_library: Maelstrom Library 1.2.4-1.18.2
magiccombatwands: Magic Combat Wands 1.0.1
magicfungi: Magic Fungi 0.7.1-BETA+1.18.2
magna: Magna 1.7.0-1.18-pre1
marketcrates: Marketcrates 1.4.1
matrix: Matrix 1.0.0
mavm: More Axolotl Variants Mod 1.0.7a
maxhealthfix: MaxHealthFix 5.0.1
mcda: MC Dungeons Armors 2.0.6
mcdar: MC Dungeons Artifacts 1.4.7
mcdw: MC Dungeons Weapons 4.3.2
mconfig: Mconfig 1.1.2
mcwbridges: Macaw's Bridges 2.0.2
mcwfences: Macaw's Fences and Walls 1.0.4
mcwlights: Macaw's Lights and Lamps 1.0.3
mcwpaintings: Macaw's Paintings 1.0.3
mcwwindows: Macaw's Windows 2.0.3
me_hypherionmc_night-config_core: core 3.6.5_custom
me_hypherionmc_night-config_toml: toml 3.6.5_custom
megane: megane 7.5.1
megane-api: megane-api 7.1.0
megane-applied-energistics-2: megane-applied-energistics-2 7.1.0
megane-deep-mob-learning-simulacrum: megane-deep-mob-learning-simulacrum 7.1.0
megane-extra-generators: megane-extra-generators 7.1.0
megane-fabric-transfer: megane-fabric-transfer 7.1.0
megane-kibe: megane-kibe 7.1.0
megane-lib-block-attributes: megane-lib-block-attributes 7.1.0
megane-reborn-core: megane-reborn-core 7.1.0
megane-reborn-energy: megane-reborn-energy 7.0.0
megane-runtime: megane-runtime 7.2.0
megane-tech-reborn: megane-tech-reborn 7.1.0
megane-vanilla: megane-vanilla 7.1.1
megane-wireless-networks: megane-wireless-networks 7.1.0
midnightlib: MidnightLib 0.4.0
milk: Milk Lib 0.3.1
milk_plus: Milk+ 3.0.1
minecraft: Minecraft 1.18.2
mining_dims: Mining Dimensions 1.3.6
miningutility: Mining Utility 1.2.1+1.18
mm: Manningham Mills 2.3
mo_glass: Mo Glass 1.6.1-MC1.18.2
mobscarecrow: Mob Scarecrow 1.2.2
mobz: MobZ 3.3.1
mocolors: Mo' Colors 1.4.0
modern_industrialization: Modern Industrialization 1.1.0-alpha.01
morebannerfeatures: More Banner Features 1.1.3
moretags: More Tags 3.0.3
morevillagers-fabric: MoreVillagersFabric 3.2.0-SNAPSHOT
mostructures: Mo' Structures 1.4.1+1.18.2
mtmechs: Magitek Mechs 1.0.12
multibeds: MultiBeds 1.2.5
multipart_entities: MultipartEntities 1.1.5-1.18.2
myloot: myLoot 2.1
myron: Myron 1.6.3+1.18.1
mysql_mysql-connector-java: mysql-connector-java 8.0.28
mythicmetals: Mythic Metals 0.13.1
mythicmounts: Mythic Mounts 1.18.2-7.0
naturescompass: Nature's Compass 1.18.2-2.0.3-fabric
net_objecthunter_exp4j: exp4j 0.4.8
ninjaphenix_container_lib: NinjaPhenix's Container Library 1.3.0
notenoughcrashes: Not Enough Crashes 4.1.6+1.18.2
omega-config: OmegaConfig 1.2.3-1.18.1
omega-config-gui: Omega Config GUI 1.2.3-1.18.1
onsoulfire: On Soul Fire 1.18-1
org_jetbrains_kotlin_kotlin-reflect: kotlin-reflect 1.6.21
org_jetbrains_kotlin_kotlin-stdlib: kotlin-stdlib 1.6.21
org_jetbrains_kotlin_kotlin-stdlib-jdk7: kotlin-stdlib-jdk7 1.6.21
org_jetbrains_kotlin_kotlin-stdlib-jdk8: kotlin-stdlib-jdk8 1.6.21
org_jetbrains_kotlinx_kotlinx-coroutines-core-jvm: kotlinx-coroutines-core-jvm 1.6.1
org_jetbrains_kotlinx_kotlinx-coroutines-jdk8: kotlinx-coroutines-jdk8 1.6.1
org_jetbrains_kotlinx_kotlinx-serialization-cbor-jvm: kotlinx-serialization-cbor-jvm 1.3.2
org_jetbrains_kotlinx_kotlinx-serialization-core-jvm: kotlinx-serialization-core-jvm 1.3.2
org_jetbrains_kotlinx_kotlinx-serialization-json-jvm: kotlinx-serialization-json-jvm 1.3.2
org_jgrapht_jgrapht-core: jgrapht-core 1.1.0
org_spongepowered_configurate-core: configurate-core 4.1.2
org_spongepowered_configurate-hocon: configurate-hocon 4.1.2
org_xerial_sqlite-jdbc: sqlite-jdbc 3.36.0.3
org_yaml_snakeyaml: snakeyaml 1.30
origins: Origins 1.4.1
origins-classes: Origins: Classes 1.3.0
overlord: Overlord 3.1.5+1.18.2
overweight_farming: Overweight Farming 1.18.2-1.2.0-fabric
owo: oωo 0.7.0+1.18
packet_tweaker: Packet Tweaker 0.2.0+1.18-pre1
paintings: Paintings++ 9.1.1.0
patchouli: Patchouli 1.18.2-67-FABRIC
pehkui: Pehkui 3.2.2+1.14.4-1.19
phonos: Phonos 0.3+1.18.2
phosphor: Phosphor 0.8.1
pickupnotifier: Pick Up Notifier 3.2.0
pigpen: PigPen 8.0.1
placeholder-api: Placeholder API 1.1.3+1.17.1
platforms: Platforms 1.2.4
player-data-api: Player Data API 0.1.0+1.18
playerabilitylib: Pal 1.5.1
plushies: Plushie Mod 1.2
polymorph: Polymorph 0.0.20-1.18.2
prefab: Prefab 3.1.3
publicguiannouncement: Public Gui Announcement 3.2.0.1
pugh_lib: Pugh Lib 1.3.0
pugh_tools: Pugh Tools 1.2.5
puzzleslib: Puzzles Lib 3.3.1
quarryplus: QuarryPlus 18.4.555
quartzelv: Quartz Elevator 2.1.1+1.18
quickshulker: Quick Shulker 1.3.6-1.18
reach-entity-attributes: Reach Entity Attributes 2.1.1
reborncore: Reborn Core 5.2.0-beta.3
redbits: Red Bits 1.13.2
redstonebits: Redstone Bits 1.7.1
repurposed_structures: Repurposed Structures 4.1.6+1.18.2
resourceful_tools: Resourceful Tools 1.2.35
respawnablepets: Respawnable Pets 1.18-4
rhino: Rhino 1801.1.9-build.135
right-click-harvest: Right-Click-Harvest 1.2.0
rocks: This Rocks! 1.6.0
roughlyenoughitems: Roughly Enough Items 8.1.457
roughlyenoughresources: Roughly Enough Resources 2.5.0
rpgstats: RPGStats 4.3.8+1.18.2
runelic: Runelic 11.0.1
sandwichable: Sandwichable 1.2+1.18.2
secretrooms: Secret Rooms 1.3.1+1.18.2
seedfix: Seed Fix 1.0.1
server_translations_api: Server Translations API 1.4.10+1.18.2
sgui: sgui 1.0.1+1.18.2
shetiphiancore: ShetiPhianCore 1.2.10
shulkerboxtooltip: Shulker Box Tooltip 3.0.7+1.18.2
shulkerutils: shulkerutils 1.0.4-1.18
silkspawners: SilkSpawners 1.1.1
someforgepatchesported: Some Forge Patches Ported 1.0.3
spark: spark 1.9.1
spectrum: Spectrum 1.3.3-1.18.2-midgame18-trinkets-brewing
spoornpacks: SpoornPacks 4.2.1-1.18.2
spoornweaponattributes: SpoornWeaponAttributes 3.4
stacc: Stacc 1.2.3
step-height-entity-attribute: Step Height Entity Attribute 1.0.0
stonecutter_recipe_tags: Stonecutter Recipe Tags 3.0.1+1.18.bc850d5.fabric
stoneholm: Stoneholm 1.4.3
styledchat: Styled Chat 1.2.3+1.18
styledplayerlist: Styled Player List 2.1.3+1.18
tacocraft: TacoCraft 1.7.4-1.18.2
team_reborn_energy: Energy 2.2.0
techreborn: Tech Reborn 5.2.0-beta.3
teenycoal: Teeny Coal 1.1.2-1.16.x-1.17.x-1.18.x-1.19-experimental-snapshot
tempad: Tempad 1.1.0
tenshilib: TenshiLib 1.18.2-1.6.7
terrablender: TerraBlender 1.1.0.99
terraform-wood-api-v1: Terraform Wood API (v1) 3.0.0
terrarianslimes: Terrarian Slimes 1.2-BETA+1.18
the_aether: Paradise Lost 1.6.8+1.18.2
things: Things 0.2.17+1.18
tinyskeletons: Tiny Skeletons 3.2.1
toms_storage: Tom's Simple Storage Mod 1.3.0
toolstats: ToolStats 9.0.1
tradingpost: Trading Post 3.2.0
trashslot: TrashSlot 11.0.2
trinkets: Trinkets 3.3.0
tweed4_annotated: tweed4_annotated 1.3.0
tweed4_base: tweed4_base 1.5.0+mc1.18.2
tweed4_data: tweed4_data 1.2.1+mc1.18.2
tweed4_data_hjson: tweed4_data_hjson 1.1.0
twigs: Twigs 1.1.3-patch1+1.18.2
unforgivingvoid: Unforgiving Void 3.1.4+1.18.2
valley: ValleyCraft 2.3-1.18.2
veggie_way: The Veggie Way 1.2.32
veinmining: Vein Mining 0.0.12-1.18.2
villager-hats: Villager Hats Mod 1.3.1
villagernames: Villager Names 4.0.4
visualworkbench: Visual Workbench 3.3.0
voidz: VoidZ 1.0.7
wandering_collector: Wandering Collector 1.1.2+mc1.18.2
waterdripsound: Drip Sounds 1.18-0.3.0
waystones: Waystones 2.5.0
whisperwoods: Whisperwoods 1.18.2-2.1.0
winged: Winged Mod 1.18.2-3.2.0
wirelessnetworks: Wireless Networks 1.5.1
wthit: wthit 4.9.1
xaerominimap: Xaero's Minimap 22.6.1
xaeroworldmap: Xaero's World Map 1.20.7
xlpackets: XLPackets 2.1-1.17.1
xps: Xp Obelisk 0.3.8.r_for_1.18.x_Fabric
yigd: You're in Grave Danger 1.3.1
zihlaunchpads: ZIHLaunchpads 1.2.0
```
This is certainly one of the more bizarre issues we've had reported. Is there any chance it could be an incompatibility with a specific mod rather than of some sort of limitation that C+ hits?
I tested all the mods required to reproduce the issue 1 by 1 with C+ and none cause the same problem as all of them together.
And yeah, it's one of those problems where things don't really make sense to me too.
This is so strange.
My theory is currently a block state or block model limit. It would explain how some block counts don't trigger this but others do
Also it having to do with multiplayer may be a clue into what causes this - just as a test, does it do the same thing if before you join any multiplayer worlds, you join a singleplayer world first? We had a different issue with stonecutters/SCRT tags breaking where doing that caused different results, and at this point this is just a shot in the dark to see if anything new happens.
My problem that I wrote about is irrelevant to what you mentioned about multi blocks, but yes at that time it was on both server and single player. [...]
Thanks for the modlist. We have a lot of mods in common, so I'm surprised you don't have the same issue... I'll try to replicate it with your mods later, but for now you are absolutely sure that with your mods, on a dedicated server, MultiBeds render correctly when placed down, Platforms render correctly when floors are placed on top of each other etc, Waystones render correctly at all times and Macaw's Windows don't disappear when being opened?
My theory is currently a block state or block model limit. It would explain how some block counts don't trigger this but others do
Yep, I thought about it too, C+ would be the only mod in my modpack that adds massive amounts of new shapes for existing blocks. All the other ones simply add new ones entirely. However, I don't know how would I go about testing it...
Also it having to do with multiplayer may be a clue into what causes this - just as a test, does it do the same thing if before you join any multiplayer worlds, you join a singleplayer world first? We had a different issue with stonecutters/SCRT tags breaking where doing that caused different results, and at this point this is just a shot in the dark to see if anything new happens.
I thought of the same thing because your mod, as you mentioned, Chipped and Traveler's Backpack used to have an issue where you had to join SP first in order for things to work properly in MP, so I tried doing that and nope, loading into SP first doesn't change anything.
I could probably make a block that has like 2^16 blockstates and we can go from there
Not sure this is related to block count. I think this might be some kind of EXTREMELY niche load order issue. I've seen several cases of mod counts causing issues instead of mod contents, and that seems somewhat similar here.
I reduced the amount of mods needed to basically the essentials: https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/7eea0c2703631e73a3ad1a945c3b36c5.
Is this still the smallest combo found?
I could probably make a block that has like 2^16 blockstates and we can go from there
If you won't be able to test it yourself, drop the test mod here and I'll get to it within the next couple of days, can't do it today and, likely, tomorrow either.
Also I read through the entire list itsdinkd provided, seems like the only 2 mods he doesn't have, that I used to replicate the issue (https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/7eea0c2703631e73a3ad1a945c3b36c5) are Universal Graves and Simple Copper Pipes. Copper pipes have a lot of new blocks, but unlikely to be the cause of the issue. However, Universal Graves uses Polymer, which now that I think of it, could be what's causing it, I don't think I tested UG and C+ alone because UG doesn't add any new blocks, but I completely overlooked the fact it uses Polymer. I'll look into that right now as that's going to be quick.
I reduced the amount of mods needed to basically the essentials: https://gist.github.com/Footage2-Amply-Pounce/7eea0c2703631e73a3ad1a945c3b36c5.
Is this still the smallest combo found?
Yes. With that combo if you place "floor" blocks from the Platforms mod in an upside down L shape, they stop rendering. To break other mods, you will need to add the other 2 mods I mentioned. As long as the stuff from Platforms is broken, the issue only gets worse the more mods you add.
something else to consider is that it might be an issue with models, which would make more sense really see if you can get your test mod to print block model count
