quorum-key-manager icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
quorum-key-manager copied to clipboard

Hard delete ethereum accounts not working

Open capri-san opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments

Describe the bug

We are testing QKM and we've found that the operation of hard delete (/destroy API endpoint) with Hashicorp Vault is not working, while other operations as list, creation and soft delete works properly.

Configuration

We are using last version of QKM: "consensys/quorum-key-manager:latest"

Steps to reproduce

  1. Run QKM properly connected to Hashicorp Vault
  2. Issue: `curl -X DELETE 'http://localhost:8080/stores/my-ethereum-store/ethereum/0x<EXISTING_ACCOUNT_TO_DELETE>/destroy'

Actual result

{"message":"ST100: failed to get deleted account","code":"ST100"}

Expected result

A message indicating that the account was deleted

Additional context

Logs

The QKM log shows the following:

key-manager_1  | 2022-08-30T12:13:36.806Z       ERROR   stores  failed to get deleted account   {"store_id": "my-ethereum-store", "address": "0x<EXISTING_ACCOUNT_TO_DELETE>", "error": "ST100: resource not found"}

Obviosly, the account does exist:

$ curl -X GET 'http://localhost:8080/stores/my-ethereum-store/ethereum/0x<EXISTING_ACCOUNT_TO_DELETE>'
# response
{"publicKey":"0x04f703a9fe6cba9e9f7bf639da7709179766948291a0630956a4521dde64e1642f7735db7b6d2eb090097528c56172fe4a835dc3e0778fd3ada99edb498cb8c454","compressedPublicKey":"0x02f703a9fe6cba9e9f7bf639da7709179766948291a0630956a4521dde64e1642f","createdAt":"2022-08-30T08:06:55.731586Z","updatedAt":"2022-08-30T08:06:55.731586Z","keyId":"my-eth-account","tags":{"property1":"string","property2":"string"},"address":"0x<EXISTING_ACCOUNT_TO_DELETE>","disabled":false}

capri-san avatar Aug 30 '22 12:08 capri-san

You might find a successful response of destroy, once you operate soft deletion.

It seems that destroy does not do before soft deletion. https://github.com/ConsenSys/quorum-key-manager/blob/d509f52d9ab3d6476327415a6d276f4e570b50e2/src/stores/connectors/ethereum/destroy.go#L22

amane-c avatar Apr 09 '23 00:04 amane-c