CommonCoreOntologies icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
CommonCoreOntologies copied to clipboard

Make cco:acronym a sub-property of skos:altLabel

Open johnbeve opened this issue 11 months ago • 3 comments

During the one-off Annotation meeting on 12-15-23, consensus was reached that (see "Annotation-Discussion-12-15" minutes on TRMC):

  • either skos:altLabel or cco:acronym will be used for all acronyms
  • cco:acronym will be made a sub-property of skos:altLabel

To be updated in the next release of CCO.

johnbeve avatar Mar 12 '24 12:03 johnbeve

@johnbeve Is the plan to deprecate cco:alternative_label? Thus also making cco:doctrinal_label a sub of the skos property?

mark-jensen avatar Mar 12 '24 13:03 mark-jensen

@mark-jensen I'd be in favor of this; from the survey of use, CCO is the only ontology using cco:alternative_label; others use skos:altLabel.

johnbeve avatar Mar 13 '24 02:03 johnbeve

@johnbeve I agree. CCO should follow current usage rather than reinvent existing standards. Annotations are metadata, have a very slim semantics, I don't see a reason not to reuse SKOS or DC or follow Foundry recommendations here.

mark-jensen avatar Mar 13 '24 02:03 mark-jensen

Would we like to aim to implement this for 1.6, 1.7, or 2.0?

cameronmore avatar Aug 06 '24 15:08 cameronmore

@cameronmore I'd like to get to this one today. @APCox Any bandwidth? Otherwise, we can take this one.

neilotte avatar Aug 18 '24 15:08 neilotte

@mark-jensen I'd execute this, but perhaps you can give some deprecation guidance? I'm not familiar with the latest practices that CCO has followed.

neilotte avatar Aug 23 '24 01:08 neilotte

Gentlemen, in the interest of agility, I propose we review PR #455 in the interest of closing this issue, but open another focused issue on deprecating cco:alternative_label.

Any objections?

johnbeve avatar Sep 01 '24 23:09 johnbeve

@johnbeve #455 now merged. Your proposed new issue now at: https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues/458 . Thanks!

neilotte avatar Sep 02 '24 15:09 neilotte