EvalAI icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
EvalAI copied to clipboard

Improve test coverage for challengeHostTeamsCtrl.js from 70.51%

Open 1234-ad opened this issue 2 months ago • 0 comments

Description

This PR addresses issue #4731 by significantly improving test coverage for challengeHostTeamsCtrl.js from the current 70.51%.

Changes Made

Based on systematic analysis using Lumyst (Gemini 2.5 Pro Sequential Thinking), I identified and implemented the following missing test cases:

1. Untested Functions

  • ✅ Added comprehensive tests for activateCollapsible() function
  • ✅ Added detailed tests for load() function with success, error, and edge cases

2. Critical Edge Cases

  • ✅ Zero results pagination scenario (count: 0)
  • ✅ Initial load failure handling
  • ✅ HTTP error handling in load function
  • ✅ Null URL handling in load function

3. Enhanced Error Handling Tests

  • ✅ Specific error response parsing for different HTTP status codes
  • ✅ Error handling when retrieving updated lists fails
  • ✅ Error handling when refreshing team list after creation fails

4. Dialog Interaction Tests

  • ✅ Event propagation handling (stopPropagation)
  • ✅ Dialog cancellation scenarios
  • ✅ Invitation of existing team members
  • ✅ Comprehensive pagination state after deletion

5. Form Validation & State Management

  • ✅ Team object reset after successful operations
  • ✅ Error state management
  • ✅ Loader container assignment
  • ✅ Edge cases for storeChallengeHostTeamId with null/undefined values

How Lumyst Assisted

Lumyst (Gemini 2.5 Pro Sequential Thinking) was instrumental in this process:

  1. Systematic Code Analysis: Lumyst analyzed the controller code line-by-line to identify untested code paths
  2. Gap Identification: It categorized missing tests into 4 main areas: untested functions, edge cases, conditional branches, and user-flow scenarios
  3. Prioritization: Lumyst helped prioritize which test cases would have the most impact on coverage improvement
  4. Edge Case Discovery: It identified subtle scenarios like pagination state after deletion and error parsing that were previously missed

Test Coverage Improvements

  • Before: 70.51%
  • Added: 25+ new comprehensive test cases
  • Focus Areas: Error handling, edge cases, user interactions, state management

Files Changed

  • frontend/tests/controllers-test/challengeHostTeamsCtrl.test.js - Enhanced with comprehensive test coverage

Testing

All new tests follow the existing testing patterns and use proper mocking/spying techniques. The tests cover:

  • Success scenarios
  • Error scenarios
  • Edge cases
  • User interaction flows
  • State management

Suggestions for Lumyst Improvements

  1. Code Coverage Integration: Direct integration with coverage tools to show exact line-by-line gaps
  2. Test Generation: Ability to auto-generate test skeletons based on identified gaps
  3. Pattern Recognition: Better recognition of common testing patterns in the codebase
  4. Dependency Analysis: Understanding of complex dependency chains in large codebases

This PR significantly improves the robustness and reliability of the challengeHostTeamsCtrl tests while maintaining code quality standards.

1234-ad avatar Oct 09 '25 16:10 1234-ad