gltf-pipeline icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
gltf-pipeline copied to clipboard

Files with external `http://` uri refererences can't be procesed with gltf-pipeline

Open hybridherbst opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

I'm trying to convert some old glTF 1.1 files to glTF 2.0.

While that works in general, it seems that external references throw up gltf-pipeline:

image

Here's an example:

https://storage.googleapis.com/assets.icosa.gallery/63208108939333337/63210051195686758/GLTF/sketch.gltf https://storage.googleapis.com/assets.icosa.gallery/63208108939333337/63210051195686758/GLTF/sketch.bin

To reproduce:

  • download the two files above
  • run gltf-pipeline -i sketch.gltf -o sketch.glb
  • note the exception being thrown

Expected External references are kept as external references

Additional Context While the issue here is happening during glTF 1.1 -> glTF 2.0 conversion, I believe this also affects general use with glTF 2.0.

hybridherbst avatar Jul 24 '24 11:07 hybridherbst

To add some detail - this is (as far as I know) specifically a Tilt Brush thing. But there's a fair number of Tilt Brush GLTF v1 files out in the wild.

Is there any reason gltf-pipeline shouldn't treat file references as opaque unless requested to handle them?

andybak avatar Jul 24 '24 20:07 andybak

Here's a glTF file without the tiltbrush extension(s) that has the same issue: needle_godot_plush_ref.gltf.zip

This one is even simpler (just a grey sphere): NeedleSphereReference.gltf.zip

Quick test:

Tool Can load these files
model-viewer
needle-engine
Gestaltor
glTF Validator
glTFast
UnityGLTF

hybridherbst avatar Jul 24 '24 21:07 hybridherbst