Celestia icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Celestia copied to clipboard

Standardize Celestia icon

Open SevenSpheres opened this issue 5 years ago • 14 comments

This icon should be used in all front ends.

SevenSpheres avatar Nov 14 '19 22:11 SevenSpheres

yes, 1.6.x branch on Mac has changed to use this icon now, we should replace the current icon on other platforms too. generating an icon file should be trivial

levinli303 avatar Nov 15 '19 14:11 levinli303

Sigh, still sad to see the icon I was forced to make used but let me know if you need my icon file or higher res files. Or ideally use a better quality redesign of that icon.

But yeah I agree, would be nice if the actual appication used the icon too.

Panterstruck avatar Nov 15 '19 20:11 Panterstruck

FarGetaNik, why don't you try and use your icon. https://celestia.space/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=19914&p=146117&hilit=icon#p146117

Anthony-B-Russo10 avatar Nov 15 '19 21:11 Anthony-B-Russo10

I actually prefer the icon that is obviously Saturn to the "simple" one.

SevenSpheres avatar Nov 15 '19 22:11 SevenSpheres

With the way IS GUIs are now, that simple icon is a better fit then the current Windows XP and OS X 10.5 Leopard icons.

Anthony-B-Russo10 avatar Nov 15 '19 22:11 Anthony-B-Russo10

How about we just make the circle in the center the Sun? Then the "C" will just be greyish It'll be much simpler than the Saturn one, which I understand why Pantherstruck does not like seeing

LafuenteAstronomy avatar Nov 15 '19 23:11 LafuenteAstronomy

Which just so happens to look like the icon in the link, but just make it more color-accurate

LafuenteAstronomy avatar Nov 15 '19 23:11 LafuenteAstronomy

Well if more people like the "simplified" icon, that can be used instead. The point is to use the same icon in all frontends. Maybe we can have a poll for which icon to use.

SevenSpheres avatar Nov 15 '19 23:11 SevenSpheres

I did refine that icon a bit more for Project Echoes 0.2:

celestia-c13

Hm i can't upload icon files directly.

A star in the center might work too, but iirc thats very similar to Celestia Origins icon.

Panterstruck avatar Nov 16 '19 18:11 Panterstruck

How do I make a poll on the forum?

SevenSpheres avatar Nov 16 '19 20:11 SevenSpheres

Good question. Maybe only admins can?

Panterstruck avatar Nov 17 '19 12:11 Panterstruck

You know what, I do like the new icon. I still want to make a poll though.

edit: @LafuenteAstronomy, you're a mod, can you make a poll?

SevenSpheres avatar Nov 21 '19 02:11 SevenSpheres

Glad to hear that. It's just my current result tho. Importantly I think the icon should not feature texture details or harsh shading like th current one, anything else im up for debate. Just one thing that many have commented on, "realistic" colored Saturn looks too bland as an icon. You'd want some contrast in colors.

Panterstruck avatar Nov 23 '19 12:11 Panterstruck

"Wishlist"? IMO this is something that needs to be done for the 1.7.0 release.

SevenSpheres avatar Apr 05 '20 17:04 SevenSpheres