json-rules-engine icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
json-rules-engine copied to clipboard

Question: Comparing Distinct Arrays of Objects

Open mahirk opened this issue 3 years ago • 5 comments

Hello,

I am trying to compare an array of objects to check for a specific set of objects to be present in any of them, but not across all of them, specifically lets take this rule:

const arrayRule = {
        conditions: {
            any: [
                {
                    all: [
                        {
                            fact: 'data',
                            path: '$.[*].equalityTest',
                            operator: 'equal',
                            value: 50,
                        },
                        {
                            fact: 'data',
                            path: '$.[*].anotherTest',
                            operator: 'equal',
                            value: 50,
                        },
                    ],
                },
            ],
        },
        event: {
            type: 'arrayRule',
        },
    };

This is the first iteration of the rule I came up with, it is incorrect, but I wanted to give an idea of what I am aiming for.

Specifically here, we have a rule where I want equalityTest to equal 50 and anotherTest to also equal 50. But I want them to equal those values in the same object, such that: THIS SHOULD RETURN FALSE

 const facts = {
                data: [
                    {
                        anotherIntegerFact: 1,
                        equalityTest: 50,
                    },
                    {
                        anotherIntegerFact: 50,
                        equalityTest: 40,
                    },
                ],
            };

THIS SHOULD RETURN TRUE

 const facts = {
                data: [
                    {
                        anotherIntegerFact: 50,
                        equalityTest: 50,
                    },
                    {
                        anotherIntegerFact: 40,
                        equalityTest: 40,
                    },
                ],
            };

Would love any suggestions or ideas on a way to tackle this. One thought was I could write my own operator and add it to the registry of operators on our end, but before I did so, I wanted to validate that is needed.

Thanks

mahirk avatar Mar 11 '21 00:03 mahirk

@CacheControl Tagging you because I am unsure of the policy on issues here, thank you in advance!

mahirk avatar Mar 11 '21 00:03 mahirk

We have a similar need. Given an array of objects, I want to return true if and only if one of the objects (evaluated by itself) matches multiple conditions.

alexthehurst avatar Aug 10 '21 05:08 alexthehurst

We have similar use case, can someone suggest any ideas around it.

vindu25 avatar Jul 25 '22 09:07 vindu25

Any updates on this? @mahirk @alexthehurst @vindu25

OmarKhattab avatar Sep 23 '22 19:09 OmarKhattab

@OmarKhattab I no longer remember what caused us to hit this issue, but this kind of requirement can probably be worked around with custom operators, which we've since learned are pretty easy to implement in JRE. If you provide samples of what kind of data you want to match, I might be able to give suggestions on implementation.

alexthehurst avatar Sep 23 '22 21:09 alexthehurst