BeeStation-Hornet icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
BeeStation-Hornet copied to clipboard

Adds the Grenade Gauntlet

Open ToasterBan opened this issue 11 months ago • 4 comments

About The Pull Request

Adds the Grenade Gauntlet, a powerful traitor item that functions similarly to old explosive lances, when loaded with a grenade, anything punched by this gauntlet will have the grenade be detonated right under them.

The gauntlet can also be used inhand to toggle it being NO_DROP

it has a 20 minimum pop before being able to be bought in the uplink

Why It's Good For The Game

A very high risk- high reward weapon, to encourage risky, flashy plays

Testing Photographs and Procedure

Screenshots&Videos

https://github.com/BeeStation/BeeStation-Hornet/assets/54711687/b5f7a1bd-f9b5-47f3-8b34-299443a4ca0c

https://github.com/BeeStation/BeeStation-Hornet/assets/54711687/3580780f-8071-4abb-9456-48937de899d0

Changelog

:cl: add: Adds the Grenade Gauntlet, a risky weapon that when loaded with a grenade will cause anyone hit by the gauntlet to get hit point-blank by the grenades effects add: The Grenade Gauntlet to the traitor and nuclear operative uplinks /:cl:

ToasterBan avatar Mar 10 '24 14:03 ToasterBan

If we are going to do something like this, then the grenate should prime on impact but be forced to go through the 5 second period before it explodes; with the spear embedding in the victim while it activates giving them some time to either pull it out, realise what is about to happen, or have it deflect from armour if its embed fails.

Edit: Just saw that it operates instantly from a fist mounted weapon instead of on a spear or anything. In that case perhaps it should have some kind of property similar to the power fist, where it will hit someone back a few tiles, stun them and drop a grenade underneath their mob. Anything with a few seconds before detonation allows them to be dragged away by a teammate and makes slightly it less of a 1-hit kill punch.

This needs something to make it not instant or a little more fair to be against. You need to consider how to make it fair for the victim, but also still powerful/fair for the user if someone is able to counter it.

Some other ideas:

  • Limit the explosion size to a light explosion that doesn't affect the user, which delimbs but doesn't instakill and instead sends anyone in front of the device flying proportional to how big the explosion would have been. (would need a lot of explosion tweaking probably)

PowerfulBacon avatar Mar 10 '24 14:03 PowerfulBacon

A big part of the balance of this is that if you do something high explosive you'll probably die aswell, better use cases would be something like lube foam with noslips or a plasma flash when your an oozeling.

but having the grenade not instantly detonate but embed is interesting and I might do that

ToasterBan avatar Mar 10 '24 14:03 ToasterBan

Agree with bacon - grenade should embed or something to give the other player a moment to react, it should not be a forced instant explosion, or frankly even be possible to make instant - this sort of thing just isn't fun for the receiving player.

Rukofamicom avatar Mar 10 '24 17:03 Rukofamicom

If we are going to do something like this, then the grenate should prime on impact but be forced to go through the 5 second period before it explodes; with the spear embedding in the victim while it activates giving them some time to either pull it out, realise what is about to happen, or have it deflect from armour if its embed fails. Edit: Just saw that it operates instantly from a fist mounted weapon instead of on a spear or anything. In that case perhaps it should have some kind of property similar to the power fist, where it will hit someone back a few tiles, stun them and drop a grenade underneath their mob. Anything with a few seconds before detonation allows them to be dragged away by a teammate and makes slightly it less of a 1-hit kill punch. This needs something to make it not instant or a little more fair to be against. You need to consider how to make it fair for the victim, but also still powerful/fair for the user if someone is able to counter it.

I mean being thrown back, stunned and then exploding isn't better than what's being offered here considering it would make it an insta-win weapon to your targets or anyone that's alone however:

The embed proposal is.. interesting! but then again.. how can a punch embed something to you!? i do like armor having a chance to deflect it though, you could try something along those lines and see what you can come up with, the current version seems like an explosive lance that costs tc(and lets you put other stuff i guess like an emp nade and other explosives) and can equally kill you as wel(since that's intended) so i doubt people would use it that much given they have a craftable lance as the free alternative for suicide charges, unless they want to make the damage slightly more devastating using a syndiebomb(which you can if you go right next to someone with INSTANT detonation), looking forward for the update

Fronsis avatar Mar 10 '24 20:03 Fronsis

good job on using the EMP grenade first in your video so that we can't see the gauntlet not working properly, really clever

Howluinb avatar Mar 11 '24 07:03 Howluinb

I mean being thrown back, stunned and then exploding isn't better than what's being offered here considering it would make it an insta-win weapon to your targets or anyone that's alone however:

The advantage is that its only an insta-win against alone targets, meaning that you can reasonably deal with it while in a squad. Anyone who gets caught off guard should reasonably die, but we need to balance it against the people who will see it coming and can prepare themselves to deal with it. At the moment there is nothing you can do, which makes it a bit unfair.

PowerfulBacon avatar Mar 11 '24 13:03 PowerfulBacon

after doing some thinking, this could easily be used as an unfun instawin option, my initial idea would be creative use of grenades but I need to remember that players will always try do a free win if possible

ToasterBan avatar Mar 11 '24 20:03 ToasterBan

I do think this could be adapted to be fair and work well if you are interested or have any ideas

PowerfulBacon avatar Mar 14 '24 10:03 PowerfulBacon