DotNetty icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
DotNetty copied to clipboard

this project stopped developing?

Open xuanyuan5005 opened this issue 4 years ago • 13 comments

this project stopped developing?

xuanyuan5005 avatar Mar 09 '20 09:03 xuanyuan5005

if this project is stopped, what should we do? is there some other project to replace it?

SepMyself avatar Mar 25 '20 09:03 SepMyself

This is only the java port of the "netty" project. In this case, no additional functionality is introduced.

iamkisly avatar Mar 26 '20 08:03 iamkisly

i suggest libuv sharp

sevencat avatar Mar 26 '20 10:03 sevencat

Stop the maintenance of project, there is a great risk in the use of the project.

xuanyuan5005 avatar Mar 31 '20 01:03 xuanyuan5005

i suggest libuv sharp

libuv sharp was stopped

xuanyuan5005 avatar Mar 31 '20 01:03 xuanyuan5005

I'm also interested in DotNetty replacement. While it looks like DotNetty production ready, it seems quite a risk to pick it for new projects, since it is not actively developed and it's minimally maintained.

We might pick some actor framework Akka/Orleans for upcoming projects instead of DotNetty.

TailyFair avatar Mar 31 '20 06:03 TailyFair

Don't tease, Akka / Orleans is totally incomparable with dotnetty,Akka / Orleans can do it, Netty can do it, but Netty can do it, Akka / Orleans cannot.Provides support for extending different application layer communication protocols (TCP, UDP, DNS, MQTT, HTTP, WS.) based on socketchannel.Features such as zero copy and memory pool also ensure that Netty will not have performance problems.I would not choose Akka / Orleans, which is not flexible and not very scalable.

fanliang11 avatar Mar 31 '20 07:03 fanliang11

i suggest libuv sharp

libuv sharp was stopped

never mind,it's enough

sevencat avatar Apr 02 '20 01:04 sevencat

if this project is stopped, what should we do? is there some other project to replace it?

BedrockFramework or Supersocket

zh6335901 avatar Apr 03 '20 02:04 zh6335901

BeetleX 1M connections problem solution NetCoreServer 10K connections problem solution

xuanyuan5005 avatar Apr 04 '20 15:04 xuanyuan5005

I don't think BedrockFramework is suitable.

Please See.

https://github.com/dotnet/aspnetcore/issues/20554 https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/issues/1793

xuanyuan5005 avatar Apr 07 '20 01:04 xuanyuan5005

Hey all, BedrockFramework is very much in the same space as DotNetty albeit trying to be a more idiomatic approach (not a port of a java framework). Those issues linked are what the foundation of what BedrockFramework is built on. The library will uses abstractions provided by the core framework and has a set of implementations (transports, codecs) for various protocols.

See https://speakerdeck.com/davidfowl/project-bedrock for more information.

davidfowl avatar Apr 09 '20 15:04 davidfowl

I found SpanNetty, it's an active fork from DotNetty

gsw945 avatar Dec 13 '20 14:12 gsw945