Device Power on mqtt zigbee2mqtt payload

[Travis90x]

What happened

In according to the MQTT Device Configuration

I correctly manage a tasmota over mqtt with this

[power MQTT]
type: mqtt
command_topic: cmnd/Printer_Name/POWER 
query_topic: cmnd/Printer_Name/POWER
state_topic: stat/Printer_Name/POWER
command_payload:
    {command}
state_response_template:
    {payload}
query_after_command: False

So the Power On command is cmnd/Printer_Name/POWER On

But I cant' manage a zigbee2mqtt device that needs the command: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get payload {"state": "on"} or zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state on

I set in my moonraker.conf

[mqtt]
address: 192.168.1.2 # mqtt borker IP
port: 1883
username: mqtt_user
password: my_password
mqtt_protocol: v3.1.1
enable_moonraker_api: True
  
[power MQTT]
type: mqtt
command_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state
command_payload:
    {command}

query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state  
# the correct command should be zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get payload {"state": ""}
# with zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state   the Toggle Button in Maisail is still Dark
# with zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name the Toggle Button in Maisail is light

state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state
state_response_template:
     # {payload}  # I no need entire payload, only the "state" value
    {% set resp = payload|fromjson %}
    { resp["state"] }
query_after_command: true

Command_topic won't send commands to MQTT broker

If I set query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state Log will be: Zigbee2MQTT:error 2024-03-26 00:26:05: Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Friendly_name' failed: 'Error: '' not allowed, choose between: toggle,off,on because "zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state" send command without On/Off/Toggle, Ok, anyway query_topic send commands to MQTT broker.

Power Device wont send mqtt command written in command_topic & command_payload. Only query_topic: send commands but wrongly, it should send

I tried: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state

in vary combination with command_topic, query_topic and state_topic

with no results...

Client

Mainsail

Browser

Firefox

How to reproduce

zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set {command} is wrong

zigbee2mqtt need zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set { "state": "ON" } or zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state on

Additional information

[Arksine]

Without moonraker.log it isn't clear what is happening with the command topic, but I suspect the primary issue is that the device can't initialize and thus commands won't be sent. If you need to send a payload with the query topic you need to configure the query_payload option (see the docs. You can use Jinja2 to encode a dict to json if that is what is required for your zigbee client. Moonraker has some brief Jinja2 docs, and the full Jinja template documentation is available here.

[Travis90x]

Thank for your reply! Uploaded below moonraker.log and klippy.log with no usefull log

Ok, if I set command_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state command_payload: {command} query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state query_payload: toggle The Zigbee2mqtt device toggle in loop ON-OFF every 5 seconds because of query_topic that works as SET and not GET the state

But the Power button doesn't work, so I suppose that is necessary to configure correctly the query_topic that it's needed to enable command_topic

I tested with MQTTX (client mqtt)

zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get
zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get state

give me Zigbee2MQTT:error 2024-03-26 22:51:08: Invalid message 'null', skipping...

If use zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state I obtain

Zigbee2MQTT:info 2024-03-26 22:52:12: MQTT publish: topic 'zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name', payload '{"current":0,"energy":0,"indicator_mode":"off/on","linkquality":232,"over_current_breaker":"ON","over_current_threshold":65,"over_voltage_breaker":"ON","over_voltage_threshold":265,"power":0,"power_breaker":"ON","power_outage_memory":"restore","power_threshold":13,"state":"ON","temperature":26.94,"temperature_breaker":"ON","temperature_threshold":100,"under_voltage_breaker":"ON","under_voltage_threshold":75,"update":{"installed_version":-1,"latest_version":-1,"s

So I don't need query_payload, right?

Otherwise I can use it with zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get {"state": ""} I obtain the payload with MQTTX but If I set

query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get 
query_payload: {"state": ""}

The Power Button Disappear because the correct Jinja2 output should be query_payload: {'{"state": ""}'}

Correct it, Power still no work

I try query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state query_payload: state MQTTX obtain payload, But the Power button still no work

If I set state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state state_response_template: toggle Power button disappear

state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state state_response_template: state Power Button goes dark

################################### ################################### For my reminder Button Name (MQTT) goes dark: ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get state_response_template: {'{"state": ""}'} query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get query_payload: {'{"state": ""}'} ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state state_response_template: state {% set resp = payload|fromjson %} { resp["state"]|lower } ###################################
state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state state_response_template: state ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state state_response_template: ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state state_response_template: query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state query_payload: ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state state_response_template: state query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state query_payload: state ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get state_response_template: {% set resp = payload|fromjson %} { resp["state"]|lower } query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get query_payload: {'{"state": ""}'} ###################################

################################### ################################### Button Name (MQTT) goes light: ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get state_response_template: {payload} ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set state_response_template: state ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get state_response_template: {% set resp = payload|fromjson %} { resp["state"]|lower } query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state query_payload: state ################################### state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get state_response_template: {% set resp = payload|fromjson %} { resp["state"]|lower } query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state query_payload: {'{"state": ""}'}

klippy.log moonraker.log

[Arksine]

Based on the info you provided, it looks like the state_topic needs to be zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name. The state topic is the topic Moonraker subscribes to and listens for updates. The "zigbee2mqtt" client should publish all updates to this topic. If the zigbee sets the retain flag on this topic then the query_topic is optional.

Again, based on the info provided, the query_topic appears it should be zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state, with no payload.

[Travis90x]

Thank you, now it works, you earned a ko-fi The issue was the state_topic: that want "zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name" and not "zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get"

[power MQTT]
type: mqtt
command_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/set/state
command_payload: {command}
state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name
state_response_template:
    {% set resp = payload|fromjson %}
    { resp["state"] }
query_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name/get/state
query_after_command: false
locked_while_printing: true

[Travis90x]

Now I'm configuring the powermeter function with

[sensor mqtt_powermeter] type: mqtt name: Powermeter state_topic: zigbee2mqtt/Friendly_name state_response_template: {% set notification = payload|fromjson %} {set_result("power", notification["apower"]|float)} {set_result("voltage", notification["voltage"]|float)} {set_result("current", notification["current"]|float)}

But the documentation is poor to understand how show in Mainsail those sensor values.

[Arksine]

Unfortunately I can't help with setting up Mainsail, as its a separate project. Moonraker just exposes the APIs which frontend applications like Mainsail can choose to implement. I don't know if Mainsail can show data from generic sensors or how to configure it if it can.

[Arksine]

As the original issue has been resolved I'm going to close this.