`run_at` running immediately if `start` in past

[dekiesel]

What happened?

According to the documentation

If the time specified is in the past, the callback will occur the next day at the specified time.

A run with a time that lies in the past should be scheduled for the next day, but that doesn't seem to be the case.

Issue

It is 13:46 now. When I schedule this run (one minute into the future) everything works as expected: self.run_at(self.run_actions_cb, "13:47:00") But when I schedule it one minute "too late"/one minute in the past it fires immediately self.run_at(self.run_actions_cb, "13:45:00")

Am I misunderstanding the doc or should the second run be scheduled for tomorrow's 13:45?

Version

4.5.12

Installation type

Docker container

Relevant log output

Relevant code in the app or config file that caused the issue

Anything else?

No response

[dekiesel]

Slight correction, the same happens when using datetime.time

    def initialize(self):
            run_at_time_object = datetime.time.fromisoformat(run_at_time)
            self.run_at(self.run_actions, run_at_time_object)

This yields the same outcome: run_at triggers immediately when the time is in the past.

Minimal non-working example:

import hassapi as hass
from datetime import time

class TimeTriggeredActions(hass.Hass):

    def initialize(self):
        run_at_time_object = time.fromisoformat("01:00:00")
        self.log(f"{run_at_time_object=}")
        self.run_at(self.run_actions, run_at_time_object)
        self.log("initialized")

    def run_actions(self, **kwargs):
        self.log("Called run_at")

Log output:

2025-11-27 13:20:05.779307 INFO timetrigeredactionstestapp: run_at_time_object=datetime.time(1, 0)
2025-11-27 13:20:05.783002 INFO timetrigeredactionstestapp: Called run_at
2025-11-27 13:20:05.783445 INFO timetrigeredactionstestapp: initialized

[dekiesel]

Am I really the only one with this issue? Is there a workaround? Or am I just using it incorrectly?

[hugh-martin]

You are not the only one. I don't use run_at in any of my apps, but I just tested it with a run_daily callback (replacing run_daily with run_at). With run_daily and times in the past, the app does not run until the next future callback time. However, with run_at, it runs immediately.

I am also running AD v4.5.12 (via the Home Assistant add-on v0.17.12), but since I've never used run_at before, I can't say if behaved differently in earlier versions of AD in my environment.

Edit: My simple callback that reproduced your issue: self.run_at(self.warn_of_upcoming_freezing_weather, "08:00:00")

[dekiesel]

As a workaround I've created a file in helpers called time_functions.py with the following content:

from datetime import time
from datetime import datetime, date


def seconds_to(run_at_time: time | str) -> float:
    """Seconds from now() until run_at_time. Negative if run_at_time is in the past."""
    if isinstance(run_at_time, str):
        nr_delimiters = run_at_time.count(":")
        match nr_delimiters:
            case 1:
                format = "%H:%M"
            case 2:
                format = "%H:%M:%S"
            case _:
                raise ValueError(
                    f"run_at_time should contain one or two colons. Contains {nr_delimiters}"
                )
        run_at_time = datetime.strptime(run_at_time, format).time()

    now = datetime.now()
    diff = datetime.combine(date.today(), run_at_time) - now
    return diff.total_seconds()


def time_in_window(run_at_time: time | str, window_size_seconds: int) -> bool:
    """Checks if run_at_time is happening or has happened within the last `window_size_seconds` seconds.

    Example 1:
    run_at_time: 00:59:55
    now: 01:00:00
    if window_size_seconds <=5 this function will return True, otherwise false

    Example 2:
    run_at_time: 00:01:05
    now: 01:00:00
    if window_size_seconds <=5 this function will return True, otherwise false
    """
    abs_seconds = abs(seconds_to(run_at_time))
    return abs_seconds < window_size_seconds

I can then use it like this to abort the callback:

from datetime import time

import hassapi as hass
from helpers.time_functions import time_in_window


class TimeTriggeredActions(hass.Hass):

    def initialize(self):
        self.run_at_time_object = time.fromisoformat("14:52:00")
        self.log(f"{self.run_at_time_object=}")
        self.run_at(self.run_actions, self.run_at_time_object)
        self.log("initialized")

    def run_actions(self, **kwargs):

        self.log("Before check")
        if not time_in_window(self.run_at_time_object,3):
            return
        self.log("Called run_at")

"If the callback didn't happen within 3 seconds of the requested time then abort the callback".