SDRPlusPlus icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
SDRPlusPlus copied to clipboard

Rigctl client - Normal tuning mode option

Open qbg opened this issue 1 year ago • 4 comments

I want to use the rigctl_client module with my radio, but I use an SDR splitter/switch external to my rig rather than an IF tap. I want to see the signals as you normally do, but have rigctl_client sync the frequency of the demodulator to the rig.

qbg avatar Nov 09 '24 14:11 qbg

Hello. Don't hope any work about your request. I have the same request and asked Alexandre for that since more than a year. Like you and many others users, we just want to synchronize the SDR++ frequency with our radio.

Actually, I'm using ChatGPT to make a program that uses the Rigctl server of Sdr++ to grab the frequency and send it to my radio with rigctld. It works but just some minutes because rigctl server switch to idle state after a while and the only way to restart it is to close sdr++ and run it again...

I'm desperate...

David.

f4bpp avatar May 08 '25 15:05 f4bpp

Don't hope any work about your request. I have the same request and asked Alexandre for that since more than a year

I'm not your personal software developer. If you want something quickly, write it yourself, or hire someone to write it for you. You should consider yourself lucky that you're even getting 5 years of my work for free. Entitled people like you are why so many open source developers give up on their projects.

AlexandreRouma avatar May 08 '25 16:05 AlexandreRouma

Please don't misinterpret. I understand the developers' priorities and that not all our requests can be met. I awkwardly expressed the fact that this feature was never your priority, which as a developer (far from possessing your talent and skills), I can understand. I'd like to remind you that I'm a teacher and that I had requested this feature for my educational projects, as I teach technology in two French secondary schools via educational projects linked to amateur radio. I'd also like to point out that I'd offered to pay you to add this functionality. So to say that because of people like me, developers of open source projects are giving up... please don't exaggerate.

Dear qgb, I'm developing an open source python program for my Yaesu FT-847 radio to do the job. I just have a problem with the figctl server function of SDR++ which deactivates itself after about 4 minutes without any intervention on the software or launching another application. I declared an issue, but Alexandre closed it and doesn't seem willing to solve the problem. I hope that it will nevertheless be corrected and I'll gladly share my work so that all those who have been waiting for this feature can finally benefit from it because, let's not forget, under Linux, SDR++ is by far the best SDR software and I thank Alexandre again for developing it.

A last thing Alexandre : I'd like to make a donation for your work to encourage you and show you my appreciation, unlike what you mentioned, without asking for anything in return, because yes, I do the job myself and I intend to share it with the community of SDR++ users. Give me a paypal link and it's a done deal.

Peace and love, David.

f4bpp avatar May 08 '25 17:05 f4bpp

Dear Alexandre,

I apologize for having raised a bug that wasn't one As I said, I don't have your skills or talent to develop the feature I'm interested in, so I had to rely on artificial intelligence to help me. The latter was far from perfect and had produced some inappropriate code that caused rigctl to stall.

Unfortunately, when I read the issues, I realized that this problem had already been reported and I mistakenly thought that SDR++ had a bug, which is not the case.

I've now managed to code the functionality I'm so keen on, i.e. click on a frequency in SDR++'s bandscope and see it synchronized on my radio without having to use the rigctl client function and the IF frequency, which in my case needs to be adjusted on each of the amateur bands I work with.

I'll soon be making my entire code available on the Github platform after modifying it so that it's operational for all radios and not just mine as it is currently the case. That way, if anyone who has skills wants to use it as an SDR++ integrated plugin rather than an add-on program, they'll be able to do so. I don't have the skills to do it myself, as I only have a basic knowledge of Python.

So I'd like to thank Alexandre for his work, not having added this essential functionality for me, but for having produced a program that makes it possible to get with a little programming. I still offer to make a donation via Paypal to support all this amazing work. I just need a link.

Thanks a lot, David.

f4bpp avatar May 09 '25 10:05 f4bpp